Transcript 0:00 Hey folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important, Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company. 0:12 But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question, that is, what can I do? 0:18 It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost two hundred episodes now. So here we are, The Most Important Question. 0:29 Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. Hi, everyone. It's Quinn. I am very excited this week to give you a brief intro. 0:39 We are sharing a brand-new episode from one of my favorite new podcasts today. Uh, it's called The Hidden Economics of Remarkable Women. 0:49 Um, this is one of their first episodes, and I th- really feel like our community will enjoy it. Um, some quick notes about what this is. 0:57 Uh, big question is, could empowering women in the workplace be the simplest way to boost the global economy? And in a word, yes. But, as usual, how do we get there? 1:09 And you guys know, you're intelligent, you listen, you're shit-givers, that two of the top ten most measurable ways to draw down carbon in the atmosphere is by educating girls and, uh, for, through family planning. 1:23 And, uh, this is one of the biggest reasons why I, I love this new show. So, uh, The Hidden Economics of Remarkable Women, or HERO, is a new limited series podcast, uh, from the folks at Foreign Policy. 1:36 It's supported by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and it's about women around the world shaking up, uh, the status quo in very surprising and awesome ways. 1:46 We're actually gonna air, uh, their first episode right here. 1:49 Uh, like I said, it's about an innovative approach to franchising affordable childcare centers, um, and that is changing the lives of low-income mothers and female daycare o- daycare owners in Kenya. 2:01 I think it's a really great follow-up to our, uh, recent episode with the folks at GiveDirectly and Caroline Teti, who's working there. So, um, please enjoy this. Check it out, uh, anywhere you guys find podcasts. 2:12 New episodes drop on Tuesdays. And enjoy. We'll be back to you next week. Hi, I'm Rena Ninan, and you're listening to The Hidden Economics of Remarkable Women, a new series from Foreign Policy. 2:23 So it was, uh, nearly ten years ago that I first stumbled across one of these baby care centers. I was working for a large nonprofit in Kenya. This is Sabrina Habib. 2:35 Originally from Canada, she was drawn to Kenya by the idea that she could make a difference in a country where, according to the World Bank, more than a third of the people survive on less than two dollars a day. 2:47 I had the chance to go out to an informal settlement or a slum, uh, just outside of the city, and, uh, we'd heard about this concept of baby cares and wanted to learn a little bit more. 2:59 And so I, I remember being escorted by, uh, some community members to this, uh, gated compound. Uh, we took our shoes off at the door and then opened the door, and the first thing that struck me was the smell. 3:13 There was no sanitation at all, so the smell of urine, of feces, it was overwhelming. And it was completely dark. I couldn't see anything. I'd come from this bright sunlight outside. 3:24 And so I began to step forward, and I felt my foot hit something, and I looked down, and it was a little girl. 3:34 And I was so s- so horrified that I'd almost tripped on this child that I instinctively leaned forward, I picked her up, 3:42 and as my eyes became adjusted to the darkness, I saw babies all around me, fifteen, twenty of them, all awake, but completely silent. 3:52 These kids had learned not to cry anymore because they were so severely neglected, they didn't receive any attention, or in some cases, they were actually given alcohol or a, a low-cost sleeping pill to keep them hushed through the day. 4:04 And I learned that this was the best childcare option for working moms living in the informal settlements. 4:14 What drew us to wanting to hear from Sabrina is not that she discovered squalor or an underserved sector of the economy. 4:21 It's that a decade ago, she decided she had the ability to transform, innovate, and make a real difference, and so that's exactly what she did. I think they talk about it as a, a moment of obligation. 4:33 Sabrina ended up founding Kidogo. It's a word that means small in Swahili, but the change she's hoping to bring is, in fact, enormous. 4:42 Sabrina's working to build a network of affordable, high-quality childcare centers across Kenya. Kidogo's mission is twofold. 4:49 The primary one is to provide great childcare to low-income women, but the organization also sees itself as an engine for economic advancement for women looking to start or improve their own childcare centers. 5:02 Sabrina calls these women mompreneurs. So while Kidogo is a nonprofit, the individual daycare centers themselves are not. The women who run the centers have a chance to earn a good livelihood. 5:14 Kidogo's budget primarily depends on grants and philanthropy, which is then used to help renovate individual childcare facilities, pay program staff, and train and mentor their mompreneurs. 