Transcript 0:00 Hey, folks, it's Quinn. Since we recorded this conversation, we've renamed the podcast. It used to be called Important Not Important, which is what you'll hear in the episode and is still the name of the company. 0:12 But now the podcast is called The Most Important Question, that is, what can I do? 0:18 It's the question we get the most from all of you, and it turns out it's the question I've really been asking guests for almost two hundred episodes now. So here we are, The Most Important Question. 0:29 Please enjoy this old conversation. Thanks for listening, and thanks for giving a shit. [upbeat music] Welcome to Important Not Important. 0:45 My name is Quinn Emmett, and this is science for people who give a shit. And boy, is that ever ring true today. There's a lot going on out there, folks. Our world is changing every single day. 0:56 You can see it, you can feel it. We give you the tools you need to think better, to feel better, to fight for a better, very different future, uh, for everyone. 1:06 Um, that means, and again, especially today, the context, and that's straight from some of the smartest thinkers on Earth, uh, and the action steps you can take to feel better and to build systemic change. 1:18 Our guests are scientists, futurists, uh, journalists, farmers, uh, educators, CEOs, investors, engineers, even a reverend. Some quick housekeeping before we get started. 1:31 You can send questions, thoughts, and feedback to us on Twitter at importantnotimp, or you can email us at questionsatimportantnotimportant.com. 1:41 You can also join tens of thousands of other smart folks and subscribe to our free weekly newsletter at importantnotimportant.com. 1:49 It's the most important science news plus analysis and action steps, uh, so you can get involved. Uh, lastly, you can hunt for a new impactful job on the front lines of the future at importantjobs.com. 2:03 Uh, that's importantjobs.com. 2:05 If you work for a company or organization already doing that work or looking to get started doing that work, if you need a, your first sustainability officer, uh, you can list your open roles there for incredibly affordable rates. 2:17 Uh, our goal is to move the needle of progress, not make a bunch of money, and you can get them in front of our entire community of amazing shit givers. 2:25 Uh, as, uh, foreshadowed, this week's episode is getting kind of meta, uh, but is hopefully a good step. 2:32 It's a help for those of you who've been fighting the climate change and, and the power structures behind it for a long time, um, but also to everybody new to it. 2:42 I think there's a lot of folks who are new to it these days, and obviously the show is growing, so we're aware of that. 2:47 I'm, uh, talking today, uh, with a friend about retraining our minds, uh, to try and understand and operate in this, as he puts it, discontinuity, uh, we are in. It's not just one issue. It's not one vote or industry. 3:05 Um, it is everything. It's, it's all-encompassing, uh, th-this discontinuity we have built. Um, it will last beyond the rest of our lives. So 3:15 in order to best execute on it, to operate within it, uh, to build radical, unforeseeable change, we have to come to terms with what it means to, to be in this, um, again, so we can figure out how to build something new and better, uh, that applies to so many more people than it ever has before. 3:34 Um, but that includes you too. Um, my guest is, uh, again, there's nobody better talked about, uh, this stuff than Alex Steffen. He is a longtime climate reporter, climate futurist. 3:45 He's the author of the forthcoming book, The Snap Forward. Uh, he's got an incredible blog and podcast that accompany those. Can't recommend them enough. 3:54 I'm a big fan of Alex's work and the way he thinks and the way he challenges me to think, and I hope this conversation does the same for you. 4:01 If you're new here, go ahead, scroll back, check out some of our recent episodes, some incredible conversations with amazing people. Uh, how does the universe end? 4:11 H-what happens when trees talk to each other, and what can we learn from them? What does that mean for climate change? What about carbon offsets? Are they actually bullshit? 4:19 How do we beat poverty with just a couple bucks? Uh, what is the future of mosquitoes? You can find all those recent episodes. 4:27 And of course, you're gonna wanna hit the subscribe button now so you're ready when our next conversations drop. 4:33 We've got incredible stuff coming, and that includes conversation with Isaias Hernandez, who's built an incredible following on Instagram about intersectional environmental justice. 4:44 We've got a conversation with Twitter's new ethics chief about what's next for that incredible platform. Hit subscribe now so you're delivered to you right on your phone. Please enjoy my conversation with Alex Steffen. 