Transcript 0:00 Hey, folks. It's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company. 0:12 But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question. That is, what can I do? 0:18 It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost two hundred episodes now. So here we are, The Most Important Question. 0:29 Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. [upbeat music] You know you're stressed. You know you're anxious. Do you have depression? 0:44 And do you really need to know the latest in the biology of how the brain works and depression works or doesn't work and whether the gut is involved to get meaningful help? That's today's big question. 0:59 I promise it's kinda one question, even if there's a ton of different answers, and they're gonna be different for everybody. 1:04 And this conversation is a follow-up to our last couple conversations about the brain and the gut and depression. My returning guest is Srijan Sen. 1:13 Srijan is still the Francis and Kenneth Eisenberg Professor of Depression and Neuroscientists at the University of Michigan and the director of the Francis and Kenneth Eisenberg & Family Depression Center. 1:25 His leading research focuses on the interactions between genes and the environment, and their effect on stress and anxiety and depression. And let's stop here before we get into it, our usual disclaimer, folks. 1:39 When we're talking about depression and stress and anxiety and mental health and suicide, this is a very important conversation. 1:48 It's an important one to be had, but if any of this could be triggering to you, please just skip over the next one where we talk about oceans or animals or whatever. 1:57 Nothing in this conversation, of course, should be taken as medical advice. If a treatment or some combination of treatments prescribed or recommended by your healthcare provider is working for you, huzzah, that's great. 2:09 Stay with it. Your personal experience with the treatment is much more relevant than anything in this conversation. 2:17 If you're using a depression medication or other therapy and not getting relief from your depression symptoms, talk with your healthcare provider. 2:25 And finally, of course, if you are struggling and feeling distress or that you might hurt yourself, you can text or call the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline at nine eight eight. That's nine eight eight right now to get help. 2:38 And you can even call and press three to speak to a counselor with The Trevor Project, our friends, the nonprofit who provide wonderful support for LGBTQ+ folks. Welcome to Important Not Important. 2:51 [upbeat music] My name is Quinn Emmett, and this is science for people who really, really give a shit. 2:56 In these weekly conversations, I take a deep dive with an incredible human, like Srijan, who's working truly on the front lines of the future, where there's so many questions and so much possibility in an effort to build a radically better today and tomorrow for everyone. 3:12 Our mission is to understand and help them unfuck the future. Our goal is to help you answer the question, what can I do? Srijan, welcome back to the show. 3:29 Welcome back. Thanks for having me. Glad to be back. Uh, you are welcome, man. Uh, I'm so glad it's starting to get a little warmer there for ya. 3:36 Seventy degrees yesterday, which is amazing for, for the beginning- That's wild... of March. Yeah. Now, I don't wanna dive into climate stuff 'cause it makes me, uh, wanna have another mental health conversation. 3:46 But from what I understand, like, not a bad winter there. No, no, no. The little-known upsides of climate change are- [sighs]... seen in- I know... [chuckles] in, uh, in Arbor in January and February. 3:57 But yes, it, it wasn't a bad winter. I have m- made this, like, semi-gallows humor joke, uh, a few, a few times, 4:08 m- maybe not to you, but, you know, it's, it's very easy to be with people, friends, family, whoever, but really, like, children who so innocently [chuckles]... 4:18 I know I'm in Downham, Virginia, and it's, it's very mild anyways. Like, we get hot, sticky summers, but it's not Alabama. We get cold winters, but it's not Central New York- Right... where we lived. 4:26 Um, but you know, it's very easy for someone in December, January to be like, "Wow, what a nice day. Can you believe it?" And I'm just like, "Don't say it." Like, don't, don't ruin this for them. 4:39 They don't wanna talk about it right now. They don't wanna know right now. You don't wanna talk about it right now. Uh, but at the same time, it's, like, the most important thing we can do. 4:47 But I'm like, "Can we just take a day off, bud?" Yeah. Yes. So anyways. Yeah. No, no. I, yes. I, I, I agree. [chuckles] Sorry for, sorry for bringing it there. No, no, no. It's fine. 4:56 Like, I asked the question, but it is, it's one of those things where, you know, a- again, you, you want people to feel like, "Oh, this is w- uh, weather's so interesting. Isn't it wonderful? And we're not freezing." 5:04 Like, I get it, man. I lived in Central New York for five years. Like- Yes... holy cow, it's relentless. Right. If you get a warm winter, great. Right. 5:11 It'd just be superb if they weren't all going to be warmer than this one, basically. Yes. Um, so. Yes. So but you know, it was a warm winter. But yeah, hard to do any, you know, 5:22 snow activities like skiing or, or- Yeah... uh, sledding. There was, there was so little snow. Um. That's crazy. But it's a, it's a, it's, you know... 5:31 But it's, it's getting to spring, and that's always a really nice time of year around here. We'll take it. What's your spring sport? I know fall is football. Anything, uh, you're latched onto? 5:41 Getting nice enough to play basketball outside, which is nice. So I was just, you know, playing with my seven-year-old and, and people in the neighborhoods and stuff. So, um, so it's fun. 5:51 And then I, I like to run and, and transitioning from the treadmill to running in the parks now the last, last couple weeks, which is nice. Real talk. 5:59 How long until your seven-year-old can start to make some inroads on your game? Like, how long until you've gotta actually start putting in work to keep up?'Cause I'm way past that basically with my 11-year-old. 6:11 I, I still talk shit, but it's not... If I had to stand up, it wouldn't be great. I haven't figured out in basketball. Still a little ways, but we were placing, um, sort of, um, bets on the running part and like- Mm... 6:24 when he's gonna beat me in like a 5K and, you know, sort of over-under of like four years it, it looks like. Um. Mm-hmm. 6:33 Uh, definitely in like, you know, throwing football around, there's like short area quickness that he's like just blows by me, but then- Oh, no... 6:39 you know, I could still, I could still go faster th- than him in, in, you know, longer distances, but that, the, the time is ticking for that. Yeah. 6:47 The, the stop-start stuff, I always like I see some of the things they do on fields and I'm like my groin would just pull right off the bone if I tried to do something like that, or my knees would- Yes... 6:55 dissolve like, uh, at the end of m- Avengers. Um- Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Same thing. I think I'm up in the lot now like longer than I'd actually run 'cause- A hu- 100%. 7:04 The number of like rollout devices and things I have, um, this is all connected to mental health, folks, believe me, because if I don't- Yes, yes... do this, I go, I, I lose it. 7:13 But anyways, it's definitely like the days are coming. I, I get it. Um, yeah. Yes. It's, it's not- Yeah... it's not great. It's not great. But it's, yeah, it's fun to see, fun to see the kids. It's fun to see. 7:23 I do anticipate a day where I will be challenged, and I will have to decide if I'm gonna like leave my body on the field to win this one last whatever it is. Yeah, real- And what the repercussions of that are, you know? 7:36 Yeah. Or if I just let them finally have it. I don't know. I don't know. No, no, that's a glorious way to go out and then... Right? That's it. Yeah. All right. Um, so thank you for coming back. 7:45 Uh, i- the last episode was, was meaningful to me, and I got a lot out of it, and I think a lot of folks got a lot out of it 'cause a lot of folks are dealing with not just their own situations, but seeing it in their friends, in their family, young people all over the place, uh, older people all over the place, and it can be caused by any number of things, even if it's not depression, there is anxiety. 8:08 There's all kinds of different flavors of this. Um, I've certainly got my own versions of it. Yeah. 8:14 I, I really enjoyed the discussion and, and thought about points you made afterwards and heard from other people, so it was a, it was a really- Oh... great discussion- Well, that's kind of you. 8:22 My children don't think about anything I say to them, so that's great. I say it, and their just eyes glaze over like a shark. It'll, it'll come back to them. In 20 years, they're gonna be like- Right... 8:30 that, that thing you had- When they're in therapy for themselves. Yeah. 8:32 [laughs] Um, I think what was immediately evident to, to, to both of us was, oh, we, we can do 10 more of these but in a slightly more specific version, which I'm, I'm excited to do because obviously you are working on this every day, where I'm just reading books and, and making up ideas. 