Transcript 0:00 Hey, folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company. 0:12 But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question, that is, what can I do? 0:18 It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost two hundred episodes now. So here we are, The Most Important Question. 0:29 Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. 0:33 [upbeat music] In a world where it increasingly feels like radical change is happening to us, not by us, how do we continue to innovate? How does innovation actually work? 0:48 That's today's big question, and my guest is Christopher Mims. Chris is a journalist for The Wall Street Journal, and I had him on the show in twenty twenty-one to understand how he asks big questions. 1:00 You guys know how much I love big questions. 1:03 Chris is constantly asking questions about the most pressing technological and societal issues we face, from robot trains to the future of batteries, brain implants, and whatever happens to land in between. 1:15 And his thesis is this: Every little bit counts, and innovation is more predictable than you think. Or is it? Welcome to Important Not Important. My name is Quinn Emmett, and this is science for people who give a shit. 1:30 In our weekly conversations, I take a deep dive with an incredible human like Chris, who's working on the front lines of the future to understand and build a radically better today and tomorrow for everyone. 1:41 Along the way, we'll discover tips, strategies, and stories you can use to get involved, to become more effective, to ask big questions for yourself, your family, your city, your company, and our world. 1:54 In this conversation, Chris and I explore the team dynamics of innovation, the great man question, the invisible force behind Moore's law, and more. The bad news, nobody gets to save the world. 2:06 The good news, everyone gets to save the world a little bit. [upbeat music] My guest today is Christopher Mims. 2:16 Uh, together we're going to explore and try to help me and you understand how, uh, innovation really is, works, it turns out, across, uh, everything from your iPhone to supply chains. 2:31 Uh, and it seems like it's a conversation that's really more timely than it's ever been. So, uh, excited to have Chris here 'cause there's really nobody who follows this stuff more. Chris, welcome. Yeah. 2:43 Quinn, appreciate you having me. Uh, for sure, man. Uh, if you could tell the people real quick who you are and what it is you do. So I write a weekly column on technology for The Wall Street Journal, 2:55 and I've been doing that for seven years. So I don't cover personal tech, but that means that I'll cover everything from, you know, brain implants to nuclear fusion. 3:09 Uh, so the world's kind of my playground, and I enjoy, you know, going outside my zone of comfort every week, hopefully. Sure. I mean, that's the challenge, right? That's, uh... 3:20 That I, I feel like that is just so directly applicable. Maybe the most concise way someone's ever described what I try to [laughs] do here. 3:26 [laughs] Which is like, you know, someone will say like, "Well, can, can you consult on, you know, floodplain maps or, or reinsurance for this?" I'm like, "No, I cannot for sure." 3:35 But I can talk generally, you know, and ask questions of like these, these big topics that, uh, like you said, challenge myself and get outside my worldview because I try to almost like, uh, 3:47 you know, Neo in The Matrix with the plug in the back of his head. Like, and he's like, "I know kung fu." 3:52 Like, I try to get like a three oh one, at least a two oh one, maybe a three oh one in every one of these conversations before I have them so that I can be relatively informed so that it's a little more of a conversation than an interview per se. 4:03 But, um, it, you know, it's, it can be daunting for sure. There's so much to know. [laughs] Yeah. So much expertise in the world. [laughs] Yeah. There's so much. Yeah, there's nothing like being humbled all the time. 4:14 Uh, that's what I tell my kids all the time. I'm like, "D- Dad spends his whole day going like, 'I... Who, who knows? Who can, who can know?'" [laughs] Um, awesome, man. Well, I, I appreciate you sharing that. 4:25 Um, Chris, we like to start with one, uh, a little bit tongue in cheek question, but eventually after some cackling, y- you can get to something relatively profound maybe. 4:38 But we like to say, instead of telling us your entire life story as, as wonderful as I'm sure that is, I like to ask, Chris, why are you vital to the survival of the species? 4:49 Um, and I, again, I encourage you to be bold and honest 'cause who, who can know, man? Who can know? Who can know? I mean, I, I have some wonderful children. So I, 5:00 first and foremost I think that, uh, you know, I'm vital in, uh, raising, you know, future leaders of America or whatever [laughs] it is they're going into. That's number one frankly. 5:11 But number two, you know, I had a mentor in college who said that, you know, the way you find your path in life is at the intersection of what you're good at and what the world needs. 5:24 And so as a journalist, I'm privileged to talk to a lot of people, and my goal always is to highlight the things that we should be talking about more 5:36 and to try to simplify and make them a- accessible in a way that people can, you know, be more knowledgeable and have those conversations. I'm very privileged to be, I think, 5:49 one of the few journalists in America who is given the, the time and the resources to do that. 'Cause I've been on every side of the journalistic equation where you're just trying to pump out material for clicks. 6:02 I, you know, back in the day, way back in the day when people actually paid by the click-I had jobs as a freelancer [laughs] where I would, I would get paid that way. Oh, man. I would never want to go back to that. 6:13 So- Yeah... 6:13 being in a position to like really dig deep, like, it's just e- e- there- every time that I tackle a new issue, you know, I feel like I'm either retreading what other capable journalists have done and sort of bringing it to the Wall Street Journal audience, 'cause frankly, that's a different audience [laughs] than a lot of other publications- Sure... 6:31 that I'm privileged to reach. You know, or I'm just trying to, you know, blaze a trail and, and, and get at the things that people in the industry already know, but the public doesn't. 6:44 I mean, I had a conversation with a guy today about e- electric charging infrastructure, and he's like, "You didn't know this, but the last time you wrote about that, there was a map in there, and we've taken that map to every single, you know, municipality, and state, and private enterprise in 24 states to argue for, you know, this is why you should 7:04 y- allow us to put more charging infrastructure in your state." And I, and I was like, "Fantastic. I didn't know I did that." Yeah. "But you're welcome, I guess." Great. Yeah. [laughs] I think so. Yeah. You're welcome. 7:13 S- I'm sorry? Like, yeah. [laughs] So yeah, that's just what I'm trying to do every, every week is, is justify, uh, my ongoing employment- Right... by enlightening [laughs] and enriching, hopefully. Yeah, man. 7:26 I, I, I love that. And, uh, you know, uh, thank you for your, for your service in that endeavor for sure. Um, it's, it's, it's important to, to... 7:34 I mean, that's what I, I feel like w- we attempt to do a version of here, which is, which is essentially like taking a step back, you know, and, and looking at these, these undercurrents and these things that are going on, and not just revealing them, but trying to dissect them and, and help people at least, like you said, at least be aware of them. 7:51 And it's, it's beautiful when it turns around and someone's like, "Uh, we used your map, uh, with all the people, [laughs] all the cities." And you're like, "Okay, great." You know? That's awesome. That's awesome. 8:02 So thank you for sharing that, uh, fir- first of all. But, you know, 8:08 I, I try to think about each time right before we start, I mean, I, I always have this sort of underlying idea of like an, an urge to I want to have conversations, and it's either a specific topic or it's a specific person or it's the perfect sort of conflicts of them both. 8:22 And, you know, for, for this one it's, like, because of this show, and, and we're not just climate change or COVID or whatever, it's sort of just the, the, the make or break things is, is our, is our prism. 8:33 So I'm, I'm heavily invested in a number of ways through the show and our work and personally in this idea of sort of innovation and, and what that means and what it requires, right? 8:45 And, and we all are, whether we know it or not. I mean, again, a- apropos of, of, of some of your w- work, you know, we look at what happens with supply chains right now. It's, it's not just about, like, 8:58 h- has a- Apple partnered with Gorilla on, like, better glass so your iPhone doesn't break when you drop it. 9:04 Innovation also requires looking at these massively complex logistics intersecting so many systems in, in ports in Los Angeles versus Texas and supply and demand. And it requires innovative question-asking, right? 