4:58 [electronic music] My guest today is Alex Steffen, and, uh, together we're going to try to understand, get a little philosophical, but also to turn the, uh, philosophy practical, which is sort of the best version of philosophy. 5:13 H-how can we try to understand the unknowns, uh, about the climate crisis and, uh, and what we're, [chuckles] what we're very much in, what we're dealing with? Alex, uh, welcome, man. Thanks. Thanks for having me on. 5:26 Of course, man. Uh, if you could, could you tell everybody, uh, real quick who you are and what you do? Sure. My name's Alex Steffen, and I'm a climate futurist. 5:35 Uh, what I do is I look at big natural systems like climate, um, human systems, the things we've built around ourselves, um, infrastructure, cities, agriculture, uh, education, law, and, uh, ask how those two things are changing each other, how what we're doing in terms of what we're building and how we're living is changing the planet, and how the planet as it changes is changing us. 5:58 Yeah, that sounds pretty timely. There's a little bit going on with it, yeah. [laughs]Well, you are, uh... What did, what did Katharine Hayhoe tweet last year? I don't know. 6:09 I've completely lost track of time at this point like everybody else, but something about... What did she call it? 6:13 She called it, like, Cassandra Freud or something like that, about, uh, it doesn't, it doesn't feel great to be the one shouting from the rooftops this whole time, and now, uh- Absolutely... it's all happening. 6:22 Yeah, the, uh, the Cassandra effect, right? You know, who, uh- Yeah, yeah, exactly... who could see the future, but nobody believed her, right? Was the Greek myth. Right. Um... Right. And- Yeah... yeah, no. I, I, I... 6:33 You've been at this for, for far, far longer than I have. I, I had a m- you know, the real corporate job for a while. 6:38 [laughs] Uh, but it, it does feel strange, and it felt this way at the beginning of COVID too, where people were like, "Man, live." Um, you know, do, do you feel sometimes it's a little pushy maybe in a little of like... 6:53 Do you feel justified in, in being, not doomerism, but I guess being, you know, definitely get the alarmist thing sometimes, you know? 7:02 Or, or how does it feel that everything is going this way or this and that, and it's like, I'm not celebrating. I would, more than anything, I would like to be wrong and never do this job again, you know? 7:12 It's, uh- Oh, yeah. No, the dream of literally everyone who works on climate and environmental issues is to put themselves out of a job, right? So- Oh my God. Yeah... 7:19 you know, that would be the best case scenario is I have to go find some, you know, honest work to do, you know, become a blacksmith- I mean-... or a barista or something... please, God. Yeah, yeah. You know, we- Um... 7:28 we talk, um, one of the organizations I really love to support is called Alex's Lemonade Stand. It's a pediatric cancer organization, and we've had their executive, co-executive director, uh, on a few times. 7:39 It was started by his late daughter, Alex, and, you know, he talks about that all the time. He's like, "I don't wanna do this fucking job. Why would I, why would I wanna work on kids' cancer all day? 7:48 It's like, it's literally the worst thing in the world. Like, my daughter died from it. I wanna put myself out of business as soon as humanly possible." Exactly. 7:55 And, uh, you know, as, as complicated as, uh, as cancer can certainly be, the more we find out about it, it's not some monolith. 8:02 Um, unfortunately, these, like you said, uh, the, the climate systems, our ecosystems, the, the societal and economic systems we have designed and the way they all intersect are just a tad bit more complicated and, uh, affecting everyone. 8:16 Yeah. So... Well, I was gonna say that, uh, you know, one of the real difficulties about this moment in time is that we are experiencing negative consequences, and we're all pretty aware of that now, right? 8:28 People at this point either understand it's happening or are actively denying that it's happening, right? Um, very few people are sort of, you know, haven't heard that things are changing at this point. Right. 8:39 Um, but we are very much... You know, we all grow up in our own contexts. We all are educated and, and trained, you know, to do certain jobs, to do certain work, um, to think about things certain ways. 8:53 We're surrounded by media and culture that tells us, you know, "Hey, here's what's important. Here's what's cool. Here's what's worth looking at." 9:00 And i- the, the really difficult thing about doing this kind of work is that the first step to understanding what's going on is understanding that everything has already changed, right? 