8:46 Just to set the tone a little bit, so as we discussed a little bit more broadly in the first conversation, it is fortunately and unfortunately quite the [chuckles] moment for mental health, right? Um, 8:58 I've been trying to think about the right way to frame this without it being way off b- base because again, like l- l- moronic liberal arts major here, but- [laughs]... 9:08 m- it seems like more people are suffering than have ever actually been really reported before, and for a wide variety of reasons. Now, part of that, again, sort of analogies like 9:20 is there an element of that that's like cancer, where we have so much more earlier detection? Is there less stigma, so we're... 9:26 I mean, not no stigma certainly, but where we're talking about it more, especially men talking about it more. But there's obviously all these other reasons more people are suffering. 9:35 We've seen how mental health for young people has gone downhill since phones basically, 2012, and COVID and all of these things, climate anxiety. Um- Yeah. 9:44 But along those lines, we also know more than [chuckles] again, like pl- frozen concert, it seems like we know more than we've ever known about, um, the environmental, which you, you have dove into, the genetic and, uh, other biological reasons and chemical influences on mental health. 10:00 But a- again, as we've talked about before, and I did another conversation about, uh, the brain and the gut access and how we're pulling those things apart. We're trying to. 10:09 Knowing more means [chuckles] understanding we really don't know- Yes... what to know or as much as we think, which is exciting and also unnerving depending on who's listening or reading the headlines, right? Right. 10:19 So, um, before we get going, I, I do wanna do one thing, which is you're, you're so thoughtful about all this, so I think you'll understand. 10:29 Like climate change, obviously, as Katherine Hayhoe says, it's important that we talk about this more and more and more, right? But it's also important how we talk about it. 10:39 I'm trying to keep in mind like who is listening to this. Um, so many people dealing with these things. So 10:47 as we try to get more men to speak up and share their journey, or at least to be supportive, to seek help, especially with friendships going down, um, 10:55 I saw some research in the conversation from like 2022, and they said, "Although viewing depression as a biological disorder may seem like it would reduce stigma, in fact, research has shown the opposite, and also that people who believe their own depression is due to a chemical imbalance are more pessimistic about their chances of recovery." 11:14 So I just wanna take a moment, and let's talk about how we talk about this. 11:19 Like how do we and why do we have to be so careful about how we talk about the biological and chemical and environmental underpinnings of depression and anxiety? Does that make sense? Yeah. Yeah. 11:29 I think it's important to think about how we talk about it and do it in a, in a, a thoughtful way that, that helps people. I, I think it's important to stick to... 11:39 A- as scientists, I feel like our role is to try to get to the truth. And, and so that, I think that's important and then finding the right way to discuss it. 11:47 But, but discussing it in a truthful, straightforward way is important rather than trying to... 11:53 I think especially as a psychiatrist, sometimes we get caught up in framing it in different ways to, that, that might come across better, and we're really bad at predicting how, what framing is gonna work and what isn't. 12:04 Mm-hmm. Um, at least I am. 12:05 So I think, um, being honest about what we know and what we don't know, uh, sets us up well to, um, to have people feel part of the, the process of understanding, um, that helps them and empowers them to help others. 12:19 I think, um, w-The other point that, that might be related is, is, um, depression and anxiety and mental health is a little different than cancer and other things we've talked about in that 12:34 how much we think about it probably affects it in- Hmm... in ways that, you know, um, that is not true for cancer. Sure. 12:43 And I don't think we know the answers here, but, but there is probably, you know, anecdotally, I, I've seen friends, patients, myself sometimes ruminating about depression, talking about it more internally, um, to a lesser extent externally, um, ah, can, can make it worse and, and some of the best... 13:06 Different people are different, situations are different, but- Sure... um, but certainly at sometimes the best thing to do is to go out and do something, um, uh- Sure... s- go socialize, go for a run, um- Right... 13:21 and, and that will help your mental health more than thinking about it for another hour. Um- Sure... 13:26 but figuring out when the-- what the right balance is of how much to think about it, how much to talk about it and not is, is fuzzy and probably different from situation to situation. Thank you for that. 13:38 And I know you-- I, I know we hadn't really talked about that side of it, but I really thought about it this morning. 13:43 Like, you know, I, uh, know children who are dealing with a lot of mental health stuff, which is heartbreaking because you're just like, uh, you, you barely understand an- anything at this point, much less your emotions, or how do you explain the chemicals? 13:59 Actually, it's not chemicals, but scientists are arguing [chuckles] that it might be. It's like... I thought about, you know, how during COVID, I, you know, I, I don't say post-COVID, we're still very late COVID. 14:12 There's so many people still dealing with it, and will deal with it. But in that first two years, how we basically did science live, right? 14:21 And all the pros and cons of that, and what that has meant in the aftermath now, and how that really screwed with people in a lot of ways, um, if they weren't ready to handle it. 14:31 But also, a lot of the scientists weren't ready to... They didn't train for media training or anything like that. 14:37 They just happened to have a Twitter account, and they woke up and they're like, "I have four hundred thousand followers, like, I have to be careful." Right. 14:42 And that's-- You can be really careful and still look up six months later and be like, "Okay, it turns out like hand washing really actually didn't really do much for this specific thing. 14:50 But if you don't want norovirus, please use soap and water." You know, it's, it's hard to do it live, and it's hard to, 14:57 I imagine, on your side from the research perspective and as a practicing psychiatrist, like to think about, again, for each person, like we were saying with, like, do I tell them the, the winter is warm because of climate change? 15:08 Like, how do you constantly readjust doing this live knowing that, again, and we'll get into it, like, 15:16 everyone is arguing again over the serotonin theory and whether those SSRI are even doing anything, or if they would do something for someone else but not you. 15:23 Like, h-how do you constantly deal with, I guess, this just changing landscape when you're talking to people? 15:30 It's a challenge, and I, I'm glad you brought up COVID, and I think that's a good example on doing it in real time. 15:37 I think scientists got in trouble or, or went wrong, or we went wrong in science in-- from both political directions in trying to frame things to get people to behave in ways we, we wanted, rather than just explaining the, the facts as we knew it at the time- Right... 15:54 with the caveat that, that this is changing day to day, and- Yeah... we might think something differently. 16:00 And also got really attached to our, um, the theories that we came up with on, you know, whatever it is, March 5th, um, twenty twenty- Yeah... and then we have a lot more data three months later- Sure... 16:11 but still sticking to... And that's a problem we have, uh, in science and, and broadly, and, and I think that applies to, to, um, serotonin things and, and all other parts of science. 16:24 Um, so trying to be open to changing minds and changing, um, directions if new evidence comes that way. 16:31 And then also being honest on what we know, um, without trying to think about how that will affect, you know, patients' behaviors on, on what-- whether they take a medication or not, um- Sure... 16:44 uh, and not trying to frame things 'cause we're not, we're not that smart and, and- [chuckles] Yeah... and really bad at, at predicting how people- Sure... will take things. Yeah. So, um, yeah. 16:54 So I think, I think that's, um, that-- that's at least how I approach it, and there's, there's, um, pros and cons to that. 17:00 And I think it, uh, it, it is really relevant to, um, uh, to how we approach depression because still what-- and depression treatments, i-it's still what we don't know vastly, um, outweighs what we do know. 17:17 Um, so as you mentioned, we know a good amount and, and more than we did twenty years ago, but, um, but everything we find uncovers ten other things that we don't know. Right. 17:29 Um, and, and, um, probably when we look back on, you know, in twenty fifty at this conversation in twenty twenty-four, a lot of what I say is gonna sound really silly. Sure. 17:41 So being humble and knowing that, setting things up in ways that, that account for that, I think is important. I appreciate that. 17:47 I, I think, you know, that candid, informed humility, like objective, informed, [chuckles] like humility, that everything is gonna keep changing is helpful both to look at, like our moment in time. 18:01 Again, like it's easy to have this retrospective about the, the first half of COVID at least and go like, "Look at everything we did wrong. We could have done better." It's like, uh, maybe. 