Transcript 0:00 Hey, folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important, Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company. 0:12 But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question. That is, what can I do? 0:18 It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost two hundred episodes now. So here we are, The Most Important Question. 0:29 Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. [upbeat music] Welcome to Important, Not Important. My name is Quinn Emmett, and this is science for people who give a shit. 0:47 A little while ago, I had a conversation with Dr. Madhukar Pai about vaccine equity. 0:54 In it, I tried to understand why and how developed countries were spending billions on COVID vaccine boosters, but so relatively little in low-income countries. 1:07 Not to say that nothing has been done, but it's a pretty clear-cut case where whatever we've done, however complex the system might be from soup to nuts, is nowhere near enough. 1:19 And I can't be more clear here, and I think we were in that conversation and we will today, that this will affect you. So we knew, and we still know, that the Delta variant was first identified in India. 1:35 We knew that Omicron can be traced to South Africa and England and Botswana and even the US, possibly from an immunocompromised person. 1:45 Right now, we're handing out about twenty million shots a day across the world, and yet about thirty-seven percent of the world's population, two point nine billion people, still haven't received a single shot. 2:01 Eighty-seven percent of low-income countries, the people in those countries, eighty-seven percent of them still haven't received a single shot. 2:12 The international organization that was supposed to shepherd this whole endeavor to work with governments around the world to vaccinate the world, COVAX has, however you squeeze it, failed. 2:26 And that's because of a number of reasons I think I understand, but I want to understand better so that we can all do something about it, which of course basically sums up the entire point of my conversations of this podcast. 2:39 Why didn't those countries get the chance to buy more mRNA shots? Why didn't we give them the intellectual property to develop them and, and produce them themselves? 2:49 Why didn't we ship them as many as we bought for ourselves when we had too many and continue to have too many? 2:55 Why didn't we help build distribution efforts in those countries when we knew so well how hard the routine vaccination process is there as it is? What did we learn from PEPFAR and George W. Bush? 3:12 I continue to want to understand better not only what the hell we're doing here now in the second year of vaccine availability, but how we got here, and not just in the past year plus, but historically with HIV and AIDS, with tuberculosis and malaria and Ebola and Zika, with extreme poverty. 3:32 I want to understand what it means for a more volatile today and tomorrow with real-world climate effects growing, when we need to urgently mitigate to prevent more heat and sea level rise and storms, when we need to adapt to what's already baked in, especially again in the Global South, where they've been feeling the very real effects of climate change already. 3:55 To understand what it means as we rush towards cleaner power, but also dismantle fossil fuel infrastructure and industry, but in a just transition, but still not fast enough for one to replace the other. 4:07 To understand why millions of folks in the Global South are still using wood stoves and feeling the air pollution effects of those because they don't have another choice. 4:19 I want to understand technically what the issues have been for this particular issue, but also as always, to extrapolate, to understand why we do what we do when it's so frankly morally corrupt and self-defeating, measurably, when it costs so many lives, and even when, again, all of the evidence tells us that it will come back to bite us. 4:44 We can do better, better. 4:48 My guest today is Gayle Smith, and Gayle served until recently as coordinator for Global COVID Response and Health Security at the Department of State in the United States and has recently returned to her role as the president and CEO of the ONE Campaign. 5:03 So in Gayle's history, she has served as a top advisor on development issues for two American presidents and is one of the world's leading experts on global development. 5:12 Prior to the ONE Campaign, prior to the State, Smith was the administrator of USAID, a huge role. 5:18 She led a staff of ten thousand people working to end extreme poverty, to foster sustained and inclusive economic growth, and promote resilient democratic societies all over the world. Complicated endeavor on its own. 5:30 Smith has also served as special assistant to President Obama and senior director for Development and Democracy at the National Security Council, where she helped lead the US and global response to the Ebola crisis, which we'll talk about today, um, in two thousand and fourteen and two thousand and fifteen, and also as special assistant to President Clinton and senior director for African Affairs at the National Security Council. 5:53 Very clear to me that if anyone can help me understand where the US in particular has fallen short of helpingTo vaccinate the world and get us out of this thing it's Gayle. 6:06 As a reminder, you can always send me questions, thoughts, or feedback at questions at importantnotimportant.com. You can find me on Twitter at quinnehmmett. 6:16 [upbeat music] Gayle Smith, welcome to the show. Thanks for having me. You're very welcome. 6:28 I'm honored and thankful that you're taking the time to help us understand this enormous complex beast that is trying to get the world just a little bit more vaccinated along the way. 6:38 Gayle, we'd like to start with one important question. It sets a tone a little bit. It's a little bit tongue in cheek. We usually get something good after the guest cackles at me for a second. 6:47 So instead of tell us your life story, as interesting that as it is, I like to ask, Gayle, why are you vital to the survival of the species? And I encourage you to be bold and honest and however you wanna shake it. 6:59 Well Mm-hmm... I'm one of those who kind of believes nobody's indispensable, but if I were to say why am I vital, I'd say two things. Number one is 7:12 I'm one of those people who I think will leave the world better than where I found it in the places where I can have an impact, 7:20 and the second is I think I probably helped the shoe industry significantly in terms of job creation and productivity. I love that. 7:29 Even though who needs, who needs shoes during a pandemic, but, but I maintain my commitment. 7:34 We just moved across the country, and one of the things that made this back and forth we've been doing for the past few years work for my wife and I, we had three kids under three at one point, was- Oof... 7:43 pros and cons, Gayle. Pros and cons, believe me. If you're gonna order diapers, it's better just order for all of them. But was we basically had redundant wardrobes, my wife and I, because we're- Yeah... 7:53 adults and our ch- sizes don't change, and then we moved, and we realized we had two wardrobes, and so all I've... Like you said, who needs shoes in pandemic? 7:59 I'm going through work clothes going, "Why do I ever need anything with buttons literally ever again? I don't think I do." E- exactly. I have a whole closet full of things... 8:07 I mean, I worked in the past in the White House and- Sure... recently took a break from the ONE Campaign to work in the state department. That stuff's now in the closet, and it's, it's like where is that gonna go? Yeah. 8:18 I asked- Why does one need anything other than sneakers? I sent my wife a text the other day, and I said, "Do you prefer the brown shoes or the black shoes?" And she's like, "Who cares?" 