9:12 That we're in what I call a- Right... discontinuity, right? That, that- Yeah... that the experiences and expertise that we acquired before don't really work now, and the systems we- Mm-hmm... 9:23 built around us were built for a world that no longer is the world we live on, in very literal ways. Um- Sure... and 9:32 it can be very hard when, you know, when the f- when the first thing somebody tells you is, "Okay, now, like, okay, this is gonna be easy. You start by just changing everything you thought," right? 9:43 [laughs] "And then we'll take the second step." Right? For sure. That's, that's, that's difficult. And, you know, all of us are attached to what we know, right? Some of us a lot more than others. 9:54 Some of us have, you know, financial incentives to not sort of see things change, you know? 10:00 Um, uh, maybe we, you know, somebody works in a polluting industry or somebody has investments in those industries or, um, you know, somebody lives in a place that is guaranteed to be hit hard by the changes that are coming, and they don't wanna sort of face up to that. 10:13 They don't wanna see their property value drop, for example. You know, some people have direct incentive to not want things to change. A lot of us have sort of indirect and emotional incentives, right? 10:26 It, it's hard to think about things changing. It's overwhelming. It can be depressing. 10:31 Um, the reason why things are changing, uh, kind of stems from a failure of, of our civilization to take care of the basic realities of human life, the, the nature around us and how we treat each other. 10:43 And so, you know, a lot of people have a, have a, have a barrier to wanting to see how much has already changed now. And it-- for those folks, and, and I think almost all of us have some part of that in us, right? 10:56 Something that we- Sure... don't want to acknowledge has changed. For those folks, for those of us who are in that position, that first step of just acknowledging 11:07 how profound a change in era we have gone through can be impossible, right? Yeah. There are people who just can't make that leap. There are also a lot of people who don't want other people to make that leap, right? Sure. 11:21 You know? I mean, uh, we live in the midst of one of the largest disinformation campaigns ever launched by human beings, right? The, the denialism campaign around climate change, you know- Sure... 11:32 what I call predatory delay. And, uh, you know, and so in the midst of that, each of us is in this unique position of having to, first of all, swallow this really big pill of understanding, right, you know? 11:46 [chuckles] That, like- Yeah... the entire Earth is different than it was a hundred years ago, right? Yeah. It's the matrix moment. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. 11:53 And then we have to figure out how we feel about that and what we do about it and how we respond to that reality, right? You know, that's... the first step there is a doozy, you know? [laughs] Yeah. 12:04 And, and you, you have to, you have to empathize with folks who-Again, it feels-- I, I mentioned offline a little bit like some phone calls I was offering to have with folks at the beginning of COVID when I started to do the math on this thing. 12:18 Mm-hmm. You know, you have to empathize with folks who there's all these levels of I'm ready to hear it, hit me, and they handle it, and then they go to a dark place for a little while. 12:27 I'm ready to hear it, and then, and then it turns out they're not. Um, or I can't deal with this right now. I've got enough just day-to-day shit on my plate. Um, and then, of course, there's the denialism side of it. 12:40 But, you know, it's, it's a little harder when you've been in this thing for a long time, and, and you have to, you know, it's, it's breaking the news to folks. 12:48 As, as my wife has said, like, I have developed the unique ability to be the bummer in every single conversation- [laughs] -no matter the subject. You know? Right. 12:56 Like, I can, I can ruin just about everything, and it's not the world's most fun superpower. Um- No, no... but- Yeah... 13:04 you know, lea-learning how to, how to talk to pe-people and how to shepherd them along 'cause we need all of them, uh, is something that is, that is important. 13:13 Um, and, and as much as I wanna talk about uncertainties today, you know, like you said, there are certainties that have already happened. 13:21 Um, clearly, I mean, just look outside, like, those things are happening and the fundamentals that, that are, that are the catalysts behind them, like, are, are already there, and we can explain those to those folks. 