5:26 Mompreneurs like Lydia War from Nairobi. [instrumental music] My typical day starts with welcoming children into the daycare. I also do the health check using the thermal gun. 5:41 Thereafter, I do the diaper change and potty. From there, we do the circle exercise as the children wait to be served porridge. Afterwards, the children now get ready to be engaged in different activities. 5:59 [children cheering]That's the daily routine, the general hygiene, tracking finances, material development. I can't even mention all of them. 6:16 I just learned a lot Mamapreneurs running Kidogo's franchises first take three months. That's where they learn early childhood best practices, but also how to run a sustainable childcare business. 6:28 Kidogo has really helped me in terms of making profit out of my daycare business. The business has expanded from one room to now two rooms. I've also added another caregiver whom I'm able to pay. 6:46 The number of the children have also increased. 6:53 So Kidogo isn't just shaping children's futures in Kenya, it's also improving the current lives of women, and that's what the hidden economics of remarkable women is all about, the ways, large and small, that women are changing the status quo to improve their lives, their families, and ultimately the world. 7:12 And of course, women can't do this alone. They also need policies and programs that enable the best chances for success. But let's get back to Kidogo founder Sabrina Habib. 7:22 She explained to me why she chose childcare centers as the place where she wanted to focus her energies. It's because this is where she felt she could have the greatest impact in the lives of individual Kenyans. 7:34 A child who grows up in one of those baby care centers, their life's trajectory is already written for them. So, uh, half of them are stunted, which means they're too short for their age because of poor nutrition. 7:45 That impacts the brain architecture, and so they will grow up, uh, with cognitive deficits, with socioemotional delays, and they will go on to primary school. 7:57 Maybe they'll go on to secondary school, maybe not, and they will continue kind of menial labor jobs. 8:04 Uh, girls will probably be forced into early marriage, and they'll just continue this intergenerational cycle of poverty. 8:11 As sad as this all is, the, the hope here is that research continuously shows us that the first five years of a child's life is so important that if we can just make a few adjustments, if we can provide clean, nurturing, safe environments, we can transform the trajectory of a child's life and potentially break that family out of poverty. 8:31 When you started, how did you set the standard different for childcare in Kenya? Tell me a little bit about how you wanted to make this operation different. There is no standard. There are no regulations. 8:44 There are no policies on what childcare could look like. 8:48 So I, I did this with my, my now husband, and we started by thinking about our own childhoods and thinking about the centers that we went to and thinking and digging into kind of global best practices of what young children need. 9:02 When we started this, we surveyed hundreds of, of mothers and childcare operators and found that they believe that children start learning at the age of three, and we know the research says something quite different. 9:14 And so just starting with that point of these early years are so crucial, and then talking about how we can use simple, affordable ways to get children the best start to life. 9:26 Tell me a little bit about the challenges of starting a daycare center halfway across the globe. I mean, this isn't even in your backyard. What did you find was the hardest when you're getting started? 9:36 Was it getting the money? Was it the regulations? The cultural norms that you had to navigate? 9:42 I think probably the hardest one was around that, the norms and getting parents bought in to what we were trying to create here. And it's really interesting. 9:51 We, we were talking initially about training all of these baby care operators and bringing them into a network, and the feedback we received was, um, "There's nothing wrong with my center. 10:03 I grew up in something just like this, and I turned out okay." So people were defensive? Yeah, very much so. And we realized quite quickly that we had to stop telling people, and we needed to show them. 10:14 And so that's when we started these, you know, Kidogo-owned centers of excellence. 10:20 Then it comes from a place of families in poverty want the best for their children, and they believe the best is if they can read and write at, at a very, very, very early age. 10:30 Tell me a little bit more about the trainings with the mamapreneurs. Yeah. 10:35 So we, uh, we find childcare operators, and we put them through a training program, and at the end of it, if they are able to improve the standards at their daycares, we invite them to become a Kidogo franchisee, and we call the daycare operators we work with mamapreneurs. 10:51 And the training encompasses both the early childhood development elements as well as the business part because at the end of the day, they are running their own microbusinesses. 