18:10 Yet there were definitely some good actors and definitely some bad actors, and so many people caught in between. 18:14 And it's almost-They're gonna murder me, but it's almost as if climate scientists have it easy because as much as, like, weather impacts have been getting crazy and, and the temperatures have been going up in various places and the ocean is, is, is like a boiling pot of water, it's actually basically followed the exact predictions, uh, of the models so far, which it won't always, uh, pros and cons. 18:35 But they go like, "But no, this is what we said," which must be nice, right? Uh, th- [laughs] that's not really the way, uh, the serotonin theory [laughs] has gone so far. 18:43 Let, let's dig into this 'cause, 'cause it's been a little bit, and I think it's really interesting. So I wanna offer my first caveat in the sense that, again, we need to talk about this more. I came... 18:52 I don't even remember. Our first conversation was late last year or something like that. I had some just enormous stressors in my life, still do, things like that. 19:00 So I started Prozac for the first time, um, and then actually, uh, uh, eventually doubled it 'cause it wasn't doing the job. I found this incredible psychiatrist who's been very helpful, very much, uh- That's great... 19:13 in my face about things, which is the way it should, which is what I've always looked for. [laughs] Um, I've had just listeners, which is great for some people. 19:19 I need someone who's, like, gonna call me on my bullshit pretty daily- [laughs]... 'cause that's really helpful. He was like, "Your narrative is great. None of that, uh, i- like, is applicable here, buddy. Nice try." 19:28 [laughs] It's, it's really great. So we're doing the Prozac, but I've also got, um, uh, and correct me where I'm, I'm, I'm wrong here again because I'm, I'm, I, I was a religion major, but, uh, it's Klonopin, Clonazepam. 19:40 Would... Are, are they the same thing? I don't know. They're the same thing. I- Yeah, the, uh, uh, generic and, like- Great... brand names for- Good talk. 19:46 Anyways, I've got a package of 50 of them, little dissolvable guys. Goes under the tongue when I need them, when my children ask too many questions- [laughs]... when I think about all the open loops in my life. 19:56 And it was a long time before I really thought, like, okay, I th- I think m- my exercise, as much as it's clearly helpful, is like, and my meditation is, like, not actually cutting it at this point- Mm-hmm... 20:08 'cause there's just too much. Um- And it's been helpful, the, the, the- It's, it's been really helpful... adding on meditation. Yeah. The, the thing I described to him was... 20:16 Listen, I tried to use, like, a really practical example, knowing that, like, again, you don't get rid of anxiety. You don't get rid of stress. You don't want to. 20:23 But I said, "In the mornings when I'm getting my kids ready, they u- usually come down full of joy, excited to see me, all these things, and then I generally basically ruin it for them by b- [laughs]... 20:34 telling them to clean up their dishes and all this stuff, and I get increasingly stressed." I said, "I'm definitely, like, a f- I'm, like, a four to five out of 10 most mornings." 20:42 And I was like, "That, I don't get this time with them back. That is an unacceptable range to me. Tell me whatever it is I have to do to get to six to seven. No one's looking for eight here. Like, that's- Mm-hmm... 20:54 father of the year territory, and I'm not gonna get it." Yeah. And he was like, "Okay. Well, let's double... Make sure you're doing your exercise and not feeling bad you're taking time to do that. Do these things." 21:02 He's like, "But let's also try these pharmaceuticals 'cause who knows? 21:05 But you've never done it, and it could just, again, give you a little nudge and maybe help you sleep better, which can increase the whole thing," et cetera, et cetera. So- Yeah... 21:13 anyways, that has been my journey so far. Again, it's not perfect, but it's been really- That's great... really helpful. This isn't your point, but I- Please... 21:19 um, for our research studies, and so I've been doing it too, like, we ask people to, like, rate their mood on a scale of one to 10 each day. Yeah. 21:27 Um, and I find that really helpful in, like, um, at, at least identifying for myself when I'm in a three or four mood and when I'm in a- Yeah... six to seven mood. I've yet to get to, like, nine or 10. 21:39 It's like, what are you transcendent? Like, good luck. Right. Yes. [laughs] Yeah. I had- And, uh- You know, I've, and I'm been doing the Apple Watch things where they're like, "Hey- Yeah... how's it going today?" 21:46 And, and, and all that. And I'm always just like- Right... "Ah." But- Right... hopefully it's a little less like that. Again, I can't- Yeah... change what I do. I mean, I guess I, I could. 21:54 I can't change that I have three kids, and I wouldn't change that either or stop their questions, 'cause one day they will stop asking me questions. I don't want that either. Right. But how do I... 22:04 If the only way out is through, like, how do I make the through a little easier so I can be- Yeah... better self, partner, husband, dad- Right... all that stuff. So anyways. 22:13 But with, uh, with patients, it's, we've been able to see much more, um, like, when they're doing daily moods, like, you know, you see, like, four weeks after they start their Prozac, there is a uptick in their mood. 22:24 They go from more four days to more six days, or for some people they're not. It, it's much easier to catch that than trying to think back, like- Oh, yeah... "What was my mood like in December, and is it- Yeah... 22:36 better now?" Is, like, we're really bad at, at doing that. So, so I'm an advocate of trying to keep track on some kinda numerical scale- It's amazing... um, so that we can tell. 22:45 And then like, oh, you know, things got, you know, something, you know, I started a new job and- Sure... seeing if, if things are better or worse or, or, um, you know, uh, uh, things like that. 22:56 So, so I'm, I'm glad that you and your psychiatrist are talking about it in that way. Yeah. I mean, the retrospective stuff just d- never cuts it, right? We're humans. We're... 23:04 I don't, I don't remember what I had for breakfast much less, like, how- Yeah... I was feeling yesterday other than, like, I don't know. 23:08 I'd probably discount it and be like, "It was probably a five when maybe I had some six times." So- Right. Right... I don't know. Hey, parents. 23:14 You know that moment when your kid is asking you something for the 47th time while you're trying to make three different breakfasts, pack lunches, and figure out if your house insurance is about to get canceled because of climate change? 23:25 And all you can say is, "Not right now." I'm Quin Emmett, founder and host of Important Not Important. And I'm Claire Zuelke, writer and producer of the Evil Witches Substack newsletter. 23:35 And we're here to talk about, generally, with tears often, parenting in these absolutely just crazy times. 23:42 Every week we're having honest conversations about raising kids while trying to stay somewhat sane, whether that's debating screen time- Explaining wildfire evacuations, and what fascism is, and why couze has a P in it... 23:56 surviving another parent-teacher conference and behavioral reflection forms... [laughs] or just trying to get everyone to eat something other than dinosaur-shaped nuggets, which by the way, are delicious. 24:06 We're not here to tell you how to be the perfect parent. We're here to remind you that you're not alone in this chaos. 24:12 Join us for our new show, Not Right Now, a show for parents who know that loving your kids and wanting to hide from them in the pantry can both be true at the same time. 24:22 Because we're all just trying our best while googling, "Is this normal?" in our bathrooms at 3:00 AM. Not Right Now, new episodes every Thursday wherever you get your podcasts. 24:31 So let's talk about-What has been going on here on the pharmacological side? So, uh, twenty twenty-two, 24:39 this sort of, I don't know if you'd call it a meta-study, study of studies, claims depression is probably not only caused by at least this chemical imbalance in the brain. 24:47 And the quote from the nature, uh, piece is, "The main areas of serotonin research provide no consistent evidence of there being an association between serotonin and depression, and no support for the hypothesis that depression is caused by lowered serotonin activity or concentrations." 25:03 And of course, this is interesting for a variety of reasons, but also because SSRIs are designed to at least raise serotonin levels, right? 25:12 Shortly after, thirty-six other researchers criticized those findings, saying there were methodological weaknesses in the review process, selective reporting of data, oversimplification, and errors in the interpretation of neuropsychopharmacological findings. 25:26 That's all great. I hope they work it out for everyone's benefit. But on the user end, it comes down to this, and again, correct me if I'm wrong, which is it seems like SSRIs work for some folks. 25:38 Some for really well, others not at all or not so much. We aren't a hundred percent sure why or why not. Ignoring the other treatments and things we can do, what is the latest with serotonin theory? 25:50 What does that mean for treatments now when going forward? I'm peripherally involved in some of the, uh, controversies and discussions- Please... 