8:26 [laughs] I'm like, "Well, doesn't matter. Grab your all brands- Exactly... and wear them to whatever thing." There are no rules anymore. Thank you for your honest answer. So let's get to this thing a little bit again. 8:37 I wanna try to really understand this better. I try to, as I tell people, get a 201 or a 301 on these things before the conversation, so it's more of a conversation, but I'm... 8:46 obviously, I don't have all of your incredible experience by any stretch. 8:51 Let's get to a place where our listeners, our community can get it and also try to continue to apply themselves in some way for the morality- Sure... 8:59 of it, for the billions of lives that are still out there at stake, and because it is the only drivable way to really move to a different stage of this. So we have had... It is March apparently somehow already. 9:11 It has been 15 months maybe since we've had an assortment of vaccines available to the public, and yet 9:20 at that point, where I think checking our world and data this morning, about 37% of the world's population still does not have a single shot, and 87% of people in low-income countries still haven't received a single shot. 9:33 I want to be as comprehensive and truthful as we can be about this, though. 9:38 I mean, these vaccines, at least, for instance, the mRNA ones, which have taken decades of work among an amazing scientist and federal government dollars to get them there, the speed at which they were made available, the efficacy of these things- It's just phenomenal... 9:50 they are truly... People have stopped me when I've said this, but I, I do believe it's true. They are among our greatest achievements, full stop. 9:57 No one expected these in any stretch before 18 months from when we got to work, at the very least, because that's just not how these things have worked historically. But here we are. We are 15-ish months later. 10:07 37% of the world doesn't have a shot. That's almost 3 billion people. 87% low-income countries don't have a single shot. After your work the past year, are those the numbers you expected in March 2022? 10:22 They're the numbers I feared. I was hopeful that we would be able to galvanize the world to adjust those somewhat. I mean, given the way the system's built, I think it's fair to assume there's gonna be a disparity. 10:36 There's a built-in disparity between coverage in wealthy countries and coverage in low-income countries. 10:43 That it's a gap as enormous as it is, is I think a product of the fact that the world hasn't yet come together in such a way as to get that balance. Let's take a step back. Why did you come back to government work? 10:58 Obviously, with the ONE Campaign, you know, you, you, you work with any number of them, but w- why did you decide- Right... to come back to the State Department to do this work the past year? So there I was. 11:07 Okay, I did eight years in the Obama administration, and in the last couple years, I was the administrator of the US Agency for International Development. 11:14 Fantastic job, and one of the things I worked on during that administration was the Ebola epidemic, which- Yeah... I imagine most people remember. It was frightening. It was alarming. 11:24 Three countries just totally besieged by a lethal and really ugly virus, right? So there was a big international effort led by the US and African partners to tamp that down. 11:35 I joined ONE 'cause it had been so effective when I was in government, and I had the opportunity to lead it, so I, I seized it. I had not anticipated going back into government. 11:45 Having served twice, I was ready to do what I was doing, but then I got a call from the secretary of state, who is the secretary of state. Sure. He's also a very nice guy. Seems pleasant. 11:55 I mean, I've known Tony Blinken for a long time. He's a really decent... really, really decent human being, and he saidHey, could you please come back and do this? 12:05 This was help ramp up the US response to the pandemic and help within the department sort of lay the ground for the work that's gonna have to transpire over the coming years on what's called global health security. 12:18 How do we get ready for these things in the future so we don't repeat what we've all been through for the last two plus years? And I hemmed and hawed, and I said I would do it on a temporary basis, get it stood up, 12:32 uh, that I'd come in for six months. I stayed for eight. I'm glad to have done it. It's an area I have worked in, I know the players, I know the agencies, I know the tools, I know the budget, so it was kind of a natural. 12:44 Mm-hmm. So I was asked, and to anybody who's never done it, public service is also something... It's inspiring. It's an opportunity, and it's also something that if somebody asks you to serve, it's very hard to say no. 13:00 I appreciate that perspective, certainly. A number of friends I'm, I'm literally drinking... My friend is a submarine captain, and I'm drinking from... I got a mug when I visited. There you go. Um, I... 13:10 Every time I think my work-life balance or travel or whatever it might be is complicated- Right... I think about the fact that he's had two Halloweens with his kids in twelve years or whatever it might be, and- Wow... 13:20 growing up in this area, which is just filled with military and, and all kinds of things like that- Mm-hmm... and friends in the government. It... You just, I find you, you say yes, and it makes an impression. 13:28 It's like how everybody should be a waiter at some point in their life. Yeah. Just understand how to treat people. [chuckles] How to serve. How to serve, exactly. Exactly. 13:36 Not to reduce your enormous complex years of service, but why do you feel like they came to you with this? Everyone in the world's vulnerable. We're trying to make these new vaccines into old vaccines. 13:50 We're trying to figure out how to distribute them, one administration to the other, profound lacks of trust, but also expectations. We're dealing with climate. We're dealing with all these things. Right. 14:00 Why do you think they came to you to say, "How can we build this thing?" 14:04 I mean, in many ways, it was a bit of a natural choice, having run USAID, having been one of the leads in the response to Ebola, but I also have a long history of working on crises- Mm... 14:14 whether they are conflicts or famines or earthquakes or health crises. So I think it was somebody who had the combination of the experience, the skills, could hit the ground running because our government's complex. 14:30 I mean, there's a ton of agencies, a ton of rules, lots of mechanics, who does what, who's got jurisdiction, what's allowed, what's not allowed, and somebody who I think within the administration and externally has a reputation, I think, as a team player. 14:44 Because when you go to work on Ebola, right? Right. Or any, any of these crises, we had Zika, we had now COVID, any of these things, they're gonna keep happening. 14:52 If there's anything I've learned from all my new infectious disease friends in the past couple years, it's we've gotta- Get ready for more... keep better at seeing these coming, right? They've been saying it forever. 15:00 They're like, "Look, th-this is what I told you because of these," both in ways, uh, whether it's where we're living in built environments, right, or it's the enormous societal and economic fault lines that are just built into the power structures, and so that's why different people have suffered because of these things once we're exposed to it, whatever it might be. 15:18 When you go to work on one of these things, it's not, "I'm not just going to work on Ebola, I'm not going to work on Zika," unless you are literally, you know, Doctors Without Borders, right, Partners in Health. Right. 