11:00 And we're dealing with mamapreneurs that have no more than a primary school education. 11:05 But what's really interesting is we actually start all of our training with a session on confidence because for far too long, childcare operators are told that they were not good enough to become real teachers. 11:17 And so we start with confidence about, you know, why are you doing this work? What is the world that you wanna see? 11:23 How is your role going to be used to shape the young minds of, of little children, and why is this work so important? 11:29 And then there's a pride that comes with that, and it's beautiful to watch, you know, mamapreneurs come into trainings, and their shoulders are slouched, and they don't look at you in the eye. 11:40 And then at the end of the program, they, they have dreams and visions for where they want their centers to grow to and the children that they want to serve and have them eventually contribute to society. 11:52 So I think that that's been one of the coolest things to see. Sabrina, how has COVID impacted your centers? Were you forced to shut any of them down? Yeah. COVID was tough on everybody. 12:03 It was particularly tough on the childcare industry. It was not a time for us to stay on the sidelines and wait this out. 12:10 It was about, you know, how do we roll up our sleeves and figure out how to meet the needs of young childrenNow in their home. 12:16 And, uh, we came up quite quickly with new business streams, so we launched play packs, so monthly play packs that got into the hands of young kids. 12:25 So just having something for young children to do was great, and I think over the course of the year, we had created, assembled, and distributed over sixty thousand play packs. 12:35 We launched a digital caregiving stream, so we have all of this amazing content that we train our mamapreneurs on, and then also a two-way ask the childcare expert hotline, um, which was awesome because we had a sense of the pulse of what was going on in the communities and what was on parents' minds through that very, very difficult period. 12:55 I'm so fascinated by these mamapreneurs, you know, the owners of these centers. What do you think they've done for their ability to better their lives and really accumulate wealth independent of men? 13:09 Our mamapreneurs are rock stars. They're [laughs] they're incredible. And the, the name was very intentional, right? These are women who embody the elements of a mother or mama, nurturing, loving, caring, patient. 13:22 But also, they're, they're hustling. They're entrepreneurs. They're strategic and work hard and persevere in spite of challenges, as we saw last year. 13:31 We do have issues with husbands sometimes, husbands who see their wives run these thriving businesses from, from something very small and wanna get involved or wanna take the money. 13:42 Um, we're having to develop a new strategy to engage husbands on why this is great. 13:46 [laughs] I think we've also had issues with husbands who find that their wives are working too much now and, uh, are not home in time to make dinner, so again, kind of dealing with some of these challenges that come with having women that are so confident and empowered. 14:02 Um, we've had a few, uh, mamapreneurs who were in really abusive relationships and were able to detach from their husbands because they have the economic independence now to do so. 14:13 I think it comes back to if they believe that what they're doing is important and valuable, then nothing will stop them. You know, it's incredible. You've created a community. 14:23 You've solved a lot of problems that had already arisen i-in the area that people needed to deal with. 14:28 But when you look at the policy landscape in Kenya, particularly around childcare, how do you think that you are personally influencing it? 14:40 As a organization, we know that no matter how much we scale, how big we get, there's no way we're gonna reach every child, and so we need to be working with the government on advocating for better, more progressive policies. 14:54 And we've had some really great quick wins on some policies, but I think the challenge comes into having those policies actually be implemented rather than just sitting as paperwork filed somewhere. 15:07 Ultimately, our, our theory here is that if women and mothers and communities understand the importance of childcare and advocate for that, then policymakers who are working on three-to-four-year election cycles are gonna need to start listening. 15:21 And so how do we influence the behavior of parents? And one of the coolest studies that was done last year was showing how Kidogo parents have shifted their hierarchy of how they choose a childcare center. 15:35 So having been exposed to quality childcare, they're now choosing centers that have a better learning environment, that have better nutrition, that have qualified and trained staff. 15:47 And so if we can start shifting how parents choose childcare centers, it's gonna force childcare centers to improve their quality and make it really a, a strong issue that communities and, uh, elected officials need to start addressing. 