25:57 and have had conversations with authors of that meta-analysis and/or umbrella review, as they called it. Sure. And, and, and there, there are like ten different aspects and angles to it. Oh, I'm sure. 26:10 Uh, for me, one of the most important is that how we as doctors and patients decide on a treatment shouldn't, should not be related, um, very closely or I, I think at all to the mechanism of... 26:26 the biological mechanism of how it works. 26:28 Even outside of mental health and the brain and things we understand pretty well, you know, why we use statins to, um, uh, reduce the risk of heart attacks and strokes is not because we know exactly, um, what molecule the, the statins are interacting with and how that results. 26:48 We know a l- definitely we know more about that than we know about SSRIs, but- Sure... 26:53 the reason is that in, in clinical trials, it's been shown to reduce heart attacks and- The out- the, the hopeful outcome is there and there's, you know, it w- there were enough trials and clearly enough people are on statins [chuckles] in the world to know that like the, the side firks, side effects- Right... 27:07 whatever they may be, are not adverse enough to keep it off the shelf. Right. Right. And the same for, for, uh, you know, chemotherapeutic drugs. And it's, it's- Sure... 27:15 not based on like th- we have this incredibly cool mechanism. Um, the trials show it doesn't actually, you know, reduce the cancer, but like, we like the mechanism. Like, that's not how medicine should work. Sure. 27:28 Um, and, and hopefully it doesn't. 27:30 And so the reason we use SSRIs, um, and other depression and anxiety and, and, um, antipsychotic drugs is, is because of the clinical trials, um, which weren't at all involved in this umbrella review. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. 27:45 The, the clinical trials show, as you've, um, discussed, um, that, um, SSRIs help reduce depression, anxiety in a, uh, not in all patients and, and, and not nearly in as many as we'd want, but work better than, than placebo in, in the overall assessment of, of, of studies. 28:06 They don't work that much better than placebo. 28:08 Um, placebo works for a good number of people and, and SSRIs work a little bit better than them and, and as, as we've all, you know, seen and heard, there's a lot of people who don't respond well to, to Prozac and Zoloft and, um, the other SSRIs, but some people do and, and they should continue to take them. 28:26 So I think the authors, I, I take issue with them conflating the, the research onto the biological mechanisms onto whether people should take the drug or, or not. 28:39 I think the authors of that and, and I and others, uh, no one disputes, I think, that exercising a lot or exercising the right amount, m- um, exercising better than not exercising is good for mental health, um, or sleeping eight hours a night is good for- Sure... 28:57 mental health. We have no idea about the biological mechanism of how, you know, going for a bike ride, um, improves your... We don't know if it's serotonin or dopamine or what parts of the brain or the muscles and how... 29:11 We-- But, but I don't think anyone doubts that, that it works. But it does it. The same as... S-sorry, go ahead. No, I'm saying that it, that it, it does work, right? It does work. Yeah. 29:20 So we, we know from studies it does work. And the same for, you know, cogni- therapy, cognitive therapy and mindfulness- Sure... and meditation. Um, we have good evidence from clinical trials that they work. Um, 29:32 we don't-- we know even less about the bio... They're working by definition through biology. It's, you know, doing- Sure... 29:40 meditation for, for, we know, uh, uh, we've studied monks and, and even normal people when they go through meditation and mindfulness training, how their brain changes, and we're starting to learn more and more about that and how that changes even your blood pressure and, and- Mm-hmm... 29:56 and certainly changes your anxiety and depression. But we don't really know what, what neurotransmitters are changed and what circuits are changed in the brain. 30:05 But so I think the, the holding the medications to a different standard than other interventions for, uh, for mechanisms isn't fair. 30:15 We should keep all the things in our arsenal and, and use whatever works for whatever person, um, to get them better. I think the understanding the biology is really interesting. 30:24 It's interesting to me as a scientist, and hopefully will get us to a point where we can, um, develop new interventions that work better and new treatments. 30:33 Uh, but, but I don't think it should influence how we think about our own treatments today. I think that'sIncredibly reasonable. Again, it can, it can all be applicable. 30:44 It can, uh, you know, you can consider the whole thing and go further to other, uh, like, lifestyle things like, you know, in our previous conversation we talked about your work on residents and doctors and, 30:55 um, things like that. Um, but again, understanding that we're doing a lot of this live, um, because the more we pick apart the brain and the gut, the more we're just like, "Oh, f- okay. [laughs] Great. 31:10 No idea where this goes. Let's find out." 31:12 But knowing that, again, you know, I have-- I definitely have people in my life who are dealing with a lot of long-standing issues that may or may not be exasperated by long COVID. 31:22 Um, you know, it's easy to say like, "Have you figured out what it is?" It's like it's probably closer to what are they, and all the different pieces and levers. You know, it's like a Rube Goldberg machine at this point. 31:32 At the same time, understanding again that, like, we just only know so much. And so, you know, when I talk about this with them, we try to separate in parallel where we can, um, separate relieving symptoms, right, and 31:47 trying to understand what a cause is, if we can even find that, if it's something that can even be controlled in some way, right? Like it's, it's pretty easy to back up and go like, "Hey bud, you're just... 31:58 You're not getting any sleep." You know? That... Not that that's necessarily the root cause of something, but it's pretty easy to go like, "Oh, that's a symptom and a cau- a potential cause type of thing." Mm-hmm. 32:06 But for a lot of people, it, it will not be, right? Those will be two different things. Mm-hmm. 32:11 So we do try to separate those out, going like, "Look, at least if we can find things that relieve your symptoms but that do not have two adverse side effects, we're not gonna make the cause worse or whatever it is, great." 32:23 You know? Um, this show, my work, um, we, we try very hard to not, uh, barter in snake oil of any sort. 32:30 There's so much pop psychology stuff that is a nightmare, and so much correlation where causation isn't even considered. Uh, it's a nightmare. Yeah. 32:38 But, um, there is something too, like you're saying, going, oh, we got the monks in the MRI machine and going like, look, meditation's not for [laughs] everybody. 32:47 It can be a real pain in the ass, or you can fall asleep, all of these things. But if it helps, it is not gonna hurt you. It's like acupuncture, right? Yeah. It's like we've been doing it for three thousand years. 32:56 Like it's not... You're, you're gonna be fine. But you also might be a little better than fine. 33:00 And it seems like with the prevalence of most SSRIs, I mean, again, like how many billions of people have taken them in some form- Right... 33:10 and for how long that we know, again, yes, there are side effects and, and they're different for everybody, which is kind of why almost like the birth control pill, like you gotta find what works for you. 33:18 Um, but they could help, and along the way, folks like you are gonna keep trying to figure out ex- exactly how they work and why they work for some people and not, right? Right. That's exactly right. 33:29 And, and I think the... It's important to n- know that they weren't really designed... It wasn't like someone thought that, "I think serotonin's important. 33:39 We're gonna develop this drug to target that and then, um, see if it works in depression." It was more that 33:49 there were a few different lines, but like, you know, um, anti-tuberculosis, people were giving tuberculosis treatments and noticed people taking these meds seemed a little happier, and then trying to reverse engineer what it is, what is about this, this tuberculosis treatment that's helping mood and then, and then find other drugs that kind of seem similar. 34:11 It was mostly from finding medications that worked and then, and giving them, rather than understanding anything about the mechanism, um, that, that led to it. 34:21 And, and that's true for a lot of the other depression treatments as well. You know, there's a lot of interest these days about, um, ketamine and psilocybin and, and- Sure... 34:31 these are older, uh, psychedelics that we also don't really know the mechanisms of. 34:36 There's, there's lots of interesting work going on in animal studies in trying to understand what receptors they, they work on, what parts of the brain, but they're incredibly, um, uh, uh, broad drugs that, that affect lots and lots of different things and, and, um, we don't know why they help, why they affect our, our, our thinking and our mental health. 35:00 But, um, but it's more that they probably do, and trying to understand how they do is, is interesting. But more I, I, I tend to, in terms of patient decisions, try to go to the clinical trials and understand w- who... 35:13 That whether they work and then get to, you know, who they might work for much more than trying to understand the mechanisms in, in making individual, um, decisions on treatment. 