9:18 About, like, if, eh, look, turns out COVID was testing something else as well and how we come out of these things. 9:23 Um, but it's also, like, the GPS we rely on every day, and, and, and machine learning, and electric cars, and medicines. And I think, like, in these moments, we are 9:34 more acutely aware of, of this idea of innovation in our life. 9:38 Um, it can be in personal moments, like, um, you know, I've had, uh, my, my best friend died of cancer 10 years ago, and immediately, you know, you turn into, like, this, this sort of fake doctor and researching, like, "Oh, these are the best treatments for this and that," and you're trying to get educated on that and, and understand, like, how it's changed or how it doesn't. 9:56 Or you're like, "I haven't upgraded my phone in a few years, but I am a camera nerd," like, what are the actual upgrades in the hardware but also the software? Why... What is a, an mRNA vaccine, you know? 10:06 Like, w- why is it new? Why did it take so long to get here? Uh, et cetera, et cetera. You know, there's, there's all these examples from 10:15 why our elections still use paper ballots to, to, uh, electric car battery density. The point is, like, 10:23 we're in this really fascinating moment, and the future could possibly look very different from the past, but questions really remain about, and this is what I try to think about all the time, about what does innovation mean in the context of progress? 10:38 You know, who is doing the innovating? Who's funding it? Who's participating in the conversations? What does progress mean for a wider variety of folks? Because the opportunities for societal progress are, are myriad. 10:50 So, you know, through all of your work and, and when you wrote that specific article talking about the long view of innovation, it intrigued me because I want to understand these things for our community, but also to unders- help folks understand where we are and, and, and where, 11:04 uh, we're going. So let, let me start with this, which is, like, h- how did you stumble upon this, this, this work that was being done to try to, like, again, understand 11:17 what innovation is and how it works and how it's worked, I guess, to date through time to, to get to the point where you wrote about that? 11:24 So you're talking specifically about this paper, but, well, sorry, this effort that came out of MIT. Just to put this in context for your- Yeah, please... listeners, where they looked at a bunch of empirical data 11:41 about rates of innovation- Mm-hmm... in, um, various technologies. And that- Right... is a very squishy thing. It's hard to define. It's very hard to gather data on. Sure. 11:50 But other researchers have sort of very painstakingly spent years gathering that kind of data on 50 different fields of innovation. Mm-hmm. 12:00 And then what they did was, you know, it's a classic machine learning thing, where they're gonna train a model on the data that they have, and then they unleash it on, I think f- uh, now it's more than tens of thousands of different categories of invention. 12:15 Mm-hmm.Here they're also leveraging more human intelligence, which is that it turns out that the, no surprise, the US, uh, Patent Office has this incredibly deep and pretty clever, uh, Dewey Decimal-like classification system for inventions. 12:32 Mm-hmm. Because if you're a patent examiner and somebody comes to you with a new widget, you need to know where to search in the patent literature- Sure... to find prior art, right? Yeah, yeah. 'Cause if... 12:40 You need to know it's sufficiently new to grant a patent on that. So, um, yeah, they took this empirical data on, you know, 50 different inventions over time, you know, one of which is the microchip, 12:52 and they wanted to examine, you know, how does innovation happen. And what they found, and this is... 13:01 I mean, it's very controversial, on Twitter anyway, where there was [laughs] this huge debate after I published the piece. [laughs] You can stop there. But yes. [laughs] But it was an intelligent debate. 13:11 It wasn't just people shitposting each other. Right. And, um, and, and one of their findings was that in, in, in fields of innovation where 13:22 v- you know, there's more than, let's say, like 100 patents on something- Mm-hmm... innovation proceeds at a very steady, if not stately, pace. 13:31 And yes, there are individual breakthroughs that speed things up by a few years here or there, but because of the law of compound interest, if you wanna ask, like, you know, what is the rate of innovation, you know, that has determined Moore's law, for example, like, that has been remarkably steady. 13:49 And of course, part of that is because companies committed to it. But if you look at other fields, um, you know, energy generation and stuff like that, 13:58 across all of them rates of innovation are remarkably steady on the sort of, let's say, the decades scale. Mm-hmm. 14:05 So yes, there are spikes where there are breakthroughs, but overall innovation kind of r- is a, uh, is really a team sport. 14:13 And when I say team, I mean, like, all, you know, seven or whatever it is, eight billion of us are all participating at this point. 14:20 [laughs] At least over the span of time where they were able to examine it, which I think is about the last 50 to 100 years. 14:26 The other thing that they found that people got really riled up about was that this idea that, you know, lone geniuses, uh, are really responsible for these key breakthroughs, they found as kind of bullshit. 14:44 Now, there is one exception to that. Every once in a long, long, long time, someone invents a totally new category of invention. Mm-hmm. But that happens way less often than people think. 14:57 Because, you know, as somebody who's a student of innovation and the history of invention like yourself knows, 15:04 every innovation you wanna dig f- for, dig through the history of, there's always a much deeper history than people realize, and it's always- Sure... like, you know, it's turtles all the way down. 15:15 It's people standing on the shoulders of giants standing on the shoulders of giants. You know, et cetera. Like it's... You know, even if you're, like, talking about 15:23 the invention [laughs] of calculus or something like that. Sure. So this kind of busts these two myths of innovation. One is the sort of, you might call it the great man theory of innovation. Mm-hmm. 15:33 Like, oh, we're all waiting around for an Edison to just kind of, uh, change, tran- be transformative. 15:39 And then the second being that, you know, we're kind of dependent on breakthroughs to make things w- change all that quickly. 15:46 Like, really if you wanna look at anything you can measure, like computers getting faster, batteries getting more denser, or a million other things, it, it, it's kind of happening. 15:57 It's almost like a, a law of physics or something. It is, it is [laughs] happening at its own pace because it just requires so many different people and so many different contributions- Mm-hmm... 16:07 from so many disparate fields. And that was, of course, their final insight was that the innovations that really advance a field- Mm-hmm... almost always come from outside of it. Mm. 16:19 So what has driven the progress of Moore's law? It's really advances in laser technology, right? Because that's what allowed us to shrink the features- Mm... 16:29 on the chip, which are etched, of course, with a photolithographic process, which requires light. And that's true for, you know, any other field you can name. The... 16:37 So you never can predict where the next breakthrough is gonna come from, because it's gonna come from some totally lateral place. And of course, that is, just to conclude here, a really strong argument for just 16:51 general science funding. [laughs] Yeah. And that's frankly what the US is really good at. We are better at coming up with new innovations than we are at holding onto the industries that they result in. 17:04 Those tend to get captured by countries that are fast followers and are like, "Oh, you invented, you know, the microchip? Like, great. Like, we're gonna subsidize the production- Yeah... 17:14 of that until, you know, we're Taiwan." Or, "You invented- Sure... the solar panel? Like, we're gonna subsidize the production of that until we are mainland China." Sure. 17:22 You know, or that LCD screen going to, um, South Korea, on and on and on. You know, there's a million examples. 17:30 Well, it's interesting 'cause on the one hand it's easy to look at that and go, "Okay, I guess maybe just some places are better suited than others for certain parts of, of, of the system," right? 17:39 Of the pipeline of, of turning these innovations into realities, into consumer goods or, or part of a supply chain or, or, or whatever it might be. 17:47 At the same time, it's interesting to look at it and go, 'cause like you said, 17:53 you know, one of the big takeaways, if I'm, if I'm understanding it correctly, is, is like you said, uh, Moore's law, which is about as, as famous as it gets for this sort of thing, 18:04 th- that occurs because it was constantly... 