15:26 You're, you're on the ground doing that. Like you were saying, it's, it's about working on the machine that works sometimes, works in other times, so many competing interests, so many complications. 15:37 I'm curious, coming into that, about your expectations and at the end of your tenure, how much did it seem like top-down 15:47 vaccine equity, which is to say vaccinating the rest of the world if the end of this virus was everyone. 15:54 How much was vaccine equity realistically sort of day to day, week to week, a priority for the Biden administration from the top down? How did that compare to your expectations? 16:04 I think it was a big priority because the, the biggest focus, and you know, you work with a team, so- Mm... 16:09 but I was able to work on a number of things, but the big thing and the most urgent thing was ramping up increased vaccine delivery. So part of that was moving funds. 16:18 We were fortunate to have funding in the COVID response legislation from the Hill for international. So move that money quickly- Mm-hmm... 16:27 so the vaccines can be bought, and then we built this platform for sharing vaccines. I think as everybody knows, the US had and still has more vaccines than we need. Mm-hmm. So how could we share those? 16:39 And then the big decision, because even with sharing vaccines, even with increasing our financial contributions to buy vaccines through multilateral organizations to the billions plural, 16:52 there was still an acute shortage, so that's when we bought the first five hundred million and then the second, so a billion vaccines- Mm-hmm... to be donated immediately. So there was a real focus, I think, on 17:07 calibrating that balance between extensive coverage here and next to no coverage there. 17:12 I think the other thing that was in play that was really significant, it seems obscure, but it was key, was for the administration to support what's called a TRIPS waiver, the temporary waiver of- Right... 17:24 intellectual property rights just to get more vaccines produced. Now, that wasn't necessarily gonna deliver vaccines immediately. Sure. But it was a really important signal that we've gotta have a different arrangement. 17:36 This is an extraordinary time, and business as usual isn't gonna be big enough. So I would say the vaccine equity was key. 17:42 I think we're still far from it, and part of that is because the system is built basically with inequities in it. Sure. 17:53 And it's not built for crises, and overcoming that takes more than just doing more than anybody else, which is what the United States is doing. We gotta fix the system, right? 18:02 We gotta get people around the table and say, "Hey, looks like we need new rules for times like this." Sure. 18:08 And one of the topics we cover here is AI ethics, and there's this idea, it's called the alignment problem, which is essentially it's not the data, it's not the algorithms. Those have plenty of problems. 18:17 It's the people writing them or collecting them. It's-How did those people get chosen to be those people? And what are the incentives for- Right... how then to design those things? 18:27 And like you said, these are enormous systems, and I'm not interested today in just being like, "The blame goes here." 18:32 I'm interested, like I said, in really understanding the machine and the problem because anyone who says it's like, it's one piece of this puzzle, and that's the problem, is- No... 18:40 that is operating in a vacuum, which is not how government [laughs] or any of these things work by any stretch. So what was your relationship like with the COVAX entity, and kinda how did that develop along the way? 18:53 We worked very closely with COVAX. [clears throat] Uh, of course, the US government, many of us know Gavi, the Global Alliance for Vaccines, which is the foundation that COVAX was built on. 19:03 It's done a good job for many, many years. 19:05 So we worked closely, I mean, day to day, week to week, pretty constant consultation with both COVAX and then a mechanism that was built in Africa by the African Union called AVAT, which was also buying vaccines and distributing them in Africa. 19:20 And again, that was because we're sharing vaccines, we're providing these Pfizer vaccines, they're doing vaccines, AVAT's doing vaccines. 19:29 How do we make all of that work so the countries know what they're getting and when they're gonna get it? Mm-hmm. So it was a close, close working relationship. 19:37 So I think it's, you know, if we can start to identify some of the, it seems like, I don't wanna say failure points, but where there has been, I think- Yeah... a lack of- There's several of them. Right. 19:47 And I think that's the way any complex system works, or- Yeah... or doesn't work. 19:52 Again, expectations seem to be everything, but also just, again, coming back to this very tangible and, and clear, I don't think it's misleading. 20:01 It's not to say, "Hey, listen, it should be this easy," but it's very easy to look at these sort of... I've become a big fan of, uh, Mariana Mazzucato's mission-oriented approaches to doing these things, right? Mm-hmm. 20:13 If you've got this enormous complex system to do this thing, you gotta define the thing and reverse engineer from there. So it was put a man on the moon and bring him home safely. That's pretty black and white, right? 20:22 You can measure that- Right... 20:23 pretty clearly, and you can design every system, every contractor, every team, every test, every piece of machinery you develop along the way to go, "Is that going to help us do this in a more efficient, affordable, and also measurable way? 20:36 Are they gonna land, and are they gonna come home?" And you can apply that as well to something like decarbonize everything by 2050, right? 20:44 The complexities behind that are enormous, and not to shy away from those, but it is pretty measurable, and it is something we need to do. 20:51 And if you look at a pandemic that is born from a coronavirus, which we have a lot of familiarity with, but one that, uh, was novel in this sense and affected everyone and then keeps changing, if the answer to save as many lives as possible, obviously, and make fewer people sick, and you're measuring that in the billions, and of course, the second order effects of that are not crash economies, not crash health systems, not reduce- Right... 21:20 childhood vaccinations for everything else, here and everywhere else, but also just stop new [laughs] variants as much as we can, arrest them as much as we can. 21:29 The answer is vaccinate everyone as quickly as we can- Right... with at least one shot. Whenever I come to these things, and this feels like this is gonna be my theme this year, is thinking about incentives, right? 21:40 This country, and, uh, look at what's going on with Ukraine, right? 21:44 We pick and choose, and that's the job, what we apply our enormous wealth and resources or military to, whether that's on a military front, Syria or Ukraine or Yemen. Mm-hmm. 21:55 And we can't do everything, and we should not, but there are moments and issues that obviously are so clear, so that's, I think, why it becomes disheartening 15 months after we have these things to see a project like this one start to fail in a lot of ways, and again, it has a lot of fails. 