35:24 Well, it really is like two parallel paths, right? And, and, and 35:28 again, people in my life, it's, it's, it's easy to go to a first grade teacher and say like, "H- how, oh, how are you not keeping up with the latest on, on the mental faculties of how first graders work?" 35:42 And they're like, "Well, I'm paid twenty thousand dollars a year and I spend my day with five-year-olds. I don't have the time for that." 35:47 And it could same, could be said for, like, the very few primary physicians we have left, right? 35:52 Which is like, sure, it'd be great if, like, your doctor was a nerd who went home and, and studied this stuff, but w- their job is to help people feel better ev- each and every day, right? Right. 36:00 They don't have the time or the bandwidth to do that, or honestly, in the US, like the incentive to do that, right? Um- Yeah... it's surgery or, or not, basically. At the same time, it is. It's, it, it's... 36:12 I guess it's important to have that... 36:15 I just keep coming back to this idea of like we're doing it live, but how do we share that in, in, in a, again, a, a candid way that still makes people feel solid about what they're doing? 36:26 And ag- I, I always come back to... And there's the big example we'll talk about [laughs] in a second. 36:31 Um, but I always come back to like what, like you were saying, in twenty-five years, we're gonna look back and be like, "Holy shit, can you believe someone said that? You know, it's crazy." 36:38 And chemotherapy is always the one I think of, which is like someday we're gonna look back and be likeJesus, that was our first option for how long? For how many people? 36:46 Like, the world's bluntest instrument is often worse than the cancer itself, but it's also what we've got right- Yeah... now. You know? Immunotherapy's really cool. Also really doesn't work for a lot of people. 36:57 [laughs] We're not 100% sure why. 36:59 The big one on the block, and, and I think this probably applies to mental health too, 'cause it seemingly applies to everything, is these, the weight loss drugs, Ozempic, et cetera, et cetera. Um, 37:09 every week we're finding out more and more what they do, and we really don't know, [laughs] don't know why. Um, and there's some positives and negatives there maybe. We- we're not sure. But 37:19 it doesn't mean it hasn't improved so many people's lives in a huge way. It's amazing, and there's so many interesting directions and, and, and consequences of Ozempic and that class of drugs. 37:31 Um, but the profound effect it has on obesity and, and, um, and, and diabetes is, is incredible. And, um, certainly there seems like there's some side effects and- Of course... 37:43 muscle loss and overall that, that, that seems really positive. And there seems to be interesting inter- intersections with, um, behavior and mental health too in, in- Yeah... 37:53 particularly around, um, addiction and, and maybe on, on mood and, and in, in different ways. 37:59 So, you know, seeing how that plays out's gonna be fascinating and also, you know, I think, um, how it affects I- I think in a sense we thought of obesity and how much we eat as somewhat of a moral or ethical question, and seeing how much it changes. 38:17 And I think there's some aspects of that in mental health as well, and how much a new type of drug completely transforms something that seemed somewhat mystical into, like, a purely, like, practical thing is, is, is interesting. 38:33 And, and I hope, I hope that we have incredibly effective drugs that 90% of people with depression respond to in, in, in five years or 10 years- Yeah... 38:43 and, and a lot of these philosophical questions, um, a- are no longer philosophical questions. Sure. And I love the phil- philosophical questions. Like, I'm again- Yeah... a l- liberal arts major who barely graduated. 38:55 Long story, but, uh, uh, I am... 38:57 Like, when I look at these tech companies and [laughs] rolling out AI, AI, AI, they're, they're incredible, gonna change the world, but I've always believed that these companies should have a, like, chief 39:07 should we really fucking do this officer, like, in their C-suite, someone who is liberal arts- Yeah... who, who's like, "Who gets to ask the questions? Why do they get to ask the questions? 39:15 Who's this gonna affect, uh, adversely or not? Who's, who's incentivized to do this? Who's gonna benefit? Do we really have to make money this way?" 39:22 Like, that's all really helpful, and when you have like, uh, I think it's Ozempic who, uh, is it out of the N- Netherlands? Where? I can't remember which country it's out of- Yeah, I think so... 39:31 where it's like it has changed their GDP for the past, like, 18 months, [laughs] like completely- Right... 'cause it's so crazy. And all that's great. We should keep asking those questions. 39:39 You know, I saw, um, an article this week, I can't remember where it was, talking about, um, how, uh, pregnant women have started taking it, um, because there's a lot of weight gain, and that can feel horrible. 39:53 Um, again, this can be an entirely different conversation, but, you know, 39:58 some do- scientists and doctors are like, "Well, hold on though, we don't know what that's gonna do to the placenta and the fetus in delivery and, and afterwards and brain health and all that." 40:08 My first comment would be, like, we don't study pregnant women as it is, which is a nightmare in itself, so, uh, we could, [laughs] we could start there. 40:15 Uh, but you have to empathize with why they might wanna try it certainly, um, when you hear all this about it. 40:20 But again, it doesn't mean it's not helping people along the way, and we-- doesn't mean we can't keep asking questions along the way. Yes. Yeah. But keeping those on... 40:29 Yeah, keeping both those tracks going, but not interacting in unhealthy ways I think is important. Unless there are... I mean, look, red flags come up, and you pull something off the market. 40:38 Like, it's-- wouldn't be the first time we've done that sort of thing. It's just it requires intentionality I think. Um, let's talk about the non-pharmacological things because there is, there are things people can do. 40:49 Obviously in the last conversation we talked a lot about sleep, and everyone has heard so much shit about sleep hygiene. It's not that complicated. You can use a watch to track it if you want, but you get the idea. 40:59 It's kinda like tracking your food if, you know, if you're able to. After a week you're like, "No, I got it." Yeah. "I got it." Yeah. [laughs] "I know, I know what I'm doing here." Right. Um, let's talk about exercise. 41:09 Tell me about for folks who are able to exercise, which obviously is a pretty broad term, how do we know that this helps? What does it help with, and are there sort of measurable 41:22 10,000 steps type stuff, um, where people can go like, "This is the sort of thing maybe I could adopt to complement or be in place of or whatever my mental health regimen"? Yeah. 41:34 I think starting with tying it all together with the medications- Sure... there are a lot of... There's SSRIs. There, there are, you know, um, many different types of SSRIs. 41:45 There's other ones that are close to that, like SNRIs that are slightly different and other classes of medications. 41:52 There are, there are therapies that we, you know, have, have mostly heard of, like cognitive therapy and mindfulness- Sure... and interpersonal therapy. 42:00 Um, and they all kind of work probably something like 40%, 50% of people respond to any of them, but it's a different one that, that different people respond to. 42:12 And, and, and right now people tend to go through lots of trial and error. Uh, some people are lucky and the first thing they try works. 42:22 Um, some people have to go through four medications and, and three therapies before finding what works or what combination works, and some people none of the conventional ones we have work. 42:32 And we don't really have a good way of figuring out what's gonna work for what person and- What your cocktail's gonna be. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. 42:39 And, and so we're doing work and other groups are doing work to try to see if anythingUm, from people's histories or how they're thinking now or, or some of their wearable data or genetics or other things can help, help us identify, 42:54 you know, you're really gonna-- you're likely to respond to Prozac, or you're likely to really do well with, uh, with mindfulness or- Mm-hmm. Or psilocybin, right? Exactly. Right. 43:05 Or, or you-- these things are probably not gonna work for you, and you're probably gonna need, you know, um, uh, uh, ketamine or, or- Mm-hmm... electroconvulsive therapy- Mm-hmm... 43:15 and not going through five years of, of trial and error and just skipping to that. We're not there yet, but we, we, um, uh, we're, we're hoping to get there. Mm-hmm. 43:24 And the same kind of thing I think applies to, um, uh, to things we don't consider typically as part of the, um, uh, the typical regimen of things that, that a doctor would prescribe, but are effective treatments and, and interventions for, um, for depression and anxiety. 