16:02 You've given so much thought to this, and it really is just so deep, the, the tentacles of the operation in community and with culture and with government. 16:13 What do you wish you had known about the childcare industry when you had started that you feel could have made a difference? 16:19 I think when we started, we, we really thought about this as an early childhood education issue and really focusing only on education, and it took us a couple of years to realize that when you're dealing with zero to three-year-olds, the needs are very different. 16:32 It's, it's health and nutrition and social protection and all of these different sectors. And I think that's part of what makes childcare so brilliant is that it touches every department. 16:43 You know, there's the health component. There's the labor component for women's economic empowerment. There's the social protection component. 16:50 And I think we've, we've only now really started to approach all of these different departments. 16:56 But I think that's also what makes it super difficult is that childcare doesn't fit squarely in one place, which is why there's no ownership or accountability. 17:05 And I think that's one of the biggest moves we need to make as a sector is potentially framing this more as an economic issue 'cause I, I think I was very naive at the beginning to think that if we could show policymakers... 17:17 And we've brought them, we've brought them to our centers. We've tried to show them the reality of working moms living in the informal settlements, and they, there is empathy there, but there's no action. 17:27 And I think I, I now, a little bit wiser, a little bit with more gray hairs, um, know that policymakers don't make decisions based on their hearts. They make it based on their wallets. 17:37 And I think if we can start framing this as an economic issue, that childcare will unleash this potential for women to work and have peace of mind at work and take fewer days off of work because their children are not sick as often, we can completely boost the economy of nations. 17:56 And then the, the spillover effects, which I think is re- you know, the real important part, is we're then having children develop that are cognitively smart and have critical thinking skills and socioemotional development, and that will be the future human capital for these countries. 18:13 It's great advice. The company is called Kidogo, operating in Kenya, childcare centers and mamapreneurs. Sabrina, I want to thank you for your time. Thank you so much for having me. 18:24 [upbeat music] So Sabrina Habib created this network of affordable childcare centers and opportunities for women to become mompreneurs. But what's the larger impact of Kidogo? 18:38 How transformational can good childcare be for low-income women? To answer this, we turn to Patricia Wakulo, Associate Research Scientist with the African Population and Health Research Center. 18:50 She's an early childhood specialist and has studied Kidogo. What Kidogo does is to show through their hubs, which are, in quotes, centers of excellence, they show through the hubs how it can be done. 19:04 One of the things that, uh, Kidogo really emphasizes is keeping everything at low cost. So, like for example, some of the materials that they use within their centers are mainly homemade or locally produced materials. 19:20 Why do you think it is that people ignore paid childcare in urban Africa? It's not really one area where you see instant results. 19:29 So for example, if I think about it from the, a budget holder's perspective, it's not one area where you put in money and see instant results out of that. 19:40 The results tend to come after a long time, and many people are not willing to wait for that long period for them to see results, because we are talking about long-term investment, long-term return on investment. 19:53 Patricia, how has COVID affected childcare centers? Wow. Um, what we know from our own experiences, particularly at the beginning of COVID, many of the childcare facilities shut down. Wow. 20:08 One of the issues that, uh, faces childcare facilities is that whereas they don't really have a home, in quotes, a home, um, ministry, they don't belong to the Ministry of Health, they don't belong to the Ministry of Education. 20:23 When the restrictions were put in place, including school closures, childcare facilities somehow fell under schools- Mm... 20:31 and all of them had to be closed, and that really c- created a very negative impact on the incomes of the childcare providers, because many of them rely on these facilities for their livelihoods. 20:47 And I imagine there was a ripple effect. It's not just the childcare providers who work there, but also the families that are putting their children there. H- how did that impact, get impacted? 20:57 Uh, so for many of the families that use these childcare facilities, they use them on a daily basis, and some of them use them because they need to go out to work. 21:06 With the childcare facilities being closed, it meant that many of the parents or the caregivers bringing their children to these facilities were no longer able to go to work. 21:16 And we found that as soon as some of the restrictions were lifted, many of these families opted to move to their rural homes because it, it was no longer possible for them to survive in Nairobi. 