13:31 And then, like you said, that's a big enough ask. But to go... And then when they go, like, "What's gonna happen?" You're like, 13:38 "I mean, I think, I think, I think these things will probably happen, and they're entirely different than anything we've ever experienced since we, you know, bred off from Neanderthals, but, but here's the deal." 13:48 That's a tough one. Yeah, absolutely. It's a tough one. And, I mean, that is the essence of, you know, when I talk about The Snap Forward, the title of my- Yeah... forthcoming book and my- Yep... 13:56 and the newsletter and podcast that I'm doing now. When I talk about The Snap Forward, that's what I'm talking about, is that each of us has this process ahead of us. 14:04 Some of us are already in the midst of it, some of us are just starting it, where we are, in a very short period of time, going to be forced to, to try and understand how much has changed and how many, like, uncertainties are built into that, but also how much we definitely know, right? 14:21 Yeah. We know that things are already not the same as they were and will never be again, right? Yep. That's just a, a baseline. 14:28 Um, and there are lots of parts of this that are, uh, that can be, you know, extremely discouraging. Um, you know, to, to work on these issues is to have to process on a regular basis really bad news, right? Yeah. 14:43 But that's not the whole story. I don't even think it's the largest part of the story, right? There's certainly a lot of change happening. 14:51 Uh, there's the planetary crisis itself, climate change, biodiversity and ecosystems, toxics, invasive species, you know, uh, topsoil loss, water pollution, et cetera, right? Sure. 15:03 There are a whole mess of issues that are related to how we interact with nature, and the news on all of those fronts is terrible, right? I mean, it's- Mm-hmm... 15:10 it's, it's not going well out there, you know, in case that's- Yeah, right... news to anybody. Um, you know, and the ways in which it is worsening, um, are increasing the odds, right? 15:21 As these problems interact and interconnect, they're accelerating each other, and they're increasing the odds that we hit, if not catastrophic tipping points, at least a whole lot of small tipping points where a system that was working, you know, an ecosystem that was kinda hanging on suddenly collapses, right? 15:36 Uh, you know, a thing that was working suddenly ceases to work the way we have expected. None of that is good news, right? And, and, um, a-and it's, it's huge. It's hard to get our heads around how, how 15:51 powerful that shift is, right? It is so powerful that it's changing the rules for human societies, right? And that, that is the, the nature of, of the problem, right? 16:00 That, uh, you know, that when we talk about the planetary crisis, the crisis is that we're still doing old things, but we live in a new world, right? On top of that, you have the problem 16:13 of we have long assumed that nature and environmental problems are out there somewhere. You know, that they're, they're, they're things that are happening out in the woods, out in the mountains. 16:22 They're things that, you know, that hikers and fishermen care about, you know, or whatever, right? Um, they're- Right. Shark can't eat you if you don't get in the water. Right, right. You know, exactly. 16:31 And, you know, and so we have really underestimated the degree to which changes in the natural world are triggering even larger changes in the human world, especially because we've been in denial, we've delayed, we've put things off, we've not acted, and so there's this enormous torque built up- Yeah... 16:52 behind every human system on Earth, which as we recognize what's happening, that torque is getting released, and the changes that we're seeing are happening faster than we've ever seen things happen before, and we're just at the start of that roller coaster ride, right? 17:06 Yep. So you have the natural world, but then you have the human need to respond and react. Sure. And it can be really hard in all of that to see that that need to respond and react is also an amazing opportunity, right? 17:19 That we have- That's the, that's the clutch... we have the nece- That's what we're holding onto. Exactly, exactly. We have the necessity of remaking everything. 17:26 It is possible to remake most things in ways that benefit most people more than our current, like, what we think is going on now, right? Sure. Yeah. 17:35 And, and, you know, I actually have found that the more that I engage with this discontinuity, with the need to snap forward, the more optimistic I feel about what we can be doing, right? 17:47 But, you know, again, it takes some new attitudes, and one of them that's really hard is we all want there to be, we want there to be an orderly transition, right? Right. 17:57 We want things to progress smoothly from what we're used to into a new state of being in a way that is in control, that doesn't, you know, cost us any more than it has to. Sure. You know, all that stuff. And 18:09 as part of that, we wanna, we want to believe that there are small things we can do-That help- Yeah... push that orderly transition forward, right? 