43:43 So exercise is, is amongst those, and, and it really helps, um, some people, uh, a, a lot, and some people it doesn't help that much. 43:53 It, uh, it, it rarely harms, but, um, but there is, you know, genetics and other things that we and others have done work in, in predicting if you're gonna respond well to exercise and if it's important to you. 44:06 There's no magic number like, you know, uh, 10,000 steps. It's- Right... probably, um, it's reasonable and, and but, you know, getting 3,000 steps is better than getting 2,000 steps and- Sure... 44:17 and, and doing anything at all is probably the most important thing, and then there's marginal benefits to doing more. So I think it's, um, 44:26 it's, it's-- exercise is, is, is really good in, um, in a lot of things for, for, for physical health, cardiovascular health, um, clearly for mental health, um, clearly for, for staying well and, and even if you're, if you are depressed and sick to, to get better. 44:43 I think the-- there's, um, studies comparing different kinds. There was a meta-analysis that came out last week that found like dance [chuckles] was the most effective type of exercise. Great. 44:54 I, I'm not sure if that's true. I think it's probably more people who'd be willing to do dance as an intervention are different than people who wouldn't. But great, you know? Yes, great. Yes. 45:03 It, it's like I, I keep-- I'm wrestling while you're thinking of like, do I use the term like broad strokes telling people like you don't need to become a triathlete? 45:11 You know, like you said, 2,000 steps is better than 1,000 steps. 45:14 Or is it you, you don't wanna dumb it down to like lowest common denominator, but it's the idea that like something is better than nothing, and a little more something is better than something. 45:23 It's the same thing as, and again- Yeah... um, I know there's been studies on this, this, and that, and it's easy to feel like it's sort of softer science, but like exposure na- to nature, which seems to be really great. 45:35 Yes. If you don't, if you have any access to it and you're not doing it, a little bit, I, I don't know, it seems- And-... it seems to help... a little bit, yeah, exactly. And, and I think it's... 45:43 And, and I don't-- I think there's getting to be more real science behind all of this. Um, and, and I think it's, 45:50 uh, so I think the important point, points are, are that just a, a little bit is, is clearly better than nothing. And is multi-solving, like you said, I mean, cardiovascular, et cetera, et cetera. Yes, exactly. 46:04 If walking is easier than, uh, riding a bike, then walk. 46:08 If, if whatever it is, even if it's, uh, standing up, you know, during meetings or, uh, you know, uh, whatever it is that, that, that is easiest for you to do, um, you should do it. 46:20 It's, it's not as clear that, you know, running a marathon is better than running a half marathon. Um- Right... the, the benefits at that level are pretty small. 46:28 But, but doing something instead of nothing and whatever it is, um, is great. I think if there's a way to do it in a way that also is social, that's even better. 46:38 Uh, so physical activity that, um, is, is part of a group and, and, um, and creates more social interaction, um, seems like it's better than, um, than ones that, that aren't. 46:50 But, um, but really whatever, whatever you can do, um, is great. And then a- as I was sort of alluding to with the medications, um, really figuring out what works. 47:02 For, for some people exercise is, is, um, a, a game changer and really, um, is the key to their staying healthy. Um, for other people it, it's other things. 47:14 It's, it's more in, you know, in sleep or the quality of their, their personal interactions and for other people maybe more diet. 47:23 I, I think the being experimenting with yourself and, and understanding what sort of is the... 47:30 maybe the key is too strong, but the, the, the elements that most affect you and, and as we talked about before, trying to keep track of your mood, um- Sure... 47:40 it, you know, you don't need the one-to-ten system, but some system and, and being able to figure out like, oh, really I've been better about, I've been, you know, uh, three days a week for the last, last month I've been, um, going for a long walk and, and my mood is better, um- Mm-hmm... 47:57 um, on those days or, or, or not and, and figuring that out is, is really valuable. Yeah. I, I appreciate that. It, it does seem like, and again, it's, it's, it's asking in some ways for you to just use your phone. 48:10 You could use a journal, but, um, checking in, the, there, uh, at least, you know, Apple has built in these things now where you can very easily check in. You can even journal a little more. 48:20 I've always used, uh, it's different from that. I've used Day One, uh, journal for 15 years, and it's fun. 48:26 It shows you like on this day, in eight years ago this, and often, I'm not kidding, I'll send you a screenshot, like most of my entries are just me saying, "I'm tired." Um, so that's great. 48:36 Uh, good to know noth- nothing has changed. [laughs] Uh, but it is this-- but this checking in- Yeah... 48:43 just the act of it, but again-Enabling like a, a more valid retrospective, I think is probably a little helpful there for you. 48:51 And I imagine when you do get up the nerve to go talk to a psychologist or a psychiatrist or, or a social worker, whatever it might be, someone who you might wanna have talk therapy with or someone who might be able to prescribe a medication or both, like, having that data for yourself and for them- Right... 49:09 I imagine can, can further your own interests in some way. Yes. Yeah. Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. You know, I wanna check out that, that, um... What, what it-- Day One you said was the- Day One. Okay. 49:21 It's a, it's a journaling app. Uh, I don't know if it's M- Mac or Apple only. It's been around for 12 years, something like that at least. Okay. That's how long I've had it. It's great. 49:30 And but now Apple's got their own journaling thing built in. It's not as powerful. The point is, like, there are tools. 49:35 Um, and they're there, and you can start to use them, and they're not gonna solve everything, but just- Right... knowing yourself a little better without being one of those 49:44 crazy people like myself who, who can check too much data, um- Yeah. No, no, yeah. It-- But it's, it's good to do. 49:51 Yeah, I've been, I've, I've been trying to use the Apple one, but it's, at least on my iPhone, it's only connected with Peloton. 49:57 So, like, the only thing it asks about is, like, "How did your, how did your afternoon strength session make you feel?" And I'm like, "I don't know if that's, like, the most important thing in my life." It's interesting. 50:07 But I guess it's... Yeah. We'll do s- we'll do some tech support on that. Um- Yes. Yeah... mine is just like, "What are you annoyed about today?" Um, I'm like, "How much time do you have, Apple Watch?" 50:16 [laughs] I think this is all really helpful. 50:18 Again, I hesitate to say like, "Hey, what are like three basic questions someone should ask when they go into their first possible talk therapy appointment or their second with someone different, um, because the first one didn't feel right, or when they're going in to think about medication for the first time?" 50:35 Mine was a little easier because I was just like, "Oh, let's not have a heart attack. The-- Tell me what the things are, and I'll just do them." Um, but other people are gonna be a little more nervous. 50:46 Like, if, if you have any thoughts on that, like, how to best sort of, not steel themself, but be prepared to go in, um, this is a great moment to share them or not. It's up to you. Yeah. 50:57 Um, I-- Yeah, I don't think there's a exact right, um, s- uh, question or set of questions, but I think being as 51:07 open, um, as possible about your own anxieties or questions about different approaches, because like I mentioned, there are a lot of different choices. 51:19 I, I think often the main first one is, is medications versus therapy. And, um, oftentimes, our-- we have sort of underlying beliefs or thoughts about which one is better for us. 51:33 And I think being open with the therapist or psychiatrist or, and ourselves about, about that is important. And, and this is an area where, um, there is a, a psychological and, you know... 51:48 A, a placebo effect gets a negative term, but, but it, it has a, a role in this for- Sure... in, in, in depression. 51:54 And so if we-- if five of our friends got much better with, um, with Zoloft, we're probably more likely to respond to Zoloft. 52:05 Certainly if our-- if people in our family got better with Zoloft, uh, there's probably a genetic component and, and that, um, affects us. 52:13 But if you have a strong feeling towards mindfulness, then that's probably the right choice for you, and- Yeah... you should try it. Might as well try. 52:20 And, and so being, um, don't-- not being sort of dictatorial with the, with the therapist or doctor, but, but being open about what your thoughts are and what, you know... 52:31 If you are leaning one way or another, don't doubt that and, and, and, and go with it, and be, be open about that, that conversation. 