22:08 I agree with everything you said. I think there were a couple of things that got this off on the wrong footing. Mm-hmm. 22:14 Because you're right that at some level a response like this and doing the right thing, it's one part engineering, right? Sure. 22:20 You can figure out where vaccines need to go, at what rate, who can absorb, what production needs to be. All of that's almost mathematical. Sure. 22:29 It is also political because to make that work, you gotta make some changes. Mm-hmm. 22:35 'Cause the system is built for business as usual, and business as usual means that those who can afford to buy the vaccines are those who buy the vaccines. Sure. It's our entire healthcare system, yeah. Exactly. 22:47 It's totally, it's a total reflection of that. 22:50 So you've got a layer that is, okay, you're gonna have to make some changes, and there's a third, quite frankly, I would say it's a, a moral level or a common humanity or universal value level, which is 23:05 you gotta believe that everybody in the world should have access to a vaccine. So what happened here? First, it gets politicized from day one, who started that? It just- Sure... politicized. 23:17 And then I think second, the question wasn't until much later in the game your question, which is how do you stop new variants? How do you save as many lives as possible? 23:27 The question was, by the nature of the threat, how do I protect my country, my people, my borders? So every country in the world was turned inward. Arguably, you can say it's not completely unjustified, right? 23:40 They're like, "Holy shit." No, and I, I, I don't fault that, but you can't operate in a vacuum. Exactly. But what that meant is that the natural default muscle 23:52 in global crises of collaboration and cooperation took a long time to build, right? So you watch Ukraine now. Sure. That's happening in one place. It's in somebody's neighborhood. 24:05 The speed with which the international community- It's wild... governments, citizens, private sector have organized, coordinated, collaborated is breathtaking, and it's right. Sure. That didn't happen in the pandemic. 24:18 No. It's something that we're practiced at, right? For instance, we've been shipping arms- Exactly... abroad to a huge [laughs] variety of countries for a very long time and in massive amounts. 24:26 You know, we've been moving troops around NATO for decades, this and that. Like-We know how to do these things, right? I started thinking a lot after my conversation, uh, with Dr. 24:35 Pie about all the pros and cons of PEPFAR, right? And for folks- Right... 24:39 that aren't familiar, that was, take this for what it's worth, born out of, and like you were just using the word compassionate, born out of George Bush, uh, George H.W. Bush's- Compassionate conservatism... 24:48 compassionate conservatism, right? And- Yep... 24:49 those are two powerful words, and again, if you're not familiar, it was this frankly huge and, and truthfully incredibly impactful effort to tackle HIV and AIDS in Africa, and it's still going on, right? 25:01 But it's imperfect, 'cause again, those two words, like any of these things are, any of these huge efforts are going to be, right? 25:06 Um, Ukraine, like how many people are saying, "Don't just send fighter invite jets, send pilots and close the skies," and it's like, okay- Right... 25:12 but let's ask the bigger [laughs] questions of what does that mean, right? 25:14 So PEPFAR, for instance, the imperfections are still, and please correct me if I'm wrong, there's still thresholds around abstinence and prostitution requirements, and I believe there's no needle exchange stuff involved. 25:27 So that's gonna reflect a little more on the conservatism part of compassionate conservatism. But I was just also been thinking about it 'cause, again, in the sense of like we know how to do things, right? 25:38 Like we know how to ship- Right... arms. I mean, PEPFAR's an enormous thing where we have... It's focused on a relatively singular issue. Right. 25:46 We've sent huge amounts of aid, which have represented everything from money to goods to building, and this is where it's a little more timely with what a lot of the African groups have been saying. 25:55 It's not just about, for instance, shipping shots, it's about supporting onsite distribution complexities, right? Yeah. 26:02 So for instance, one of the criticisms has been, yes, we haven't sent enough shots, but of the ones we've sent, a lot of them are expiring, and the people on the ground there don't know what the expiration dates are when they get there, and they still don't have the distribution mechanisms to, again, vaccinate- Right... 26:17 every person in their country on their continent, right? But I also think because PEPFAR has, uh, over the past couple dates- decades, built in those outcome-based approaches, right? We wanna have, I think, was it 90%? 26:29 It was 90% by 90% by 90, something like that. Yeah. But they're quantifiable- Yeah... 26:34 however much we might have seceded and failed around them, and I just think about in the past year, in your time there, and in going forward, are there things we, we can still learn and apply from PEPFAR- Oh, sure... 26:44 in supporting COVAX and Gavi and righting this ship because it seems like the further we get away and the less we talk about this, people are going, "Has my booster expired?" 26:53 And realizing, like w- we are still so far from, again, reducing the chance that new variants come that affect everyone, right? That's just how it works. 27:02 The other thing about PEPFAR that's been interesting is it's also iterative. I mean, PEPFAR- Sure... when it was launched is a lot different than PEPFAR today. Sure. And it should be. It should be. 27:12 Because the scale of it, it's possible to look at what worked, what didn't, there's new data all the time, and there's new scientific discovery all the time. So it's changed and morphed a lot. 27:22 It's building more capacity than it was at the beginning. It started as an emergency program. 27:27 It is still that in the sense of urgency, but I think everybody who works in global health, whether it's on HIV and AIDS, malaria, TB, Ebola, anything else, is coming down to a couple things. Health systems. Mm-hmm. 27:41 We invest a great deal of money, as do governments, in low and m- low-middle income countries in their health systems. They need to be strong. That is half, three-quarters of the battle- Sure... from the get go, right? 27:54 So how do we make those investments so that if you're providing therapeutics, vaccines, whatever it may be, you've got a foundation to work on? So I think that's one 28:03 piece that gets to, for example, why we worked so closely with the African Union. They are building the capacity. That is the local capacity we wanted to be- Mm-hmm... 28:12 hand in hand with them, so we're doing this together and not, "Hi, we wanna be very generous. Here you go. Good luck." I do wanna address one thing you said on delivery, which is... 28:21 it's accurate, but I think there's another piece to it, 'cause- Please... we've all read stories now of a country that gets vaccines, but they expire. Couple things going on there. 28:29 One is that we still don't have a fully transparent system for what's being produced by everybody, all the vaccine producers. Sure. Where's it being allocated? Who's signing the contracts? When will it become available? 28:42 So you still gotta go put all those pieces together. That's a fixable problem- Mm-hmm... and something we are pushing on. We pushed on when I was in government. We're pushing on it now at ONE. 28:51 We need a supply schedule, so we need total transparency there. 28:55 But the other problem for some of these governments, they may get doses, there have been some cases where some countries, not the US, have shipped vaccines that had short expiration dates. Inexcusable, not acceptable. 29:07 Mm. There's an effort to tamp down on that. Countries also don't know when they're gonna get them, and if they don't know that they have a regular supply- Mm-hmm... 29:16 then why in the world would you put on some big, huge national campaign if you're only gonna be able to vaccinate a million people and then say, "Well, oops, we don't know when we're getting any more"? 