'cause it adhered to this predictable thing. But that, but that happened because 18:13 companies had their finger on the scale and were dedicated to, to, to that performing in that way. 18:19 So it's, it's interesting how, you know, there's this idea of-Of, um, you know, of, like you were saying, um, you know, everything from, mm, GPS or, or, or, or, uh, mRNA vaccines or whatever it might be. 18:34 That there are so many p- different players who have to contribute to that for that linear line to keep working the way it does, right? 18:43 Because there isn't just this one, like you said, this one great man that shows up and, and changes the game. Yeah. 18:50 Because y- you know, p- increase in performance of any of these things you can measure is exponential, right? Mm-hmm. Like, it's only up and to the right linearly if you're charting this on [laughs] a log scale. Right. 19:00 And so anytime you have exponential growth, that's one of the reasons that these fits and starts of, like, new innovations just kind of get smoothed out in the end. 19:08 Because if you're looking at 100 years of innovation, like, it doesn't matter so much if, if a key innovation comes in year 5 or year 10. 19:16 Once you get to year 80, like, you're, you're still gonna get to [laughs] roughly the same place. Sure. 19:22 And it's, you know, I think now of, I mean, there's no better way to pit e- environmentalists against each other than to k- talk about climate capture, right? 19:30 Which is every single net zero pledge, which are mostly bullshit, whether it's a country or a company, depends on if you read the fine print, like sucking a hell of a lot of stuff out of the air, whether it's through trees or machines. 19:42 Uh, and, uh, the problem is, is, is we know that it kind of works, but it's i- it's incredibly expensive and we're nowhere near scaling it. 19:51 But you could have said the same thing about, uh, solar panels, you know, not too long ago. It's just that we decided to scale those and innovate on them. 20:00 And now it, you know, you find the most, uh, you know, the most optimistic, uh, IEA projection from the last 10 years and the real price of solar panels or batteries, uh, you know, the, just the cost alone makes them look ridiculous, right? 20:16 Makes them look incredibly conservative. And that's not to say that, uh, innovation is guaranteed or that scale is guaranteed, uh, or this thing that we need to do for humanity is guaranteed. But it does imply that 20:30 it's very diff- it- it's- it's hard to take the conversation seriously when someone's like, "It doesn't work. 20:35 It's too expensive," without acknowledging the history of how these things and innovation actually does proceed. Right. 20:41 And let's project into the future and, and let's apply one of the principles that, you know, this research discovered. Key innovations come from outside- Mm-hmm... of the fields that they impact most. Mm-hmm. 20:54 So a hypothetical for you. Please. Y- y- you know, like, a, I don't know, a couple weeks ago, I was talking to Sam Altman because, which is not a thing that normally happens, right? Co-founder of Y Combinator. Mm-hmm. 21:06 I mean, I haven't talked to him in six years. The only reason he wanted to talk was he wants to talk about the 375 million he just put into this company, which has a totally novel way of doing fusion energy. 21:17 So basically they claim- Sure... 21:18 that something the size of a shipping container, it's this totally novel application, uh, sorry, mechanism, could generate, you know, I think 50 megawatts of power and that they could get us down to, like, uh, an electricity cost of one cent per kilowatt hour. 21:35 So let's say this works or one of the other fusion startups that are out there. Mm-hmm. And, and, and we get tons of, if not 21:44 f- free energy, like nearly free energy, the original promise of nuclear power, which didn't work out- Right... because the waste is a problem and because the scale is too big. Sure, sure. 21:52 Then what if we then are able to increase electricity production on the face of planet Earth by 10X- Right... or 100X or 1,000X without generating additional emissions? 22:09 Then carbon capture starts to make sense. Then electrifying literally every activity that we have- Mm-hmm... so we can get to actually zero emissions starts to make sense. 22:22 And now what do we do in the meantime with all of the warming that's still loaded in the atmosphere? 22:28 Frankly, I'm a little bit bored by some of the conversations around geoengineering because I've been covering this for, like, 15 years- Yeah... 22:35 or I've been paying attention to it for at least that long, and no one has proposed anything new that I know of beyond, you know, the sulfate aerosols high in the atmosphere- Right... maybe cloud seeding. 22:48 And then every once in a while you'll get somebody who will mention, like, the sunshade- Mm-hmm... at a Lagrange point or something, which is my favorite because you don't, uh, cause a bunch of acid rain- Yeah... 22:57 or anything else. Like- Right... like, I mean, honestly, like- Y- you can turn it off a lot quicker... if, if Jeff Bezos... Yeah. If, look, if we're gonna start mining asteroids 23:05 within the next 50 years, I don't see why we can't just, like, put some big sunglasses on Earth, uh, while we're drawing down all the extra carbon we put in the atmosphere. Sure. Or whatever. 23:17 The other thing is we don't know what the future is. Maybe we decide, oh, shit, we'd rather spend that money on m- migrating a few billion people and just living on planet Earth in a different way. [laughs] Desalination. 23:28 I- Sure. Yeah... 23:28 which is not to be a Pollyanna at all because I think the, the, the immediate future is extremely dire for the, like, two or three billion human beings on Earth who basically are eating from a food shed which is only as far as, like, an ox-drawn cart- Yeah... 23:43 can travel. Um, like, those people are truly in a, in a dire situation and I don't wanna make light of that. But 23:51 if you're gonna go 50 or 100 years from now, there's so much innovation going on now that it is extraordinarily difficult to project, like, where we'll be and what we'll be relying on at that point in time. 24:05 [gentle music] Hey, it's Quinn. I'll make this quick. Sifting through the news is a slog. Finding the signal and the noise, it's damn near impossible. And if you do, what can you even do about it? 24:19 I'll tell you what you can do. 24:21 Literally every week I'll tell you the most impactful thing you can do.In just 10 minutes a week you can get smarter, feel better and make radical change for yourself, your family, your investments, your company and for the world. 24:37 Join tens of thousands of other leaders and subscribe to our free weekly newsletter at newsletter.importantnotimportant.com. Get the most vital science news, exclusive analysis and action steps for free. 24:52 That's newsletter.importantnotimportant.com or just click the link right in your show notes. Back to the show. Well, I loved this quote and I jotted it down and it is just kind of perfect. 25:05 It, it, one of the things in, in, in when you wrote the article, and, and we'll put that in the show notes and everything. 25:10 You know, I get these incoming calls again and, and I try to turn it into the writing of the show but a l- I do a lot of one-on-one stuff. But, but people especially since COVID like, "Oh, what's happening? 25:19 What the hell is gonna happen? Like, where are we going?" Yada, yada. My answer is usually like, "I have no idea, man." 25:24 But you wrote, "One of the conclusions of this group of academics is that attempts to predict the exact nature of the next technological advance are doomed to fail. 25:33 But their research could help us understand how quickly existing technologies are getting better." And I think that's key, right? Because, you know, like you were saying, for so many of these things 25:47 if you really try and look at them in an honest way, it is turtles all the way down, right? The, it's, it's so ra- I mean, you know, we can talk about fusion all day, right? [laughs] That stuff. 26:01 But, but it is turtles all the way down and that's important to understand as we're looking at 26:08 what are the things we need to do over the next 5, 10, 15, 20 years if we're gonna put some benchmarks on some of these net zero pledges. Or as far as, um, discovering new antibiotics, right? 