21:27 Patricia, when you step back, how do you think Kenya should plan for a recovery post-pandemic that really better invests in childcare? 21:35 One of the ways that the government can really support this sector is to just be more involved in the running of the daycare facilities. 21:45 Many of these facilities are private-run out of people's homes, and the regulation in the sector is very, very poor, which means anybody can do whatever they want. Nobody is watching what is happening in the childcares. 22:00 So nobody, nobody feels answerable. There's no accountability in this sector. And I think if the different players are brought together, then we'll make headway in the changes that we would like to see in this sector. 22:13 Mm. What would you say to people listening why this is so important when it comes to the economic empowerment to look at childcare and to have this bolstered by support from the government and outside entities? 22:30 The one incentive I think I would, uh, talk about is that if we work to improve this sector, we'll have a big ripple effect through several sectors of the economy. One, we'll see women, 22:45 their own mental wellbeing is going to increase or improve, and in this way, their overall health is going to be improved. 22:54 The result of this is that they are going to be more productive members of the society because of their overall health and wellbeing being at a good level. 23:03 The other thing is the children themselves will see positive impact on their outcomes. 23:08 Most immediately, we'll see impact in the way that they interact with others, the way they engage with their environment, and then in the future, if we were to follow up these kids, we would see positive outcomes for them as well. 23:22 And even at the household level, you find that if women, who are mainly the ones who run households, thinking about how they support different activities within the household, whether it's the livelihood of the household, supporting the different unpaid care activities within the household. 23:41 If women are in a good place and their state of being is optimal, then you'll see a ripple effect in so many other sectors. 23:50 [upbeat music] Patricia Wakulo, Associate Research Scientist with the African Population and Health Research Center. Patricia, thank you. Thank you, Rina. The ripple effect, how do we create it? 24:03 Hearing from these women today, you realize how one painful incident of nearly tripping over babies became the catalyst to starting a whole network of opportunity, certifying childcare centers, empowering children, individual mothers, individual mompreneurs. 24:18 And over time, it all starts to add up. 24:21 You know, as we were coming up with a name for the series, we did a lot of brainstorming sessions, kicked around a bunch of names, and I can tell you that the Hidden Economics of Remarkable Women was by far the longest title we thought of. 24:33 And then one of the producers said, "Actually, you can shorten it to the acronym HERO."That if instead of W for women, you use the symbol for female, which is the O sitting atop a small cross. 24:46 And we thought in some ways that, too, was too serendipitous not to use. But I'd like to make one small little mention about the word hero as it relates to this series. 24:55 While we will be telling the stories of individuals like Sabrina, the changes they're making or hoping to make really come from the collective action of many heroes like Lydia, the mom-a-preneur from Nairobi that you heard from earlier. 25:08 And next week, we'll hear from the women in Uganda who are saving money in groups and challenging gender dynamics within their own homes. 25:16 [paper rustling] My husband used to hide his money because he didn't want me to know his income. So before the dialogues, it was so bad. After the first dialogue, my husband felt so good. 25:31 In fact, he said, "Sweetheart, do you think I should also be doing some of these things like peeling, washing, and looking after the babies?" There are many heroes in the stories we're sharing. 25:41 Change often starts with one individual, but it also often ends with many more fired up to make a difference. 25:49 It's one thing to want to empower women, but there'll be no ripple effect if you're not also changing social norms. [upbeat music] And that does it for today's show. 26:00 The Hidden Economics of Remarkable Women is a production of Foreign Policy and is supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. If you like what you're hearing, please subscribe, write us a review. 26:10 It helps us spread the word about what we're doing. This show is hosted by me, Brina Ninan. Laura Rosbrow-Tellum is our senior producer. Andrew Perella is our editor. Rob Sachs is our managing director. 26:20 Foreign Policy's audio team includes Dan Efron, Rosie Julin, and Simone Perez. Thank you, and we'll be back in your feed next week. [upbeat music] That's it for this week's conversation. 26:38 For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing. Thanks for leaving a review, and thanks for giving a shit. 26:56 [upbeat music]