29:26 Here in the US, if you look at what was put on by the US government and governors and mayors to get people vaccinated, we laid on all sorts of things. Oh, yeah. 29:37 Extras, contractors, bells, whistles, but we knew we were gonna have a steady supply. These countries don't know where they have a steady supply. So what do you wanna, you wanna create the expectation. Sure. 29:48 So again, that's why we've gotta ramp up building the delivery capacity and providing that support, but this only works if you kinda look at the full spectrum of things. Of course. Right? 29:58 From the, as you rightly said, extraordinary invention of these vaccines to getting shots in arms. There are various sticking points along the way. 30:08 So I think the lesson from PEPFAR, one of the things it's been able to do over the years, is break down some of those sticking points so that you've got a more engineered systemic 30:20 system-Rather than what we've got now, which is still a bit too fragmented I would never want to denigrate public health here in the transfer of assets and people and, and resources to the people on the ground there, w- wherever it might be, whatever crisis. 30:33 I mean, it is... I mean, I feel like we could title this conversation Various Sticking Points, and it'd be the greatest- Right... understatement that anyone has ever said of all time. 99 and counting. Yeah. 30:43 I mean, it's just like, it's preposterous, and that's the way these things go. But it's solvable. This is what matters to me, and it's that idea, right, which is true, which is... 30:51 And one of our partners is, uh, Give Directly. It's this idea of like poverty is a policy choice, you know? Yeah. In, in a lot of places. Absolutely. 30:58 And because it's so easy to oversimplify things, that doesn't mean someone voted for something and we decided on poverty, right? It's a huge international thing. It's a huge domestic thing. There's racism built in. 31:07 There's all this other stuff. 31:09 I think about one of my first public health conversations on this show was with a woman, Karen Huster, who was an on-the-ground nurse in the Congo working on Ebola, and that conversation was mostly about just misinformation fears on the ground of why don't people get- Yeah... 31:23 take shots that are available to them. I was a liberal arts religion major. It's complicated. The things you have to overcome- Yeah... there are the shots expired on a truck. 31:31 So this obviously, again, goes all the way from Dr. Karen Kariko solving the inflammation problem of mRNA shots to trip waivers to religious and sociological beliefs of what do vaccines do to someone, right? 31:43 So it is enormously complicated, but we do have to do this thing because it's gonna keep going, and it's gonna keep changing economies and societies and- Of course... 31:52 you don't have to r- read the Partner in Health blog or UNICEF, whatever it is, to see that here and elsewhere, childhood vaccinations are dropping all over the place. Right. 32:03 For everything else that we have basically solved, right? Because of vaccines and because of these systems working as well as they can. 32:10 So if we can talk for a second about what maybe you would have done differently in your time there, knowing what we know about how complex it is and how it's gonna go and, and again, these infrastructure that needed to be built everywhere. 32:22 But also looking forward both for the next, for example, twelve months of this thing, however unpredictable it may be, it's the whole sense of what you can control and what you can't, but also because it's going to happen again, and we're gonna have to deal with- Definitely... 32:34 antibiotics and things like this. What, what practically are the big moves that, like, we could have done differently that we need to do differently going forward in the sense of what we can control? A couple of things. 32:44 I mean, I agree with you that this is a huge, hairy, complex problem, but I also... there's another side of me that this isn't rocket science, right? Oh, for sure. 32:53 This is a crisis where a lot of what we're dealing with is quantifiable. Mm-hmm. There, there's a lot we can figure out, and I think in the same way that when you said poverty is a policy choice, 33:04 vaccine inequity is a policy choice- Sure... at the end of the day because the engineering pieces we can fix. That's not hard. 33:13 So I'd say a couple things that can be done or I would have done differently and, and quite frankly, I would have done some things differently before I went back into government. Mm. 33:22 I went back into government over a year after the pandemic started. Sure. For example, if you look at the creation of COVAX, right? So some countries and philanthropies and others got together. 33:34 The US was not one of them. This was during the Trump administration. We did not participate and said, "We need to create this thing called COVAX to make sure vaccines get to low-income countries." 33:44 What we didn't do was say, "And to make sure that happens, we're going to guarantee that X percentage of supply needs to go into that pipeline." 33:55 An advance agreement at the beginning, donors can come up with the capital, countries themselves may wanna buy even though they got limited resources. But we wanna secure a share of the market for low-income countries. 34:09 That didn't happen, and so we all know what happened. A limited supply of vaccines came on the market. They were all snatched up. Mm. 34:16 You and I were very fortunate to get vaccinated because our country was able to buy them and others weren't. 34:21 So that's one is build in from the ground floor some ways to cover those countries that may be less or unable to cover themselves. I think the second, and it's something we got started on, I 34:35 would have liked to have done more on it and gotten us further up to now, though I think the US will continue on this, which is looking at diversifying production of vaccines and therapeutics geographically. 34:47 You can't afford a single point of failure. When India stopped exporting vaccines, that shut down a whole lot of global vaccine distribution. Well, they have the largest- But also-... 34:57 world's largest vaccine producer in-house. Exactly. 34:59 And there's a move now, it's been around for some time, but I think it's recently been articulated very crisply on the part of Africa, for example, where their focus at the political level is, yes, still on getting vaccines, but more on building the capacity on that continent to produce vaccines, therapeutics, other medical supplies, so there's less dependence on other countries 'cause that's kind of the way this has worked. 35:24 If you could cover your own country, great. If not, you were kinda dependent on the largesse of others, and that's backwards to me. 35:32 And things like securing an amount of the supply for low-income countries, that's building it in advance. 35:38 So we've gotta do those things in advance in the future and assume that if we don't, we're gonna have the uneven distribution that we do now. And as you rightly say, we're just risking more variants. It's foolishness. 35:47 Sure. And not to expand this conversation another three hours 'cause you have an enormous amount of lives to impact here, uh, besides talking to me, but it's just coming back to the alignment problem. 36:00 This is just indicative of how we are already reacting to the climate crisis, right? 36:06 And, oh, I'm sorry that low-income countries are already feeling enormous amount of heat and Indian farmers are committing suicide because they're subsistence farmers- Right... 