26:19 Like you thought, you thought COVID was bad, like let me, let's, we can talk about that. 26:23 Um, you know, it, it is important to understand that a lot of these existing technologies are here because we've scaled them over, because they're ready to be built upon. 26:33 I wonder, do you have any sort of either, uh, wrote or even out-of-the-box examples of places where existing technologies are getting better, are gonna keep getting better in, in sort of that predictable way? 26:47 Out-of-the-box examples you say? Yeah. I mean, e- either way. Like, let's, let's sort of put some names on those things so we can understand how those compare to maybe some of the other outside ideas. Well, 27:01 I mean, I'll just give you one that's top of mind 'cause I just started reading a book on it. You know, a lot has been made of the, the potential of so-called, you know, synthetic biology and- Mm-hmm... 27:13 you know, everything from, uh, you know, genetically modified organisms that, you know, give us more robust food supply to, you know, gene drives that- Mm... 27:23 make mosquitoes less likely to reproduce, which is gonna be super important in a warmer weather world, by the way. 27:28 Yeah, we just had a conversation about that, uh, with a guy in San Diego who, uh, I mean, I- I'm not sure if you're aware or, or where you live, but Los Angeles went from like, "No bugs. Move here," to it's real bad. 27:40 Um, and that stuff is gonna be really important. Right. And a lot of tropical diseases that- Yeah... people in the United States are not used to coping with are on- Yeah... their way. It's not great. Yeah. 27:50 So I think that this is an area where a tremendous amount is and can happen. Um, I think that it is held back by a couple of things. 28:01 One is, we all have some squeamishness about it, but two is I think we're squeamish about it partly because there hasn't been very good governance on it. 28:09 And so, you know, like, if the only examples you can point to are like, uh, you know, seed companies making it impossible for farmers to do seed saving and getting locked into like a, an indentured servitude relationship with Monsanto or whoever because, you know, their, um, seeds are, are sterile after the first time they plant them, like that's just not like, a good precedent for like, what is the potential of GMOs. 28:34 Right. Versus let's put some genes in this rice so a billion people in Bangladesh and South Asia don't starve to death. Mm-hmm. 28:42 So I think that there is just, as we saw with the mRNA vaccine, right, which is like one of those great examples of an overnight success that was 20 years in the making. Sure. 28:52 And thank God all of that research was happening before this pandemic hit us. 28:56 There is so much incredible science loaded in the pipeline, in the biotech pipeline because, you know, w- I mean, I think we're, w- we live in an age of, of digital and physical and silicon technology, and we're used to manipulating those things. 29:12 Mm-hmm. But I think it's not well appreciated that like, we now and more and more have this incredible power to manipulate the other type of, you know, meat-based r- robots and technology that's all around us, right? 29:29 Like, I mean, it's, it, it drives me up the wall when people are like, "Oh, I'm so excited for nanotech." I'm like, "You are nanotech." Yeah. [laughs] "You're surrounded by nanotech. 29:38 There's nanotech everywhere, everywhere." Like, go down to your local university and ask them what's going on in any of their molecular biology labs. Yeah. They're all nanotechnologists. 29:46 You don't have to wait around for some mystical little silicon bot, uh, to do this stuff for you. Like, we can do this- Yeah... now. We have the technology. 29:55 Like, we have four billion years of life evolving it for us, and all we have to do is get on the choo-choo train and like, just- Right... ride it. So I think all that synthetic biology stuff is gonna be 30:06 really, really incredible, and I think people miss it frankly because we're so obsessed with looking at our devices and our screens and thinking about the internet and having our Twitter feeds dominated by the likes of, you know, Elon Musk and everybody else who's getting venture capital to like, build out that kind of technology that we- Mm-hmm... 30:24 just miss-All of this other squishier, more complicated stuff Sure. And, and, and I do. I, I-- and this is, again, the goal of these. 30:36 I think I've-- we've actually had two mosquito conversations [laughs] because one, uh, it's the idea of, um, you know, C- CRISPR is one thing, genetic manipulation's another. 30:48 Like gene drives or, or however you wanna phrase them, like that's a conversation that needs to be had. It needs to be an inclusive, cooperative conversation. 30:55 Uh, just like the idea of using CRISPR to eliminate a disease, right? 31:00 Because you have, uh, you need to make sure these conversations include people who are currently affected by it or, or who are, uh, might inherit, uh, a specific gene, et cetera, et cetera. 31:10 You know, they are the stakeholders in these things. It's, it-- the poor point is like the more of these conversations we can have... But I also wonder, you know, I'm a big fan of, um, uh, Mariana Mazzucato's work. 31:22 I'm not sure if you're familiar with her. Uh, she's fantastic, and it's the idea of like this mission-oriented approach, and she's got a couple of great books and, and such on it. Um, uh, to, to, to 31:36 brutally and greatly simplify just one part of it, it's, it's effectively using the Moon landing as an example, right? Okay, how do we reverse engineer, like goal: man on Moon. 31:46 Uh, it's a, it's a black or white outcome, right? 31:49 Um, so now you measure all of your people, and your systems, and your agreements, and your processes, and your milestones against that, and you build truly cooperative, measurable conversations and processes. 32:05 A-and I think with everything, uh, you know, we're talking about here, the need to fully decarbonize, right? Um, uh, biotech. Um, the opportunity now with mRNA to eradicate possibly like HIV or, or malaria, right? 32:20 Uh, universal flu vaccines, whatever. To, to innovate a way to solid state batteries, uh, uh, whatever it is. Um, more air conditioning with less of a power draw. This food waste. 32:31 I just wonder if, like you're saying, we've got all this incredible stuff floating around us we're so excited about, like what bullshit, like VC money is going into h-hard silicon. 32:41 I wonder if incorporating methodologies like these, whether it's at the government level or corporate level or whatever it might be, into the greater puzzle could be more helpful. 32:51 'Cause like you said, it's so funny, like every time we interview a scientist, one of their, uh, specific action steps that we ask for, they're always like, "Tell your congresspeople to just vote for more basic science funding." 33:01 'Cause you're right, like that opens up everything. But I also wonder if this mission-oriented approach can be helpful. I agree that being goal-oriented is key, right? 33:08 And I mean, I would point out that, that while the US, 33:12 w- a, you know, a major funder of basic research in the United States is the Department of Defense, and what you just described is, is very close to the model for DARPA. Sure. And DARPA gets results. Yeah. So I agree. 33:27 Like if you have a very particular goal, right? I mean, sometimes it's, it's-- this is why, you know, businesses do so much, 33:35 y-you know, if not innovation, at least commercialization in the US is because, you know, like they're founded by these quirky people who like wake up one day and they're like, "Hey, I really wanna reduce the cost of getting, 33:48 uh, satellites to space by a factor of 100." Mm-hmm. Or, you know what I mean? I could name, you know, 1,000 companies that I've covered over the years, and that's great. 33:57 But yeah, for the basic science, like, you know, frankly, I think DARPA does a great job of that. That's the reason that ARPA, right, which is the, the- Mm-hmm... 34:05 the, the energy version of that, was sort of modeled on that as well. Mm-hmm. 34:09 Like I think that's great, and then I think you have tons of investors now who, you know, have more money than anything because there's just so much sloshing around who are, who are ready to kinda make these risky bets as well. 34:23 Like, I mean, that's why, like I mentioned, you know, Sam Altman's like, "I'm gonna put $375 million into [laughs] one startup." [upbeat music] Hey, it's Quinn. 34:39 One of my favorite things about this job is to not actually do this job. Stick with me. Sometimes you get a sign-off. You know what I mean? 34:48 When I'm forcing myself to not think about climate change or malaria, I'm usually cooking, eating, downloading apps, listening to music, or reading dragon smut, and every month, I share my favorite updates on these in a members-only newsletter called Not Important. 35:04 If you wanna receive it, head to importantnotimportant.com/upgrade, or just click the link in your show notes to start your free 30-day membership trial. 35:13 [upbeat music] That's huge, right? Yeah. That's a super high-risk thing for a single investor- Mm-hmm... to do. 35:30 Um, so yeah, I agree. Like it, it should be sort of goal-oriented in that way. But I also- But, you know- Go, go ahead... basic science also kind of gets us the grist that, uh, it can be transformed into that. 35:41 Sure, and it doesn't need to be black or white by any sense. But I al- uh, you know, there is, like you were saying, DAR-DARPA does get results. It has forever. 