Transcript 0:00 Hey folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company. 0:12 But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question. That is, what can I do? 0:18 It's a question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost two hundred episodes now. So here we are, the most important question. 0:29 Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. [upbeat music] This week, why did we make an app? 0:43 No, really, why did we have to make an app? But first, I'm Quinn Emmett from Important Not Important, and these are my essays. 0:54 Hit subscribe right now wherever you're listening or watching to get these essays and my conversations with the world's smartest people every single week. 1:02 You can find the email version and the web version and links to everything at importantnotimportant.com or in your show notes. 1:11 And apropos of this essay, you can also take action on the causes you give a shit about at whatcanido.earth. Whatcanido.earth. One day I'll get that straight. Anyways, why did we make an app? 1:26 You'd think that considering we just spent two years building our new What Can I Do app, that I'd have a really good answer for why we were doing it in the first place. But I didn't, not until about a week ago. 1:40 I knew, of course, the practical reasons why it needed to exist and had a good idea of what I wanted it to look and feel like. I'll share that whiteboard photo someday. 1:51 I knew it was the natural evolution and a significant missing piece of our work so far. 1:58 But I had never really interrogated myself to understand why I was so hell-bent on building an app, a tool really, that gathered all of the action steps we'd researched over the years, and any going forward, and made them accessible to anyone across the world anytime they wanted or needed them. 2:19 At Important Not Important, we cover climate change, hunger, AI ethics, ecosystem decline, education, biotech, and other fun stuff, and from a human perspective, because humans are, for the most part, uh, for better or worse, in the driver's seat. 2:36 It's why the subtitle of these essays is "Two hundred and fifty thousand years of humans fucking around and finding out." 2:43 The decisions we make individually and as a people are mostly predictable because we never really change, but they're more connected now and more impactful than ever. 2:54 The good news is that also means the good you choose to put into the world can put a much bigger dent in the universe than ever before. 3:03 Which is why, for example, one, or I guess really two of my favorite questions to ask, uh, my guests and offline are, one, why do you have to do this work? Number two, why do you have to do this work? 3:20 Let's gently expand on those. Number one, again, why do you think it's essential that of anyone, you are the particular person to do this particular work? Why are you so special? What do you bring to this? Number two, 3:37 what internal reason do you have where you absolutely have to do this specific work? Why are you obsessed with this problem or opportunity? 3:49 Regarding our new app, I had, of course, never asked myself either of these questions, and I never did. 3:56 This, despite the questions and the focus of these essays being the decisions we make are mostly predictable because we never really change. 4:06 We want security and all that stuff, and because the decisions we make, good or bad, are more connected and impactful than ever. You get it. 4:13 But about a week ago, my kid asked me, and I answered him, and it all suddenly, predictably, made sense. My kids are patient and kind. They're givers. His question was innocent enough. 4:30 I'd missed dinner and was late to bedtime. Kind of a common occurrence these past few weeks as we've prepared for launch, but one that is otherwise pretty rare. 4:42 I've been incredibly privileged, mostly by my wife, to have structured my career around being around and showing up for my kids much more than most dads are able to. So when I miss dinner and bedtime, my kids notice. 5:00 When I miss it a few times in a row, they ask about it. So his, the oldest, it was a simple question: "What were you working on?" 5:12 In an essay I wrote last year called Did You Hear the One About the Starfish?, I quoted investor and dad Chris Sack, who said, "The answer to why you tell your kids you can't hang out right now better be really fucking good." 5:24 He was, of course, talking about his work as a climate investor now. 5:28 I identify with that belief and that practice, and so I wrote in the essay, "Right now, when my kids are most aware and most desire my full attention, my time, to justify a late night at the office means I better be on the cusp of curing some fucking disease. 