36:14 and they can't afford to, and migration at the southern border because the land is parched, and we're just going, "That's great, but when does my booster expire?" And like, "W- why isn't there an EV that's sexy?" 36:23 And you're going, "Guys, I do not think you understand how interconnected this all is." I wanna be crystal clear. 36:28 I usuallyOn this show spend try to, and I ask on plenty of folks who I fundamentally disagree with to come on- Mm-hmm... many do not. That's not this. 36:38 My point is when I try to help folks understand, so for instance, we had on a show with a representative Lauren Underwood to talk about before they passed her elements of the Omnibus Act to talk about Black maternal health, and how- Mm-hmm... 36:52 Black women who give birth in the year after die three to four times as likely as white women. In our home state of Illinois, it's six times as likely. And people go, "That's terrible. How do we fix it?" 37:00 And I always try to say, "We have to fix ourselves." That exists because for the vast majority of our country's history, we either had slavery or legal segregation, and we're nowhere near fixing that. 37:11 Like, this is just- Mm-hmm... the tip of the spear, right? And that is not to empathize with that system. 37:15 That's just, we have to paint the building blocks, and that's when I say, "Oh, go on about how complex this is," that's not to empathize with it. Those are the table stakes. The roots of this are deep. Sure. 37:24 But like you said, there's a whole lot of shit that's fixable, and frankly, it's incredibly inexcusable that it, that it hasn't. 37:30 And so I wanna focus on action, but again, it also just terrifies me looking at this with climate and looking at this going, what is the next year, two years, three years, five years of this look like as I talk to folks who are working on wastewater and things- Sure... 37:41 like that or whatever it might be. Let me ask you this. Everything's gonna be iterative. PEPFAR is gonna be a lot of lessons from that, Ebola, whatever it might be. 37:50 Now you've got a lot of African countries, at least this month, right, have saying, "Hold on to the donations. Distribution isn't working. We have to build these up, but also we need more help." 37:58 What are outside-the-box alternative things that institutions can be doing, whether it's one or otherwise, governments down to people, to improve vaccine equity? What else- Yeah... can be done? 38:11 Because, again, I wanna be crystal clear, the point of this conversation is none of this is cutting it, and enormous amounts of people are suffering. 38:19 Enormous amounts of people are suffering, and it's gonna come back to bite us 'cause that's how this works. So what the hell else can we be doing- Yeah... on a practical day-to-day level? 38:27 So I think on a very practical level, there are a few things coming up that are gonna be vital. 38:31 On the point you just mentioned on delivery, for example, Congress is negotiating a budget, which it always seems to be negotiating. There is funding in there that is for support to delivery, right? 38:42 Giving countries the assistance they need to have the delivery systems ready. That's something the US needs to do and Congress needs to do. 38:51 And significantly, in global public health, including HIV and AIDS and the pandemic up to now, there's actually been bipartisan support, so it might be nice to protect that one little tiny area where there's actually agreement on something. 39:04 Financing the delivery is number one. Number two, uh, President Biden had a summit in September. He's gonna have another one, it'll likely be in April, that brings the world together. 39:16 That's gonna be vitally important, and it gets to what citizens can do. And let me just say that when I left government for the third time, I came out more convinced perhaps than I've ever been 39:27 that citizens' voices really matter. And I know that at times like this, you look at vaccine inequity, you look at many things happening in the US, you look at where we are, and importantly, are not on climate change. 39:41 It's easy to feel like, "What's wrong with these people, and I can't do anything?" But I tell you, they listen and they hear, and they listen all the more when they hear from unexpected quarters. 39:52 So I think weighing in, both on the front end to say, "We expect President Biden at that summit that A, B, and C will happen. There will be more funding. There will be an agreement on a plan going forward. 40:04 There will be... You know, you'll put pressure on the vaccine companies for this transparency so we know what's coming," all those kinds of things. But also credit on the other end. 40:14 The common wisdom, I think, in political circles today is that Americans don't really care about this. 40:21 Our polling suggests that actually, roughly, I think it's over 75% of those polled think we should be doing more to make sure that vaccine equity is achieved, either because it's the right thing to do, or it's the smart thing to do, or both. 40:36 So I think weighing in matters on these things. I live in DC, I don't have a voting member of Congress, for those of you who do. An entire other conversation. Exactly. 40:45 But let them know that you expect that budget to pass. You can certainly join us at any time. We've got a lot of simple actions people can take that send a message, and we're gonna be pushing hard on three things. 40:57 One is the ongoing pandemic response. It's not where it needs to be, so we've got multiple ways we're pushing on that. Vaccines at the center, but not vaccines exclusively. Mm-hmm. 41:06 The second is the economic devastation, and if we thought we had inequity with respect to vaccine coverage, we've certainly got inequity with respect to the economic pandemic that has come on top of- Sure... 41:19 the virus itself, where low income countries have been hit just massively and don't have the ability to do the kind of surplus. And then the third gets back to something you said earlier about poverty being a policy. 41:33 Inequity is a policy, and I could be a cynic right now, but I'm actually an optimist because I think we're seeing more and more signs that more important people are recognizing that inequity is a policy, it's a choice, and it's not a smart one, so we gotta do better. 41:49 Well, I mean, that all seems to make sense for me. One of my favorite organizations, if you're not familiar with it, can't recommend it enough, uh, run by a woman named Amanda Litman. 41:57 It's called Run for Something, and they exclusively- Yes... work with progressive, uh, young people under 40 to run for every office from school board- It makes so much difference... 42:06 and that is truly, like, one of those places when people go, besides calling, besides emailing, besides these things, and, and I'm sure you're not super familiar, but one of the things we do in each newsletter is, is point people towards very measurable things, going like, "No, this is the most useful and impactful way for you to spend your time to do one of these things," whateverIt might be. 42:24 Uh-huh. And honestly, the thing is, and, and of course there's an enormous amount of people like, that cannot do this for a variety of reasons, but, you know, one of my answers is, well- Run for something... 42:33 run for something. 42:33 Because I know you don't think that matters as enough, but every time you get frustrated with that Joe Manchin won't pass X for power electrification, look at what states are doing, look at what cities are doing, and go take part. 42:45 Go run for your city council, because that matters. 