35:47 I mean, half the things in my office right now like have roots in DARPA, turtles all the way down, no question. Um, and you can try to fight against that or try to fight against, "We didn't need the space shuttles." 35:58 It's like, well, y- now you have Uber, so you're welcome, you know? Um, so it's, it's interesting to me because it, it doesn't have to be black or white. 36:07 But we have these, and I often thought of like, again, I went to like a liberal arts college where it was just like nine people in a class and you just ask a bunch of questions. But... 36:14 And, you know, m- higher education has [laughs] certainly has its pros and cons these days. 36:19 But I often thought about this idea of like how do we reframe some college majors as instead of just like political science or religion or whatever into likeYou know, water scarcity. 36:29 And then, like, what are all the different elements that you can, that you need to take to go into that? Like, identifying these larger societal problems. Again, whether it's, like, Jimmy Carter chasing... 36:37 And he's like, "I'm going to eradicate guinea worms," right? 36:41 Or we're looking at malaria and, you know, you can pay two bucks and it saves a life, and bed nets, and you've got these highly effective things, and they're great. 36:48 But, you know, we've got the basic science on one hand, and now how do we apply this mission philosophy to identify a, a societal thing and just go after it? And, and the reason I [laughs] I- as much as it excites me, 37:02 when I think about how we're gonna do that with de-carbonization, which is this humanity-wide goal, is we had a humanity-wide goal this year, which was to inoculate the entire population of the planet, and we're kinda not doing that. 37:16 Um, you know, there's, we've been stuck at four billion people unvaccinated for a couple months now. And that, I guess, gets into less about the technological innovation and more about 37:27 humanity's innate instincts to go, you know, what does investment really mean, and how are we gonna apply it, and who, who... To go to the top, like, who benefits from innovation? Like, what does progress really mean? 37:39 And if, like, if we couldn't pass this specific test, like, how are we gonna apply that to some of these other things? Yeah. 37:45 And, and I mean, l- let's be clear, like, you know, religion, philosophy, et cetera, are cognitive technologies. And I mean, good luck trying to change human nature, but we are flexible as a species. 38:01 I do think that we could probably spend a lot more time thinking about, how do we build better cognitive technologies and ways to organize ourselves? 38:14 You know, I mean, I feel like during the Obama years there was a little bit of that where people were like, "Oh, have you heard the behavioral economists have this whole concept of, like, nudging people into doing the right thing?" 38:26 And, like, that's fine, but, like, you know, we are still the same people who, you know, not so long ago were wearing animal pelts and- Mm-hmm... you know, making human and animal sacrifices on the solstice. 38:40 Like, we are still very much ideologically driven beings and, you know, there, there's always a war for ideas going on and, um, probably we need more people willing to, um, kind of f- fight that battle in a, in a conscientious way. 38:57 Yeah. Who knows? But it's so funny, you make such a good point. [laughs] Like, and this ties back to, like, innovation and, and, and four billion years of evidence and, and this and that. 39:05 Because, like, you know, the dawn of the industrial age really not so long ago. You know? It's literally, like, Peaky Blinders. And we have both made incredible advances and innovations along that timescale. 39:17 We fucked the place up pretty good along the way. There's been some enormous trade-offs. 39:22 But it's, it's interesting because you're, you know, when you say like, uh, you know, we're, we were, we're, we're not so far off from animal pelts, like, chronologically we're really not. 39:31 And so you empathize a little bit with these primal instincts and, and programming that we have to act a certain way and protect ourselves and our family, and our investments, or whatever it might be, uh, to hoard lifesaving vaccines during a pandemic, whatever it might be. 39:48 But we are on the cusp of, of, of, you know, the receipts coming due for, for a lot of these choices we've made. 39:56 And so it does require a l- you know, less nudging at times and more, uh, you know, again, y- you hate to throw the word regulation out there, uh, uh, because it'll just piss people off. But 40:07 w- we, [laughs] we have to make some better choices and- Well, I, by the way, I think that that's a complete myth. People love regulation, I don't care who you are. 40:15 Like, there's, like, 10% of the political constituency of the world is actually a diehard libertarian. But like- Sure... liberal, conservative, I don't care what your- Sure... 40:25 political orientation is, they all love regulation. It's just they can't agree on what direction [laughs] they want to regulate- Sure... things in. Yeah. And that's why bipartisanship is so hard. 40:35 But to get back to the earlier point you were making, like, yeah, like, we're more sophisticated than ever. There was this thing that happened called the Enlightenment. Right. 40:43 It can feel some days like we're backsliding from that. 40:46 But I do think that w- we do need m- more people kind of articulating new sets of values about how we sort of conduct ourselves as global citizens, and how we use all this power and this technology in, you know, ways that kind of better our lot. 41:02 And, um, you know, maybe I'm an idealist but, like, I, I still think that, like, rationality can, can help b- uh, orchestrate that. If not actually, like, organize people. 41:11 Like, I, I, as much as, um, I get annoyed by his antics, like, I think one of the really brilliant things about Elon Musk is that, like, he is kind of constantly just, 41:23 like, trolling the world into making the things happen that he wants. Mm-hmm. I mean, he's a little bit like Donald Trump in that way. He's also- Sure... just kind of a, an amazing meme lord- Right... 41:32 and sort of manipulator of people's ideologies. But, um, you know, we're not gonna, like, uh... I don't think we're going to k- k- kind of, you know, calmly and rationally, um, convince people to 41:47 do the things that are required to, like, make l- life persist on this planet in the face of climate change. Like, I think it's gonna be, uh, a lot messier and it's gonna require a lot more sloganeering. For sure. 41:58 Uh, we desperately need better and more sloganeering, there's no doubt. We've, we've been pretty bad at that for a while. 42:03 I mean, uh, but like you said, I mean, there, there is a reason folks like Donald Trump and Elon Musk, um, for, for all their very many pros and cons, like, h- how many corporate and government leaders throughout history have basically been either one of those but haven't had fucking Twitter, you know? 42:20 Haven't... And, and this is, like, the, the super fun side of social media. Yeah. What would, uh, what would, what would Rockefeller do if he'd had Twitter? Or Vanderbilt- Right... for that matter. 42:26 I mean, it's, it's the ultimate, like, don't meet your heroes kinda thing. You know? It's, uh... I mean, I'm, I'm, I'm from Virg- I'm from colonial Williamsburg. 42:32 Like, you know, you can, you can idolize, like, some of these things as much as you want, but it turns out, like, most of these guys, like, not great. But complicated. 42:40 Like, they, they did some great things and that's why, you know-Focusing on, less on people and more on, on ideas and what progress means to more people is probably helpful. 42:49 Um- Yeah, what if Alexander Hamilton had, had Twitter, right? Would we have gotten the Federalist Papers or would he have just, like- Yeah... whipped up people on [laughs] social media? Right. No, 100%. 42:59 I mean, there was a point where he was like, "I don't know, maybe we should have a king." Like, uh, yeah, we can, we can dig into that. Like, it's, it's, uh... They're, they're complicated, complicated dudes. 43:07 But it also makes me think of, like, coming back to this, like, the, the nullify, uh, nullifying of, of sort of the, the great man theory through this research is like... 43:18 And all this money floating around, like we're, we're saying and, like, how that could be re- repurposed. 43:22 Like, I wonder, uh, you know, w- when you're, when you're a, a VC or an angel investor or whatever, a corporate VC looking, and there are sort of these standard boxes you try to check when you're deciding if you're gonna make an investment, right? 