5:48 That's how important my time with them is to me and to them." And yet I'm definitely not curing a disease, not directly at least. We'll get to that. 6:00 That's not how this brain works when it works or how my biology grades went.Cut to today. I've worked a lot of places. I've done a lot of jobs. I've been paid well for some of them, and for some others, not so much. 6:15 Some carried more risk than others. I've worked at illustrious newspapers and magazines all over the world. I've built websites and apps and paywalls. 6:27 I've invested in and advised nonprofits, uh, startups, political campaigns of all sizes, and institutions like Sesame Street, for example. 6:37 I've written TV pilots and screenplays about World War I era soldier soccer players, World War II immigrant submariners, horrifically behaved Jamestown colonizers, and teleporters gone awry, forcing us to ask questions like, what makes you you? 6:54 I am a long ago liberal arts major with no defined career path. On the one hand, with perspective, it's easy to look at what I do now as the natural evolution, again, of everything I've done before. 7:11 That's the easy way, right? The media, the tech, the investing, the activism, the fundraising, the storytelling. Sure. On the other, from any other vantage point, I clearly have never had my shit figured out. 7:26 But even though my kids, and, and my son in particular here, knows what I do, that's not how he took it when I said, "We're trying to finish getting all the data in for this app, enough to launch, and making sure it won't break when we share it with people, so it can immediately help people be more helpful." 7:44 And he sighed, distraught at that. And I thought, "Ah, fuck." Maybe that's just not good enough for him, not good enough to miss consecutive dinners and bedtimes. 7:57 Now, my friends know this, my wife and children know this, I take everything personally. I'm working on it. It's not going well. So in that starfish essay, I continued, "Here's the thing. 8:10 Even though my kids are increasingly cognizant and proud of what I do and why I do it, and understanding more of the world around them, some part of me still believes they're always going to remember me missing dinner, not why I missed it. 8:27 Each time I have to pass on some crucial moment with them, I feel like I'm failing a test, 8:33 that they're more aware of our limited time together than I am, which is probably impossible, not only because their brains aren't fully formed yet, because I think about it all the time. 8:44 I'm obsessed with how little time I have with them, especially as children." So as he sighed, that's all of what I was feeling again. So I, against my better judgment, asked him what was the matter. 9:01 Now, I don't wanna betray his trust here, so I won't get into the details, but basically this new middle schooler is dealing with everything middle school, as you do, as we all did. 9:12 But he's also convinced that everyone but him has their life figured out, including me. So I laughed. Not at him, of course, but because any adult with any self-awareness and perspective would do the same thing. 9:30 Obviously, that's because exactly none of us have our shit figured out. I recounted to him my career path above, emphasizing how little of it was anticipated, much less planned or having anything figured out. 9:48 And so when he asked how this app, how this current work fit into all that, I had to think about it. I've thought about it before. Hey, parents. 9:59 You know that moment when your kid is asking you something for the forty-seventh time while you're trying to make three different breakfasts, pack lunches, and figure out if your house insurance is about to get canceled because of climate change? 10:10 And all you can say is, "Not right now." I'm Quinn Emmett, founder and host of Important, Not Important. And I'm Claire Zuelke, writer and producer of the Evil Witches Substack newsletter. 10:20 And we're here to talk about, generally, with tears often, parenting in these absolutely just crazy times. 10:27 Every week, we're having honest conversations about raising kids while trying to stay somewhat sane, whether that's debating screen time- Explaining wildfire evacuations and what fascism is and why coups has a P in it... 10:41 surviving another parent-teacher conference and behavioral reflection forms Or just trying to get everyone to eat something other than dinosaur-shaped nuggets, which by the way, are delicious. 10:51 We're not here to tell you how to be the perfect parent. We're here to remind you that you're not alone in this chaos. 10:57 Join us for our new show, Not Right Now, a show for parents who know that loving your kids and wanting to hide from them in the pantry can both be true at the same time. 11:06 Because we're all just trying our best while googling, "Is this normal?" in our bathrooms at three AM. Not Right Now, new episodes every Thursday, wherever you get your podcasts. 