52:39 And if you feel like you're really hesitant about, um, medications for some reason, then, you know, that-that's reasonable and, and maybe, maybe- Sure... 52:48 starting with something else, um, as long as it's not, you know, um, very severe, uh, makes sense. Sure. 52:54 But like, like we-- like you mentioned there, these are, as medications go, SSRIs, um, and other sort of first line depression drugs are, you know, at, at this point, you know, hundreds of millions of people have tried, have taken them, and, and we know that they do have side effects and they change, but they're relatively mild, um, um, as medications go. 53:15 I think that's all totally helpful and fair. And, you know, as a reminder too, and, and I, I this, this, uh, is slightly hypocritical 'cause, uh, kinda considering I've made it my job, but, like, 53:27 you don't need to understand all the science to go to someone to ask for help. Um, there are a lot of really well-meaning people like yourself, um, who are trying to pursue these causes and understand them better. 53:39 [gentle music] And in the meantime, you can try to get help from the things we know that help a lot of people. Not everybody, maybe not even most people, maybe someone in your family, maybe not. 53:49 But the good thing is there are a few things that seem to help a lot of folks, and finding your version of that doesn't require you to get a degree from Reddit on the neuroscience of serotonin, you know? [laughs] Yes. 54:02 Yeah. It does- I think- If you're interested in that, amazing, but don't let that dictate whether you go and try to get as much help as you need, right? Right. Understanding serotonin does not- Right... 54:15 is, is not gonna help, um, the, uh, your treatment or, or your psychiatrist understanding, uh, serotonin is not gonna help your treatment, um, at the phase, I think at any time, but certainly at the phase of science we're at. 54:30 Hopefully, it can help them, you know, be part of developing a new, uh, uh, treatment in the future, but, but we're, we're, we're not there yet. 54:38 And even broadly of the outside of serotonin or biology, trying to get to the root causes of your depression or anxiety, um, it, it-- I think, I think we're at a stage where we can do that at a, um-Sort of proximal level. 54:56 Like, like- Mm... in current things in your life, like not, um, a lot of it is around sleep and sleeping well- Sure... or, um, you know, 55:06 stressors that, you know, someone close to you just died or there's a really difficult relationship or- Sure... um, whatever. You're, you know, you have a new job and you're commuting six hours a day. 55:16 Stuff that's going on right now, understanding how that's affecting you and, and- There's some, there's some low-hanging fruit usually. Yeah. 55:24 And intervening on those and, and talking through, that's, that's very helpful. 55:28 The deep thought, uh, at how sort of things 30 years ago are affecting you, I- sometimes there's breakthroughs, but most of the time it's really hard to, to tie together... 55:40 I mean, I'm, I'm summarizing, you know, hundreds of years of Freudian psychiatry- Yeah... in, in two sentences. But it, it's- [laughs]... 55:48 it's, um, hard for those to lead to practical solutions, um, in a way that that's, um, or, or, you know, certainly to medication choices or treatment choices. 55:59 And so, um, but, but people still get better, it- but it, it, it's not... 56:04 Usually it's not by finding the underlying cause and fixing it, it's, it's finding things that help people get better and, and getting more exercise and sleeping better and- Yeah... 56:15 finding the right treatment is, is, is part of that even if it doesn't feel like it's, you know, existentially solving the underlying problem. 56:22 And exploring those problems and if talk therapy, whatever version, CBT works for you, that's amazing. I mean, finding someone, I, again, I've been through a lot of folks, but, um, not 'cause I'm a monster. 56:33 I mean, I am in some ways. But knowing what I'm, I'm... I- it's pretty clear to me like what I don't want, um, so finding what I want is a little harder, but once I do- Right... 56:42 it is so helpful to have someone who's like, "No, let's, let's talk about the hard shit." You know? Right. Because there's so many strings attached to everyone else in your life about doing that. 56:50 That is the whole point of having someone like that. Right. And it sounds like you resonate really well with the psychiatrist who, who is pretty- I do... front- He's just like-... 56:58 and blunt about and- He's like, "Absolutely not. That's-" Right. "We're not doing that. Nice try." Right. Right. Um, and that's great. That is- But that doesn't work for other people and- Not for everybody. [laughs] Yes. 57:06 Yeah. But- But, um, my cocktail is also, and has always been exercise. It i- and it, and it is newly medication and it is, uh, I am crazy about sleep stuff. 57:16 I wish we were in a place where we knew, like it was those, it's, it's those exact things- Yeah... for everyone, but it, but figuring that out for yourself and that self-discovery- Yeah... is, is so critical. 57:26 It's funny, for as much as we really don't understand the brain, much less if it's like tied to the gut, like God forbid we're in even more trouble. Or it might be amazing, I don't know. Um- Yeah, yeah... 57:36 but- I like to think of it optimistically as, as, yeah. Yeah. Let's do that today. It's exciting. There's so much fun to learn. Sure. We'll do that. Great. Uh, so much to learn. This is so great. 57:43 It's hard though to be optimistic if, and this is more probably applicable, applicable in more systemic things, which this could be, if you have been down a lot of roads and tried a different cocktails and tried a bunch of different versions and combinations of things, to not wanna go like, "There's gotta be some cause that's missing that I have not tried because I have tried Zoloft and Prozac and Klonopin on the side, and I've done exercise and I've done three types of exercise and dance and social and not social. 58:10 I've tried support groups and all these different things. I, I sleep, I've got the blackout curtains and feel like there has to be something I haven't unlocked." 58:18 And it's, it's hard to not wanna be someone who learns how to read research papers and go like- Yeah... "Ah, this changed," and go to your psychologist who's like, "I don't know. I, I've been at work. 58:27 I haven't seen that paper that was published yesterday." Right. I g- I do empathize with that. Yeah. I do get that, you know? Right. Because you do have to be sort of your first line of defense a little bit. Right. 58:37 Right? Right. Yeah. No, I, I completely understand that and it's, um... 58:42 And there are a lot of people like that, um, and it is important to, th- that, it's, that, that is our fault as a field, as a, as psychiatry and mental health and psychology. 58:54 It, it, it's, we don't have solutions or we haven't figured out those solutions for those people and, and, and we don't have, you know, the equivalent of Ozemp- of Ozempic for, for anxiety yet, and, and that's- Sure. 59:07 Must be nice. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um, and, and so, but it's not their fault for, for, um, not responding to those treatments or- Sure... 59:17 and, and it, it's perfectly understandable to, um, uh, to, to, to alwa- to be searching and to try to, um, uh, find the newest thing that, that could help. 59:27 That's, um, perfectly understandable and hopefully we get something like that- Sure... um, uh, soon. 59:33 And there are middle grounds by the way, like America's clinical trial system is a bit of a nightmare, but, you know, there are places you can look to try to get engaged with these things that aren't necessarily pharmacological. 59:44 I mean, these studies about exercise and stuff don't come outta nowhere. I mean, sometimes they're observational or retrospective or whatever, but, um, you know, th- there are- Yeah... 59:53 there are things you can do and, and questions you can ask and ways you can try to help yourself along the way. And I, again, I keep kinda coming back to a lot of these folks with long COVID who, you know, 1:00:04 are running into conditions or of a potpourri of new conditions that they didn't know they were susceptible to having genetically or are brand new or suddenly have a new cardio problem because of COVID. It's really hard, 1:00:19 uh, to look around and go like, "Okay, who's the best person to talk about this?" And you go like, "Well, everybody, the best people have only been dealing with this for 18 months." You know? 1:00:30 Um, and there's very few of them 'cause they, because we had plenty of h- health issues before that. They still have their day jobs on top of this long COVID stuff. 1:00:37 So you have to have some empathy there too, going like, it's a pretty narrow, small field, not that they're not trying, but- Right... 1:00:43 we're still figuring out, again, almost like cancer, and this is a- another terrible analogy, you're welcome, which is like long COVID is not one thing, just like blood cancer and, and a tumor are very different. 1:00:52 Um- Right... it turns out it could be any combination of like 13 things. Um- Yes. Yes. Exactly... and finding someone, the one person who's gonna help you there-... is a little tough. Right. Right. 1:01:04 I get- And, and, yeah... it's frustrating And they- and they're still figuring it out, like you said, and, and it's, it's... 1:01:08 I think there's a lot of overlap between long COVID and, and s- or mental health and, and the same thing is, is true and, and there's not one depression or anxiety. It's, it, it- Yeah... 1:01:20 it's dif- really different, and pain is, is another thing in this sort of class of- Yeah, pain's fascinating... and, yeah, it- it's really fascinating in, in lots of different ways- Yeah... and we... but we don't... 1:01:33 What you feel after you, you know, whatever, like sprain an ankle is really different than, uh, cancer pain or, or, um, and, and the intervention should be really different, but, um, uh, uh, but we call it the same thing and, and we don't... 1:01:50 A- and this is more true for depression than pain, but we don't understand the underlying processes, either psychological, social, or biological, to differentiate in, in the, in the right way to, to, um, um, to sort of carve out the different types of depression. 