42:48 And you think it won't matter as much, but for instance, like you said, it's so typically American, but also so incredibly frustrating as we go forward to look at and say like, "Well, everyone's got vaccines, like good luck." 42:58 It's like we have done so little to fix our public health issues at home- Right... but how many of those are about community health workers, right? Are about passing, taking the federal money for Medicaid? 43:08 That's your state, and you can go get a part-time legislative job [laughs] in a state, and you can start to literally save lives to do that, and you might not be able to affect any one of these African countries that are struggling with distribution. 43:21 But every one of these matters, and frankly, and one of Amanda's biggest points is, those are the future leaders that end up in the House of Representatives, that end up in the Senate- Yeah... 43:29 that do make those measurable differences internationally. You're 1000% right, and I couldn't agree more whether it's school board or whatever it may be. 43:39 You don't have to be at the center of the universe making all the big decisions 'cause it all builds up and it gives us a foundation and I would just... You know, something happened to me in serving in government. 43:48 You have this profound moment where you realize, oh man, our, our government is basically us. Yeah. Right? 43:56 There's, like, not a group of people somewhere over there that is, oh, the school board, that's other people, or the mayor, they come from some other genetic line or something. Yeah. It's us. This is it. Yeah. 44:08 This is what we got. And so I think the more people that can run for something, and the more people who can serve in government- Right... because, you know, I was a political ap-appointee. 44:18 You've got certain juice if you do that. The career men and women that serve in the US government have enormous influence and capability. So I'd look at both of those avenues. 44:27 Public service makes a huge difference 'cause it all comes down, like, it's us. It is us, and that can be very scary. It's like when you realize your parents are just people, right? And you're just going- Right. 44:36 [laughs]... 44:36 oh, they're, I mean, they're, they're the most wonderful and I worship my parents, I love them to death, I'm sure they're listening to this, but you know, you just realize like, we all have hopes and dreams and faults and the system is complicated and this and this, but that doesn't mean, and this is this little phrase that I always come back to which is do better, better. 44:51 Feel like couldn't be more applicable to global public health things, which is, like you said, it is complex and it comes down to so many different factors. 44:59 But there are concrete things we can do and we need to do and we're late to do, and that also will benefit us in the future as we confront, frankly, a world that's gonna be just vastly more volatile and complicated than it's ever been. 45:10 And we have to- It is... start doing these things to show ourselves, to do them and to show ourselves that we know how to do them, and then to build on them. 45:17 Because if we don't, if you think this is gnarly and complicated, like oh my God, what's coming is crazy. It, it is, and I think I can sometimes get a little, I don't know, romantic or something. 45:29 But I mean, this can, should be like a national project, right? Everybody's affected by this pandemic. 45:36 Everybody's affected by climate change, whatever it may be, and I think in the same spirit as run for something or public service, it's the community activism. That's the only... 45:47 I don't know, those are the tools we've got. 45:50 Because I have to believe, even though there are a lot of naysayers, and oh, we shouldn't do this, or it's their fault they don't have vaccines, or there is no climate change, whatever it may be. 46:00 I think if we organize, the vast majority of people, I think, understand that there are problems, but that collectively we can actually solve them. And I think they're tired of excuses for not solving them. 46:10 Yeah, I agree. I mean, it's very easy post haste to romanticize the state of Georgia electing on the same day a young white Jewish man and a, and a Black pastor. 46:21 But at the same time, like, that doesn't happen without literally two decades of incredible organizing from people who have at l- like best been marginalized for that same amount of time, and before that, even worse, and yet they kept doing it. 46:35 And you think it doesn't matter on a day to day, and then all of a sudden, those two votes are all we got, you know? And it does have to start from there. 46:43 I think you're right, and I would just flag one other thing that I think pertains. It's similar in the global health space, which is back when George Bush announced PEPFAR and people were like, "What? 46:53 This is coming from George Bush, who's-" Yeah... billions of dollars. It was bold. It had bipartisan support from the get-go. 46:59 A lot of people who have campaigned, acted for full funding for PEPFAR, for money to do Ebola now, for the pandemic, invested a lot of time in nurturing that bipartisan agreement and making sure that there was still agreement amongst Democrats and Republicans that the United States should be in the lead in ending the AIDS epidemic. 47:21 That's paid off big time. Yeah. I walked back into the State Department, we had $11 billion in pandemic funding from the Hill that came out of that activism over the many years. So you're absolutely right. 47:33 We are building foundations with what we do now that can be used in the future. So it's worth it. It's really, really worth it, and I think we all know what happens if we don't. Yeah, we do. 47:43 And again, this is where when someone reads a headline about the jet stream slowing down and, and they call me- Right... "Well, what, what can I do?" And I'm like, "You can't really do shit about that. 47:51 But what you can do is focus on whether you're a titan of industry or a community organizer or a teacher or whatever it might be, investor, is climate change is really the heat you feel, the air you breathe, the water you drink, the food you eat, the rivers outside your door, your insurance. 48:05 It's all of these things, and those are much more A to B reachable- Yeah... and applicable. 48:10 They're tangible and something you can do about, and they do, and this is where we focus, make you feel better and help on the personal side, but also they do measurably, we know this, contribute to greater systemic- Yeah... 48:20 change. It all adds up. So to tie it all up, I could not be more frustrated and, and angry [laughs] with the state of vaccine equity. I feel like I just had this conversation with Dr. 48:28 Pie a month and a half ago and, and it seems like a whole lot has not changed. We're in this lull between variants. 48:35 Hopefully, it's more than that, butThere's as every virologist has taught me there's no rule that says there is, or that the next one's gonna be easier, or whatever it might be. 48:43 We have to do everything we can, and doing it from the ground up matters. So it sounds like this vaccine, this summit that's coming up, we'll find the information for that when it's announced. Yep, should be in April. 48:53 Find ways for folks to interact, but also, you know, the more we can do on that level with organizing in groups like Run For Something or supporting disaster relief, supporting Partners in Health and Doctors Without Borders and UNICEF and all these things, it does, it does matter. 49:07 It adds up big time. I- Hugely... I appreciate that perspective. So I just have a couple little questions we ask everybody, then I'm gonna get you out of here, Gayle. You got enough- Okay. I'm ready. 49:16 Gayle, when was the first time in your life, uh, when you realized you had the power of change or the power to do something meaningful? 