11:17 But in this particular case, I was just so in it, and, and I doubled back to the activism and the giving, and I went back to 11:25 2008 to tell him a story he'd heard before, one I've told before to my children a lot, um, but one I've never connected to the app in particular until right then. 11:34 In 2023, I wrote another essay called Why I Don't Eat Animals that was pretty personal. And I wrote, 11:40 "I worked my first jobs in London, and then 2006, New York, absolutely inhaling Ess-a-bagels, chicken parms, and Frappuccinos on the daily. 11:50 I was clocking twelve-plus hours just sitting at my desk, drinking and going out, and not really sleeping most nights because I was young. You only live once." You get the idea. We all did a version of it. 12:01 It was great, but I was increasingly in uncharted territory fitness-wise. I felt terrible.Okay, that's the backstory. 12:09 In 2008, a close cousin was diagnosed with leukemia, and I was jolted out of my debauchery, desperate to do something. But what could I do? As I make clear over and over again, I am not a doctor. I am not a scientist. 12:26 Over and over, I asked the question you all ask me, you ask us: What can I do? The answer, it turned out, was former two-sport college athlete. I could sweat. 12:41 I somehow managed to find and sign up and train and fundraise with Team in Training, part of the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society, where I met incredible humans, raised something like sixty thousand dollars, and competed in the New York City Triathlon. 12:54 It was an incredible experience. I felt like I was back at-- that, that I had found some unexpected purpose here with something I'd been doing my whole life. Two months later, I met my future wife at a Caribbean wedding. 13:07 I was in sick shape. I tried to impress her by racing and beating a very slow ferry boat. She did not care, the first of many times, but I was riding high. When it was over, I flew away on a seaplane. It was romantic. 13:24 I was killing it. I had put good in the world. And two months after that, one of my best friends was diagnosed with cancer. And a few months after that, now early 2009, he fucking died from that cancer. Fuck cancer. 13:40 Two years later, moved to LA, drinking, depression, no, no jobs. 2011, I just convinced ten, eleven friends, something like that, to run that fall's New York Marathon with me. I had to do something. 13:52 So we'd all agreed to collectively raise a shitload of money for cancer research. At, at that time, the Livestrong Foundation, which, yeah, another essay. 13:59 Because one, honestly, fuck cancer, and because after working with Team in Training a few years before, I knew what to do. To present day. It wasn't as easy as all that sounds. I struggled a lot in both cases. 14:13 During the day, at my job, and awake at night to figure out what the fuck can I do about this, about my friend, about this just happening to people? 14:22 As I described that feeling to my son and thought about the app, I realized what had been driving me to make it all this time. Our work has always delivered something special, I think, and I think a lot of you do. 14:36 Vigorously researched, timely, evergreen action steps you can take to act on the biggest issues of our time. We help you, along with us and so many others, throw the fucking kitchen sink at these things. 14:48 But we've always given the action steps to you in what is called a one-to-many model. In short, we pick them, put them in an email, and send it to all of you. Same for the podcast. 15:01 We talk about it, upload it, publish it, all of you listen to it. It's the broadcast model. It works. It's timeless. It matters. We're proud of it, but it's pretty limiting. It's not very flexible. 15:15 If you already know the answer to why it's limiting, we know each other better than you think. It's limiting because what if what I put in the email that day wasn't what you were worried about or excited to help with? 15:28 Now, sure, you can look back through the emails to see if it's out there or the podcast. You can Google it. Good luck with that. 15:34 It's limiting because I know exactly what it's like to completely spin out at work or around your kids when you're alone or in bed at night when you just don't know what the fuck you can do about something, but you're desperate to do anything. 15:50 And it'd sure be great if that anything fucking did something. 15:56 In an essay called How Does the Brain Work?, I wrote: It's easy to think that unless you are a neuroscientist, a neurosurgeon, a neurologist, a neuropharmacologist, a psychiatrist, someone studying to become one of these, or a gut scientist like my friend Gautam, who is linking up with brain people to ask even bigger, harder, more consequential questions. 