1:02:05 And so we kinda still treat it the same way. Um, and, and a- and I hope, I hope we're, we're, we're much better at that in the future, and, and again, could be more precise. 1:02:16 That like with the, if you have these symptoms of depression and this history and, um, this genetic profile, then, then Prozac is the right thing for you. 1:02:25 But you have this other constellation of symptoms and, and, um, and history, then, then cognitive therapy, but we're n- we're, we're not there yet. 1:02:34 And, and, and post-COVID symptoms and, uh, is even farther, um, in its infancy and, and farther away from that. So it's, um, it- it's a challenge with this class of, of, of symptoms and disorders. 1:02:49 I come back to, and I don't remember who the gentleman is, uh, and I'll find it, but a couple years ago I remember reading, I don't know, it w- it, I think it was an MIT tech review or something like that. 1:02:59 It was, it was an MIT [laughs] researcher who was like among the best in like sort of the brain's neural pathways. 1:03:05 And again, don't remember who it was, and I don't remember the context or the exact quote, but he was generally like, "Look, no one knows this better than I do, and we have no idea how a thought works." 1:03:15 And you're just kinda like, [slaps fist on hand] "Shit. Okay." [laughs] Like, you know, you gotta really be pretty humble about that, right? Which is just like- Yeah... "Ugh, I, it, it wor- it happens. We don't know why. 1:03:26 Maybe whales too." Right. Ugh. Yes. Yes. [laughs] Yeah. And I, I feel, I mean, th- there are people who know it better than me, but not that many, and, and I- Yeah... have no idea. Like, so it's, it's, yeah. It's crazy. 1:03:37 So- And that can be wonderful, but I think if you're suffering, it can be just like, "But, but fix me," you know? So- Right. Right... 1:03:44 knowing that there are options, knowing that, yes, we're still sorting out the serotonin theory in all this- Yeah... 1:03:48 and probably will for a very long time, that some things work for a lot of people, and some things work for others, and that there are things- Yeah... that are available to you. 1:03:55 Um- And I, I think another point that might be important is that we change a lot in our lives and, and, um, as we, you know, develop and get older and also as life cir- circumstances change. 1:04:09 And so what works for, um, you know, what didn't work for you at 20 might work for you, um, at 40, and, and 50, and, and vice versa. 1:04:19 So, uh, um, uh, th- which makes it even more infuriating and complicated, but also, um, there's hope and, and there's, there's, um, lots of, um, lots of things to try and try in a different way or, or that, that, um, were... 1:04:35 You know, I, I've seen lots of times where, um, particularly therapies that, that didn't work or didn't take hold maybe with one therapist or, um, at one time in people's lives do work later on again. Hmm. 1:04:48 Well, it all sounds easy. [sighs] Yes. Yeah. Um- It's unlikely that I'm gonna be out of a job, so we're not gonna solve everything. Yeah. Right. 1:04:54 I mean, I, I, it's funny, I have that conversation with a lot of folks, and I'll let you go in a sec here, but, you know, 1:04:59 when I tell them that not all, because they won't be, because the problem is inherently not this, but a lot of charities and nonprofits, the best ones should be trying to put themselves out of business, right? 1:05:12 Um- Right... it would be really great if we just figured out how to deal with pediatric cancer, right? Which is obviously 40 different things, et cetera, et cetera. Uh, ho- homelessness, all these things. 1:05:23 But there's a lot of [laughs] things it's very clear that, like, we're not gonna be done with any time soon. 1:05:27 I had this wonderful conversation with, uh, Kat Bohannan, who wrote a book that you would love called Eve, and it's about, um, I'm gonna get the subtitle wrong, but How the Female Body Drove 200 Million Years of Evolution or whatever- Oh... 1:05:39 essentially. It's, it's fantastic. Also, she read the audiobook, and she's great, and it's also funny. It's, it's amazing. 1:05:45 But she has this really great point about, she's, you know, she's like, "Humans are really bad at pregnancy and delivery." Like, like, even relative to our closest r- relatives, she's like- Yeah... "It's a nightmare." 1:06:01 Like, you know, gynecology, thank God we invented that and figured it out. Like, we have to. 1:06:06 You can be in the fanciest hospital and be in the most shape and, and have all the money in the world, and it's still, like, touch and go at times. She's like, "That is ridiculous." Like, it's not- Yes... 1:06:14 [laughs] that way for, like, any other animal. Right. And again, it's like that is not something that's going away. There's no way to, like, work our way around that, you know? Right. Right. Yes. 1:06:23 Um, and the brain and the gut and all that seem to be much less how they're entangled seem to be other parts. And I mean, same thing, postpartum depression, right? Yeah. I mean, holy cow. No thank you. Right. 1:06:32 Um- Right... but it, yeah And how evolution plays into our mental health is really fascinating and, and interesting, and I think can sometimes be helpful to think about. So, you know- Yeah... 1:06:43 um, could be worth talking about in a, in a, in a- Yes... future conversation. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, well, listen, I've kept you long enough. Um, have, I've asked you all the other questions. 1:06:49 Have you read anything recently that you would like to share with folks about work, not about work, someone else's work, fiction, graphic novel? I don't know. 1:06:58 Not a specific thing I read, but just related to the, um, you mentioned charities and, and other things and, and just something that's been coming up in a whole bunch of different research-Studies, um, more and more is, um, is volunteer work and how much-- how effective that is for, um, our own... 1:07:21 I mean, it helps other people, but helps our mental health in ways. I've seen it in, in my-- in the population I study of physicians. 1:07:28 There's even a, a study recently of like workplace mental health interventions, and almost nothing worked except volunteer work and a, a bunch of other sort of meta-analyses showing pretty profound effects, um, for, uh, some extent charitable giving, but even more- Hands-on... 1:07:45 volunteering and spending time on that, um, uh, on, on depression and mental health. So, you know, I, I think not everyone can do it and not everyone has time, but, but the more you can... It's-- 1:07:57 A-a-again, we don't know the exact mechanisms, but it's hard to feel bad about yourself if you're volunteering. 1:08:02 And, and, um, and, uh, I think I-I've, I've come to, um, realize more and more in, in how much it helps the person volunteering and, and, and is a good thing to do for people who are-- who have the, you know, capacity to do it, so. 1:08:19 Sure. Um, I mean, you know, I'm, uh... 1:08:21 Again, I think we need to learn more and learn more who it helps, but I think that's a-- that's another thing in the arsenal that we should use, I think, much more than we do, and hopefully that helps the world as well. 1:08:32 Sure. Yeah. It's clearly not like that narcissistic, right? I mean [chuckles]- Yeah... there's an element of like, "Great, you're running a marathon buddy. Like, congratulations. 1:08:40 I'm glad it makes you feel better," but like what does that do for people? [chuckles] Not a whole lot. Right. Versus- Yes... some form of volunteering, like Lord knows we need it these days. 1:08:47 You know, whether it's- Yeah... anything. Tutoring, handing out food, whatever it might be- Right... is amazing. Right. And I think that helps build community too, which is really important for... 1:08:57 I, I think we know inherently it's, it's good for the world and good for the community, but the, the fact that the extent to which it affe- it helps us, um, being part of that is, is I think underappreciated. 1:09:09 So, so that's, you know, tangentially the, the one thing that came to mind to add. Great. I love it. We'll find some resources to share on that. Srijan, thank you so much, uh, for your time. 1:09:19 Again, hopefully you don't regret it this time. I'm gonna keep- No, no, no... talking to you- I, I love it... until you feel like it's enough. That's all I got. 1:09:25 Uh, obviously, where can people follow your work, uh, just so we can put it out there? Um, sure. We, uh... I, I have my group's website and on-- I'm on X or Twitter or whatever we're calling it these days. 1:09:38 The University of Michigan Eisenberg Family Depression Center, which I help direct, uh, a-also on, on Twitter and our website, has a lot on the latest news and, and research and, and, um, and things people can do to, um, uh, stay up to date and, and take care of themselves. 1:09:55 So, I'm happy to share any of those resources if, if, if it's of interest. Awesome. All right. Uh- Great... this has been fantastic. Thank you so much. [upbeat music] That's it for this week's conversation. 1:10:09 For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing, thanks for leaving a review, and thanks for giving a shit. 1:10:23 [upbeat music]