43:33 It's like, is there... How big is the market? Does this person have market fit? Is there a, is there a product at all? Is this a founder with, with passion who gets it? Yada, yada. And I just wonder, like, 43:44 how much do these, quote, unquote, like, general founders actually not have as much of an impact as your standard investors might really think. Because it seems like through the research that 43:56 it's going to keep going no matter what. Maybe slightly different in smaller scales, like, along the way, but it's, you know, it's like looking at California's collection of 90-degree days every year. 44:06 It's, you've got ups and downs, but over time it's like this. Sure. But I mean, if, if innovation is comprised of many, many people working together and 44:18 f- making n- n- new breakthroughs on their own and building new companies, you know, it's... The, the impact is cumulative. Sure. 44:25 So you should still be a founder, you should still be an innovator, you should still be an investor because it is the aggregate of all of that activity that ultimately makes- Right... a difference. 44:35 The bad news is nobody gets to save the world. The good news is- [laughs]... everyone gets to save the world a little bit. Sure. So I think it's a shift of, of mindset. 44:44 Like, if, you know, we're all raised on, like, a certain type of, you know, Western individualism and superhero movies and all that bullshit, and, like, you just have to kinda get a little more 44:57 zen about it and be like, "I am a tiny cog in a giant machine." Sure. "And it... But I better perform my role." Yeah. It's more of a collectivist mindset, but I just think that's actually how [laughs] civilization works. 45:10 [gentle music] Hey, everyone, it's Quinn. Have you ever looked around your job and thought, "What are we even doing here?" 45:20 If you've ever wanted to take your skills to more impactful work, to do world-changing work, let me tell you now's the time. With just one click, you can find a job that does that work at importantjobs.com. 45:35 Important Jobs is for journalists, students, engineers, software developers, accountants, designers, nurses, research assistants, people who wanna work in clean energy, consumer products, health tech, agriculture, and artificial intelligence. 45:52 And if you work for a company or organization already doing that work, you can list your open roles at Important Jobs for competitive rates and get them in front of our entire community. 46:03 Reinvigorate your career on the frontlines of the future at importantjobs.com. Back to the show. 46:13 One of my biggest frustrations with the, uh, the, the, the movement to slow the climate crisis is, is just the, uh, overwhelming prevalence of, of gatekeepers. 46:25 And I understand and empathize with people who've, like, been doing this for a long time. The OGs who are like, "We need to do this, this, and this, and nothing else." The world has cha... 46:32 We haven't done those things for the most part. We've done some things. Uh, you know, Robinson Meyer wrote about the, the green vortex that's been kind of working in the background. 46:40 There's other things we need to do, but there's other things that are newly available. But, you know, I think about, like you were saying, like, everyone has to do their little bit. It's not just... 46:49 You know, one of the big arguments is, like, it's not personal actions, it's only systemic shit that matters. And other people are like, "Systemic shit-" Yeah. 46:54 I gotta, I gotta cut you off because I've been thinking about this for a decade. No, please. And I think we're actually at a turning point. I think that entire debate is moot. 47:01 You can just put it in a pine box and, and toss- I mean-... it off your ship into the ocean. I couldn't be more excited. And here's why. Here's why. 47:09 The, the things that are actually gonna make a difference to, like, saving the planet are- Yeah... already out of the hands of all those gatekeepers and all those environmentalists. Yeah. 47:16 So all the innovations that are coming, all the investment, that is in the hands of people like the CEO of Ford Motor Company who's like, "You know what? I'm finally gonna commit to getting- Yeah... 47:27 Americans to buy, you know, electric trucks." It's in the hands of the people who are building out the charging infrastructure. 47:32 It's in the hands of the investors who are, like, kind of arm wrestling the US into getting more offshore wind. Sure. It's in the hands of the innovators who are building, you know, nuclear fusion. 47:42 Like, while all those people are having debates on social media and Twitter and gatekeeping each other, I'm fine with that because, like, good. That... 47:48 D- Go, fight amongst yourselves, keep each other busy, and just, like, stay out of the way while the grown-ups do the actual work. 47:54 Now, that's a very dismissive way to phrase it, but what I mean is there are different phases in the transition between a social movement and a full civilization-wide, like, technological movement. Sure. 48:06 You need all of these, like, dyed-in-the-wool people who have been, you know, very Cassandra style, ringing the alarm bells about climate change and everything else for the longest time, to get the initial ball rolling of innovation and incentives. 48:23 For sure. And let's not forget that, like, you know, f- activists have done amazing things, like gotten Nixon, of all presidents, to create the EPA. Yeah. 48:33 The Clean Water Act was one of the best things that's ever happened in this country. To everybody. People don't even know it- Yeah... because rivers aren't catching fire anymore, and we just get to take that for granted. 48:41 Right. 48:41 But that was a thing that happened before the Clean Water ActAnd, you know, or all of the incentives for electric cars and all the big loans that came out of the government which allowed a company like Tesla to exist in the first place. 48:53 Tesla wouldn't exist if they hadn't gotten hundreds of millions of dollars in federal loans, nor would all of these companies, car companies, be working so hard on rolling out electric vehicles if California and then federal y- car emission standards weren't just twisting the screws more and more to the point where they looked at their fleets and they're like, "We cannot continue to sell vehicles unless a significant portion, and eventually all of them, are electric because there's no other way to meet these emission standards. 49:20 We can't do it with internal combustion engines." Sure. And now you have these promises that are meeting... being made at, you know, COP in Glasgow, and who knows if those will amount to anything. 49:29 But we're already at the point where the most valuable energy company in the world is in Spain, and it's a renewable energy company. Yeah. 49:38 And ExxonMobil is shrinking and saying, "We're gonna get into the carbon capture and storage business." All that started initially because of all these in- gatekeeping environmentalists- Yeah... 49:47 but at this point, they can just go, like, whatever, pet their comfort animals and eat their fake meat, and everyone else, the, uh, rest of the society, whether they will admit it or not, is adopting their ideology. 50:03 They won. They won. Right. Fake meat is at Burger King now. Yeah. [laughs] You can buy an electric F-150- Yeah... today. There- You can get on the waiting list. 50:12 There's a million other things that are happening because people are like, "Oh, shit, we can make money at this." And look- Right... 50:17 I know a lot of people are waiting for the socialist revolution, but until that happens, the engines of capital are, like, groaning into action, and trillions of dollars of capital is being deployed to make this happen, whatever all those other gatekeepers wanna say about it. 50:33 Yeah, and I do... I... Look, I, I, I fully agree. Like, the, the momentum is there. 50:37 Like, you can, you can now buy, I mean, literally in the last, like, 18 months, like, seven different version of plant-based chicken nuggets that are fucking fantastic. Like, how long have I been waiting for that? 50:47 That's great. Like, I, I dropped meat 10 years ago, and it was, it was awful. It was truly awful. 50:51 [laughs] And now it's just like, yeah, they're really great, and I eat so many of them 'cause my kids are really obnoxious. Yeah, kudos for being an early adopter because you're the one who told... 50:58 who showed those companies there is an audience for this. Sure. 51:01 And now your belief will spread, not because you convinced anybody else to believe as you believe, but because it's available, and it's affordable, and it's delicious. Yeah, and that's what matters. 51:12 I mean, I do empathize with, you know... Again, we, we... I sort of reframed how we look at things here- [laughs]... 51:18 as, as we call it, science for people who give a shit, about a year and a half ago because there's just more people who do, everyday people, for a huge variety of reasons. 51:26 Like, you have already been directly touched by COVID or climate or whatever it might be, or you're invested in clean energy, whatever it is. So we're the home for that shit. 51:34 But there are so many pe- as much as, like, the, the levers have been pulled and so many of these things are happening because of the longtime OGs and gatekeepers have been doing it, like, thank you, you can, you can just en- enjoy this now. 51:47 Yes, we need to move faster, and yes, we need to do more, and yes, there's, like, predatory delay from, like, the last of the fucking oil and coal barons who are throwing their last money at lobbying. 