16:18 If you're none of that, you're really not gonna contribute to how we make meaningful progress on how we understand the brain. But that assumption would ignore, just to start, how the research they're doing is funded. 16:33 To say that it takes a village for any of this shit would be a monumental understatement, from program officers to grant managers, lab techs, grad students, undergrads, 16:44 support staff, Team in Training, and it's this way for most fields, honestly. It's really important we figure out as much as we can about the brain and how it interacts with the gut, what causes and treats Alzheimer's 17:00 or whatever else. It is vitally important, and it's easy to feel like whatever contribution you can make might not play a significant part in that journey. I have felt that. I get it, and it's fucking wrong. 17:17 Yeah, self-awareness is key. It's bui- [chuckles] it's built in the app, and it's the real reason we all constantly ask the question, hopefully: How can I help? 17:27 Not just because we're shit-givers at heart, but because we already know our limitations, and they can make us feel pretty goddamn impotent when the shit hits the fan at a personal level or a societal level or whatever. 17:42 Look, if you're someone who's interested [chuckles] and capable, unlike me, of becoming a scientist or a doctor or an elected official, go get 'em. That's incredible. I am all for it. We will support you. 17:54 But I'm certainly not one of those people. My career path might keep changing, but it's not going in that direction. When my grandparents had dementia, 18:03 my cousin and late friend Andy had cancer, my other cousin and my uncle had ALS, when everyone was stuck at home because of COVID and, and disasters and a million other days too, I stewed in my thoughts and emotions, asking over and over: What the fuck can I actually do about any of this?And the best answer is, of course, what can you do? 18:29 Because you can always show up. There are always action steps to take, even at work, even with your kids, even at night, in the middle of the night. That's what our app, What Can I Do? Doubt Earth, it's what it does. 18:44 It's self-serve. All of our really impactful actions are just three clicks away, no matter what your resources or what time it is, whenever and however much you need it. That's the answer I gave him. 18:57 That's why I had missed a few dinners. Because for fifteen years, I've been trying to recapture that feeling of finding team and training, of running a marathon through my tears for a reason. 19:10 And for the last two years, I've been working alongside a very small but passionate team to build the app I needed then and now. When people sign up for our newsletters, they get an automatic email that asks, 19:23 "Why are you here?" And the volume and variety of responses we get from endowment chairs and third-grade teachers, grandparents, law partners, sculptors, students, senators. 19:37 Man, I described that to him and I said, "Look, fortunately and unfortunately, there are many more people who give a shit than ever before for a million more reasons." 19:48 And I know how at least a privileged version of that feels. So the least I can do is help those people answer the question, what can I do for themselves whenever they need it the most? 19:59 There have been people fighting for every cause under the sun for decades and centuries, usually because they have to. I don't have to. I'm so lucky. 20:08 And we have so many allies who've been doing the work to connect new people like yourselves to existing frontline heroes for years. None of this is a new idea. But, and this is a hundred percent my fault, 20:20 I couldn't see through my own darkness to find them. So I get that. Team and training and so many others have been doing their thing for years. But finding them when I needed them, it felt like a fucking miracle to me. 20:33 In the same breath, years later, when my friend Andy was on his way home to hospice, I remember getting that email. The only thing I could think to do was drink and call my mom, who knew exactly what I needed to do. 20:45 Come home. Because the only thing left to do was be together. And frankly, an app can't help you then. Because sometimes that's it. 20:54 Sometimes when everything else has been said and done, the most important thing we can do, whether we're doctors or researchers or lab techs or grant writers or event planners or artists or carpenters or marathoners, 21:08 is be together, stand together, cry together, remember together, make sure it doesn't hurt anyone else ever again together. 21:17 Sarah Jacquette Ray wrote in twenty twenty-three that we can feel buoyed that we are not alone in our efforts when we recognize that we are part of what Martin Luther King Jr. 21:26 called a network of mutuality, what Vietnamese monk Thich Nhat Hanh called interbeing, and Indigenous epistemology recognizes as all our relations. Not all of us can do everything or fight every fight. 