49:23 Yourself, part of a group, government, private, whatever it might be that made you go, "Oh, I can actually affect something. That's interesting. I wanna do more of that." It was in my 20s. 49:35 I had been a very young reporter, and I was in the middle of the famine in Ethiopia in '84, '85. It's the middle of a war. One side was being fed, the other wasn't. 49:46 And I managed to get myself into a meeting at the United Nations. 49:50 I basically infiltrated the meeting, I guess, and rather disrupted it, but basically contradicted what was being presented and said, "I've just come from here, and none of these people are being fed." And I... 50:01 and now a lot of people were pissed off at me, but it triggered a discussion that otherwise hadn't been going on, and it was like, damn, huh. Mm-hmm. 50:08 I guess you can be a bit of an upstart and get something done, and that was one where you wanna talk about inequity. Oh. Watch people starve to death, and then you fly to a city where everybody thinks life's normal. 50:20 That's when you learn to fight for fair. Mm-hmm. But then realizing that if you speak up... 50:25 and then there were a lot of other things, but I think it's just learning that if you speak up and put the facts and the truth on the table, that's when you realize, damn, maybe I can do something. I love that. 50:37 We just have this whole community of people who are, as we say, working on the front lines of the future, and a whole lot of folks who want to, and recognizing those moments, I think, is, is super helpful for them to go, "That's how this person got started doing this." 50:48 Like, that's incredible. Who is someone in your life that has positively impacted your work in the past six months? If you wanna pay it back, pay it forward. A guy named Strive Masiyiwa. Strive's a friend. 50:59 I've known him for a long time. He's a very successful Zimbabwean businessman and philanthropist, but he's also been the lead on the African Union's work to acquire its own vaccines. Mm-hmm. Right? 51:10 Like actually buying them, delivering them. 51:14 And working with him on a day-to-day basis, seeing the determination, the fighting for what's right in a fierce way where it's appropriate, in a more collegial way where that's more appropriate, it's a total inspiration. 51:28 Mm. And it, it feels like solving the immediate problem while also getting to the root of it. I love that. I mean, it, it's someone who's in a position of they have to do this. This isn't some- Sure... 51:38 gotta get a booster type of thing. Like this, this has to happen. Right. Gayle, everything has been crazy the past couple years. What is your self-care? What, what is your walk in the woods, ice cream, Netflix? 51:48 Well, I've tried to shift from it being ice cream because the problem with the pandemic when you've got a lot of ice cream and a lot of Netflix- Mm-hmm... 51:57 that may be a temporary, "Oh, I feel much better," but it's not a long-term solution. [laughs] Walking- Mm-hmm... listening to a lot of really good music, and dancing in my downstairs guest room like a fool. 52:11 But it's very fun. It's extremely satisfying. Is there a track or album, old or new, that's really doing it for you right now? 52:17 No, I've got a ton of them from all over the world, and I just turn it on and have a good time. I mean, it's kinda ridiculous, but it's great exercise, too. Yeah. It's all my kids do. Works things out of your system. 52:27 I can't recommend the Encanto soundtrack enough. It is a delight. [laughs] It'll move you. Got it. Last one, Gayle. 52:34 What's a book you've read in the past year or so that's opened your mind to a topic you hadn't considered before or has actually changed your thinking in some way? 52:41 We've got a whole list on Bookshelf that we put in the show notes and people love to shop on. I hate when people ask me these questions. You're welcome. You can let me know later, of course. 52:50 I'm happy to just throw- I'll let you know just because but part of the problem, though, is that being in this field, I tend to read a lot of books that are about the stuff I work on. Mm-hmm. Probably too much. Mm-hmm. 53:01 And those might open the mind, but they open the mind not in ways you're suggesting. So I'll come up with, uh, something- Deal... for you on the show notes. That sounds great. That sounds perfect. I fully get it. 53:10 I'm the person who, again, I read so much because of all this and, and otherwise, and I could not tell you the last three books I read. 53:17 But I can tell you, like, thematically what I got 'em out, out of them, but recall is, is not so great. Yeah, see, my thing is I, I tend to... I'm, I'm working on this. You ask about self-care. Mm. I work all the time. 53:29 Work finishes, and then I'm reading more things about- And then working... work. Mm-hmm. It's a tough one. It's a tough one. Gotta work on that. Yeah. Gotta work on that. Yeah, good times. 53:36 As my therapist says, it's always the shoulds with me, "So I should do this, should do that." He's like, "And then you're dead." [laughs] Like, it can't be that all the time. Right. 53:43 But the cool thing is to take a should, like I decided I should walk more. Mm. So I've been walking more, and it just makes me happier than a pig in shit. So what you gotta do is take a should- Mm-hmm... 53:54 and just do it one at a time. I love that. You're a hero. Gayle, are you online anywhere? Sh- is there anywhere folks can follow you, or should they just hook up with the ONE Campaign? 54:03 What, uh, makes the most- Yeah, hook up with the ONE Campaign. Okay. I am also on Twitter now that I'm back and hope to be expanding that. Oh, boy. And will expand some more, but check us out at the ONE Campaign. 54:12 Can you give me the one line description of what you're working on at the ONE Campaign now that you're back? I or ONE? Whatever pleases you. 54:18 I mean, ONE is campaigning on the pandemic and the, the health response and the economic response. I'm working on shaping the debate. Okay. I like that. We gotta reframe the debate. I love it. Well- And keep going... 54:29 we'll follow up on that. I'm excited. Gayle, thank you so much for your time and clearly for all that you do. It's a complicated beast. 54:36 That doesn't kinda excuse where we are, but I appreciate folks like yourself who've dedicated themselves and their work to trying to, like you said, iteratively make it as good as we can, as impactful as we can. 54:46 We can get there. We'll get there.Thanks to our incredible guest today, and thanks to all of you for tuning in. 54:55 We hope this episode has made your commute or awesome workout or dishwashing or fucking dog walking late at night that much more pleasant. 55:04 As a reminder, please subscribe to our free email newsletter at importantnotimportant.com. It is all the news most vital to our survival as a species. And you can follow us all over the internet. 55:14 You can find us on Twitter @importantnotimp. Just so weird. Also on Facebook and Instagram @importantnotimportant. Pinterest and Tumblr, the same thing. So check us out, follow us, share us, like us. You know the deal. 55:29 And please subscribe to our show wherever you listen to things like this. And if you're really fucking awesome, rate us on Apple Podcasts. Keep the lights on. Thanks. Please. 55:38 And you can find the show notes from today right in your little podcast player and at our website, importantnotimportant.com. 55:44 Thanks to the very awesome Tim Blaine for our jamming music, to all of you for listening, and finally, most importantly, to our moms for making us. Have a great day. Thanks, guys. 55:59 [outro jingle] [outro music] That's it for this week's conversation. 56:10 For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing, thanks for leaving a review, and thanks for giving a shit. 56:25 [outro music]