51:56 But- Right, like, Manchin literally owns a, a coal company in West Virginia and is, and is blocking the next- Right... bill that we're supposed to get- Right... which is supposed to be Biden's big climate action bill. 52:08 Right. Like, there is substantial irony and tragedy in that. Yes. 100%. Those gatekeepers- You just, like- Those kinds... Those are the [laughs] gatekeepers you gotta worry about. Oh, yeah. No, for sure. 52:17 That's wh- and that's the thing is, like, we have to overcome those, but I do wanna... 52:20 I do empathize and, like, wanna constructively help those people who are new to this thing, who are just like, "What the fuck do I do?" And it's hard to say, like, "The wheels are in motion. Like, it's happening. 52:29 Like, just, you know, enjoy your chicken, your fake chicken nuggets." 52:32 You know, it's like they, they do wanna have a role in this thing, and they do wanna participate, and a lot of them will become founders or academics or fucking journalists or writers or designers. 52:41 And my answer usually when people are like, "What can I do?" is, "Well, you know, Chris, like, what can you do? Like, what are, what are, what are your passions? What are your skills? What are those things?" 52:49 'Cause we do need those things, and you do need them on, like, the local level. Like, Los Angeles finally voted, I mean, fucking finally voted two weeks ago to, 53:00 to put a buffer in between new oil drills and schools and houses. And you're like, are you fuck- like, we just did that, but also it's, like, only the new ones. 53:08 There are so many that are still going, like, literally next to, like, Black kids' schools in Los Angeles. They have horrible asthma. Like, they don't sleep at night. It's hotter, yada, yada. 53:16 And so I do think those sort of, again, to use the word, like, collective actions matter 'cause, like, your personal actions, like, don't really do shit on the system level except to make you feel a little better. 53:28 It is the actions that, like, will build momentum to add up to building those buffers, to buying more fucking Teslas, which now makes Ford go like, "Well, I guess, all right, I guess we'll make an F-150," and also, by the way, like, make it seemingly awesome. 53:40 And now you've got tons of pre-orders. Like, that shit does matter. So I am interested in getting this new generation to, you know, use the most leveraged ways to 53:50 affect those fixes, whether they're societal, technological, or, or whatever it might be. Um- Yeah, and by the way, the number of... the best way to get leverage is to be incredibly focused and not overly ambitious. 54:04 I think that we live in a time where we're sort of saturated by media 54:09 and calls to pay attention to this issue or that issue or whatever else, but the moment when w- we sort of shut out the 99% of calls for our attention except for the one thing that we are truly really passionate about and feel like we can make a difference in terms of, that's when you gain real power. 54:28 Yeah. Because whatever that issue is, it doesn't matter how narrow it is. I'll give you one quick example. There's... I'm actually wearing a shirt right now. You probably can't see it, but it's Glenn to the Goodwich. 54:38 [laughs] This is a shirt. This is a fundraiser, and it is for a trash wheel, and most people don't know what a trash wheel is 'cause it's a local thing. I live in the Mid-Atlantic on the Chesapeake. 54:49 There was this one eccentric inventorAnd, uh, there's actually a great, like, um [smacks lip] I think CNET documentary about him. 54:58 And he just l- he was like, "Ah, there's all this trash flowing into the Baltimore's Inner Harbor. How can I deal with this?" He's not especially technically skilled, but he is very stubborn. 55:08 And he invented this thing that it's powered by like w- we- uh, sorry, currents and, uh, solar power that uses renewable energy. It sits at the mouth of all these rivers that go into the various harbors around here. 55:21 And it just literally has a conveyor belt that just sucks up trash and dumps them into these big dumpsters, which are then emptied periodically. 55:30 And these things have intercepted, I think, over their past five years, now there's four of them- Mm-hmm... 55:36 millions of pounds of trash, to the point where you can like walk around my part of the Chesapeake now, and there's noticeably less trash. And it was this one dude's sort of weird tilting at windmills 20-year quest. 55:51 Right. But he was focused enough to make it happen and then pair with a, an organization that like gave him the grants. And this is not like radical technology. Right. 56:00 It's just that this guy was like, "Let's take what we have and imply, apply it intelligently to this problem." And now 56:07 people all over the world, cities all over the world are like, "Will you build us a trash wheel, and we'll put it here?" In like Ecuador and this and that and fucking other things. Right. And it's like, wow. 56:15 Like, we have this huge problem with ocean trash. This guy came up with a workable solution. It's mechanically not complicated. That's one of its virtues. But he had that focus. And now, you know, this guy could 56:30 n- not single-handedly, but sort of through his actions, eventually like eliminate like the Texas-sized Pacific garbage patch- Right... you know, once all that stuff finally sinks. 56:39 So I could give you 100 examples like this- Sure... 'cause I talk to people like this all day long. But when someone focuses on whatever issue they care about, whether it's, 56:49 you know, y- you know, gender equity or racial equity or education or, you know, women's access to adequate healthcare or, you know, any of these technological things we're talking about, 57:03 people can make a huge difference because most of us are just kind of trying to survive. Yeah. And if we care about things at all, 57:15 as humans, I think our great weakness is we feel this incredibly strong drive to keep up appearances and be like, "Well, I know the correct language to use in this social context so I can appear to be enlightened." 57:29 But it's like, cool, but like, you know, what have you actually done for the disempowered group whom you are trying to not offend with your- Right... choice of words in this moment? Right. 57:40 I feel like most people just spend most of their time, even if they care about this stuff, just trying to maintain appearances instead of trying to do something of substance. No, fully, and I empathize. 57:51 Like a- at any given time, I can probably name... And, and forgetting like all of this work, like I probably know like two friends of friends with like a fucking GoFundMe for medical bills. 58:00 Like, we're all being pulled in 10,000 different directions because like [laughs] Yeah... so many of these systems are fucked. So I do empathize with this like idea of like, "W- what can I do? 58:07 I'm supposed to do everything." And being scattered, I can tell you day to day, like with three kids, it's not helpful. You don't get shit done. Focus like really does matter. 58:16 And the good news is like when I say to people like, "Okay, so Chris, like what can you do? What are your skills, your interests, your passions, or what did you like in seventh grade science?" 58:23 That matters because also, there's already incredible people and groups who are doing that one specific thing. 58:30 And you can either fucking donate to them or volunteer with them or join them, whatever it is, and use that leverage, 'cause they already probably know some of these best practices and ways to get in there. 58:40 But like you said, like the trash wheel, I mean, a news last week, there's a young, uh, Black woman who's now I think a b- in high school, but she's in college now. 58:48 You know, she used like beets to develop sutures that change colors when they're infected. 'Cause like 30% of deliveries in, in 88 African countries, uh, maternal deliveries, uh, end up being infected. 59:01 And you're like, "Fucking beets? Like that's, that's it?" But like, you just never know. She's not gonna scale that, but there are so many organizations that are like, "Oh my, wait a minute. Oh my God." 59:09 Like [laughs] "Like, holy shit." And that's that little point that matters because there are people that care, there are people that are really focused on those things, and it does matter. 59:17 I mean, this is the opportunity of having so much shit that we need to fix and that we can fix because of the time and everything that's gone into these innovations, uh, is that you can apply yourself in, in, in a huge variety of ways. 59:30 But like you said, sort of picking those things, making sure they're measurable and that they matter and that you give a shit about them is what's gonna make you actually have some application to your, your, whether it's your fury or your passion. 59:43 Right. And, and, and, and, and, and I, and, and, you know, and sometimes that's a completely abstract thing. 