21:41 Some of us are much more skilled in one thing or another, have more resources than others, have lived experiences so different from one another, or are not locked in as many intersecting predatory systems as others. 21:54 Our job is, in fact, to unlock those presents. It had been glaringly clear to me over the course of this work, especially that I and many of you, not all of you, have what Viktor E. 22:06 Frankl described as a freedom to take a stand toward the conditions. 22:11 But neither you or I can do it alone, nor can the scientists working on kids' leukemia, depression, and Alzheimer's, making rice and coffee safe from the heat and drought and floods, or the candidates running for school board, for judge, lieutenant governor, the journalists, the artists, the investors. 22:29 That's not what compound action is, going it alone. At one point when we were building the app, our one and only developer, Connor, an incredible human being, said, "Hold on, you want to build a social network in this? 22:43 Am I reading this right?" The social networks we've come to know and loathe are coming apart the way the empire comes apart in foundation, very slowly and inevitably, 22:55 terrifying everyone who built fortune on the backs of a world connected for the first time, for better or worse. Now, I don't want any of that bullshit. 23:05 The entire world can search our app for free as many times as they want forever. 23:10 If you want to keep track of the actions you've taken and the ones you want to take later, and if you want to connect with other shit givers, you can 23:18 make a profile and you can leave it private and share it with the world and you get a thirty-day free trial to do it and then it's two bucks a month or twenty bucks a year. That's all we're asking. 23:27 And the world will know it's you because we verify every public profile. 23:31 So you can actually trust you're following a real person in your darkest moment, whether they're a family member, a philanthropist, an athlete, a celebrity, whatever. 23:40 And so that person can trust that there are real people following them in this time, in this network, for a reason. 23:46 The candidates that will flip houses and the doctors and nurses and teachers and organizers and organizations that are working on the front lines of the future today need much, much, much more help. 23:58 It is my entire job to connect you to them, to help you keep up with their work, to help you understand how it relates to the past and the future and how we act and connect you to them so that in the dark of night, we can each see and be inspired by all of the many ways so many of us around the world are taking action right now, in this minute, and now in this minute, and the next one, over and over again, no matter your time zone. 24:22 Because somewhere at their job or newly out of oneIn their darkest minute or most hopeful, someone can and will find you and see the actions you've taken in your little profile and the ones you've favorited for later, knowing then you've done so much already, 24:38 but you're not at rest. There's always more to be done. Hey, let me check out that. I had never thought about that. 24:44 At various points throughout our lives, we can each feel like we're fighting our own long defeat, as we've written about, 24:50 and throughout history, a collective one, against real bad guys and for a better, cleaner future, one that is only so close because we have come so far on the backs of so many, but that will require many more to be a better ancestor for those to come. 25:06 People who immediately follow up, what can I do with Dr. Ayana Elizabeth Johnson's favorite question, what if we get it right? Again, there's nothing new here. There's nothing groundbreaking about a 25:20 guy, a white guy with a bootstrap app, a newsletter, and a podcast. It's like the Holy Trinity. But the reason why I need to do this work is more clear to me than ever before. And it's been right here the entire time. 25:32 So that's what I told him. This is what I was working on that night. I don't have my life anywhere near figured out, but I do know now why I needed to make this app the past couple years. Why are you here? 25:45 That's it for this week. If you have feedback, questions, opinions, cookie recipes, or just cookies, email them to questions at importantnotimportant.com. Again, you can go to whatcanido.earth to get started. 25:59 Hit subscribe to get next week's essay straight to your feed and my upcoming conversations with amazing folks. To go deeper, visit importantnotimportant.com. Thanks for giving a shit. 26:29 That's it for this week's conversation. For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing. Thanks for leaving a review. 26:44 And thanks for giving a shit.