59:50 So I mean, I, I just listened to, uh, an interview with, um, I think her name is Lilly Singh, and she is, you know, a self-described creator. She's a creator and a comedian on YouTube. 1:00:01 And like, you know, she's not gonna solve world hunger, but what animates her is she's like, "I grew up watching movies and TV where there was nobody who looked like me, and now people come up to me all the time, and they're like, 'My little sibling thinks it's totally normal that you're famous and you're doing movies,' and all this other stuff as a result of her YouTube fame." 1:00:22 Yeah. "And now I feel like, you know, I'm no longer invisible." So, you know, bully for her. Like, her- Yeah... 1:00:29 her thing that she decided to focus on that animated her was representation, and her vehicle was becoming a creator. 1:00:35 It, it- I think it's easy to like, be like, oh, you know, people who are just making videos all day long for YouTube, that's frivolous. Like, what's the point? 1:00:42 But no, she's actually [laughs] made a big impact by her own account. 100%. 100%. Um, and you know, the flip side to that is like America has, uh, for all the incredible... 1:00:52 You know, if you look at sort of the...The top 10, 25, whatever companies on the S&P or NASDAQ or whatever it might be or, uh, I mean, how many of them are headed up or were founded by immigrants? 1:01:03 And like, but but for whatever reason, like we've stopped doing as many [laughs] of those, those green cards and the, and the research be- And you're just like, "But, but it's so important for people to see those people," whether they're running YouTube videos or, or whatever it might be, you know? 1:01:15 It, it, it does matter. So if that's your thing, then, then, then that's great. Again, like find your thing that you can do and do well and, and apply it and it'll matter. I wanna get you out of here. 1:01:26 Uh, I'm gonna ask you one question we ask everybody. Chris, fir- I mean, first of all, thank you for your, your time and your expertise. I feel like I... this could be like a four-hour conversation. 1:01:34 Um, but what is a book, uh, you've read this year, can't say your own, that has opened your mind to something you hadn't considered before or has actually changed your thinking in some way? 1:01:45 And we've got, you know, 100 and plus books up on a bookshop list, and we'll throw it on there. So actually, the book that I just... There's a bunch because [laughs] I'm an avid reader, but- Yeah... 1:01:56 one that I'm really, really loving that I feel like has not gotten nearly enough attention, uh, I think because it just came out, but, but this one I think is a sleeper hit. 1:02:06 I'm predicting this is gonna be one of the most influential books of the next 10 years. So you heard it here first. Please. It's, uh, by an academic and also gifted writer named Beth Shapiro. Okay. 1:02:19 And it's called Life As We Made It, and here's what's unique about this book. She is an expert in ancient DNA- Okay... who successfully articulates the following thesis. Uh-huh. 1:02:35 We should get elbow-deep in doing everything we can with biotech to pr- you know, preserve life on earth, our own and that of the many species that we now have the power to manipulate because there's really no such thing as nature because we've been manipulating it for tens of thousands of years. 1:02:54 And as an ancient DNA specialist, she has the receipts to prove it. 1:02:58 So she takes you on this wild journey from like 100,000 years ago to, you know, potentially 1,000 years in the future, and she totally sticks the landing. 1:03:09 And, and, uh, you know, she's not just some random know-nothing journalist like me. Like, she's been studying this for decades. 1:03:16 So this is the best introduction to, and I think almost like a rallying cry for, you know, our future on Earth as, you know, sort of m- masters of synthetic biology. Yeah. It'll change your mind. 1:03:30 This book will change your mind no matter what your belief systems are because there's so many kind of unorthodox conclusions in it that she really buttresses quite well. That's amazing. I'll throw it on the list. 1:03:42 I will immediately read it and probably email her to come on the show right after. Um [laughs] - [laughs] She would be a great guest, I'm sure... but, but that's amazing. I mean, it... 1:03:49 [sighs] Look, o- of course things can be... 1:03:51 Uh, you don't have to go too far down the Monsanto like Wikipedia hole to, to see that like things can be done in a, in a, in a negligent, poor/worse way than, than they should be done, uh, in a huge variety of ways. 1:04:04 But it's also- Sure. I mean, you can use nuclear power to eradicate a city, or you can use it to create carbon-free energy. It's up to you. Sure. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, we... Look, we're humans. 1:04:12 Like, we're gonna fuck it up, but we can also do in- incredible things. And, you know, it's, it's, it's like how I feel when we talk about, uh, you know, I, I'll, I'll never buy GMO foods. 1:04:22 It's like, I hate to break it to you, but like corn didn't used to look like this. [laughs] Yeah. It, it used to have- That's one of her first examples. It's a great example. Yeah. Yeah, it didn't use to look like this. 1:04:31 Like, vegetables used to be m- you know, this and that. It's like s- s- this is... Sorry, it's been happening this entire time. That's like, that's just what we do, and that's what we've done. 1:04:40 And also, that's why we have like rice that's more available to way more people than used to be. But the point is, uh, I'm interested, and I'm gonna dig into it, and I'm very excited. 1:04:48 It has eight Amazon reviews, so we're gonna bump that up. Yeah. Uh, that's very exciting. Well, listen, man, I, I can't thank you enough for your time today. This has been, uh, fantastic. 1:04:58 We might have to do another one at some point. But, uh, thank you for all your work you do. Can you give a shout-out to where folks can find you online, but also at the journal and such? Yeah. 1:05:08 I mean, just go to mims.club. It's my [laughs]- That's amazing... it's my universal- Hold on. [laughs] That's my redirect. I just, just... It always... I think right now it redirects to my book. [laughs] mims.club. 1:05:21 I need to- Oh, wait. Can we give a real plug- I need-... for your book too? 'Cause we touched on it a little bit, but- Yeah. 1:05:24 So my book is called Arriving Today: From Factory to Front Door and Why Everything Has Changed About How and What We Buy. You know, it's about e-commerce. It's about supply chains. 1:05:33 It's also about automation and the present and future of work. Mm-hmm. 1:05:37 So if you're interested in any of those topics, you know, hopefully the, uh, price of the book is worth, worth it for you 'cause it's a, it's a bunch of different chapters on all these different subjects. 1:05:47 And we'll definitely... We'll put that in the show notes and on the book club list as well. And, and, I mean, uh, again, folks, it's like how we were all trapped in our living rooms for a year. 1:05:55 If you didn't think science was, like, affecting your life, it does. 1:05:57 And if you didn't think, you know, these supply chain issues are affecting your life, like try ordering your Christmas presents later than like next week, and you'll discover that you should probably read Chris' book. 1:06:08 That's awesome. mims.club is just... Goddammit, that's great. [laughs] Uh, that's really great. So, [laughs] we will have everybody follow you and, and hound you and, and check everything out. 1:06:19 So, uh, thank you for your time, man. I really, really appreciate it. And, uh, yeah, we'll, we'll do it again sometime soon. Yeah, looking forward to it. 1:06:28 [outro music] Thanks to our incredible guest today, and thanks to all of you for tuning in. 1:06:35 We hope this episode has made your commute or awesome workout or dishwashing or fucking dog walking late at night that much more pleasant. 1:06:43 As a reminder, please subscribe to our free email newsletter at importantnotimportant.com. It is all the news most vital to our survival as a species. And you can follow us all over the internet. 1:06:54 You can find us on Twitter @importantnotimp. Ugh, just so weird. Also on Facebook and Instagram @importantnotimportant. Pinterest and Tumblr, the same thing. So check us out, follow us, share us, like us. 1:07:07 You know the deal. And please subscribe to our show wherever you listen to things like this. And if you're really fucking awesome, rate us on Apple Podcasts. Keep the lights on. Thanks. Please. 1:07:17 And you can find the show notes from today right in your little podcast player and at our website, importantnotimportant.com. 1:07:24 Thanks to the very awesome Tim Blaine for our jammin' music, to all of you for listening, and finally, most importantly, to our moms for making us. Have a great day. Thanks, guys. 1:07:37 [outro music] That's it for this week's conversation. 1:07:53 For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing, thanks for leaving a review, and thanks for giving a shit. 1:08:15 [outro music]