18:18 But those small things are always keeping these changes external to our lives and our work- Mm-hmm... and our families and, you know, our, our most immediate concerns, right? Sure. They're always out there. 18:28 It's like a charity we do, right? You know? Yeah. Oh, this is the day we take care of the planet. Sure, of course. You know? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And, yeah. And, and, and that's not how it is, right? 18:38 I mean, you know, this is, in fact, the context for our lives is this change. It is the main context. Sure. 18:45 Whatever else we think is going on, part of the discontinuity is that we can no longer keep nature out there and, and the human world here, and our lives, you know- Right... how we want them to be within it. 18:56 And so we're all sort of called to recognize that this is a moment not only of planetary change, but of personal change for every single person on the planet, and that's, that's a heavy lift. 19:07 It's a heavy one, and that's the part where, like [chuckles] it diverges from, from that moment in The Matrix, you know, where he's like, "Or you can just go back to your, to your fucking life in your office." 19:17 Like, the difference now is, like, you can go back to your life in your office, but recognize that it's all gonna change completely because the, the... Mr. Smith and his guys are gonna destroy that as well. 19:29 Like, it's not just two worlds anymore. It's not just this whole thing that's been happening and you didn't know about the whole time. 19:35 That thing is going to intersect with, with your day-to-day that has felt safe and boring and, and it... everything is going to change, and it's already changed, and it's gonna be 19:46 actually really difficult for you to not only comprehend what's coming, but what has already happened. You know, when we see the heat that's, you know, uh, what did they say this week? 19:56 Uh, you know, basically, all, all the salmon in the river in Washington are gone. They're, they're just like, "That's it." They couldn't survive the heat. 20:01 Or the billion starfish in the Pacific Northwes- Northwest that just didn't survive the heat wave. And you're going like, "How can that happen?" You're like, "Well, that- that's the easy thing to understand." 20:11 That's literally just temperature. You know, that's tem- [chuckles] like, fish aren't made to do that. But it's all the interconnected stuff that's going to, that's going to 20:22 af- you know, a- again, it's, it's, it's all the interconnected stuff that's gonna require folks in every part of society to, to look at it and, and take a step back and not only be ready to snap forward, but to, again, like we, we were talking about offline, like, to retrain ourselves to do systems thinking, to look at what- Mm-hmm... 20:39 we've built and go, "Oh, if, if X, then what about, like, Y and Z?" And constantly take the step back and going like, "What else is that connected to? What else..." 20:48 I wrote a whole thing about, like, now is the moment to [chuckles] ask yourself and ask your company and your government, whatever it is, like, "What am I exposed to?" And you can't just... It's not one level. 20:57 It's over and over and over, whether it's your investments or whatever it is, because 21:01 there's just n- it's not like when microchips came out, and they changed the world, and it was great, and that's exciting, and Intel was born, a bunch of people made money. 21:08 Entire sectors are going away, and then everyone is going to have to evaluate their Scope 3 emissions, and entire companies aren't gonna be able to make it through that. Yep. 21:16 And what does that mean from everything from buying your porch furniture, to jobs, to old forests, you know, to Tonga grass? Like, it, it, it just, it goes on and on. So- Yeah, and it, and it- Um-... 21:27 shakes through a whole category- 100%... of the way we think, right? So- Yeah... 21:30 you know, for example, one of the things that, uh, you know, not just I, but a bunch of people have been talking about is how, uh, when we're trying to figure out risk, right, how much risk are we exposed to? 21:41 One of the problems is that it no longer actually makes much sense to ask what is exposed to risk, but to try and figure out the things where the risk is small enough that we don't need to worry about them very much, right? 21:51 Yeah. And then, and then look at everything else that is already exposed to risk and change, right? Sure. That the risk is becoming ubiquitous in our society. Right. Right. 21:59 Um, especially the risk that things will not be as you initially planned for is totally ubiquitous in pretty much every aspect of human society pretty much everywhere right now. Yeah. Right? 22:09 And there are some things where, you know, hey, you don't need to worry about that for now, or, like, that's way down our list of concerns. 22:14 But, you know, that still means there's a whole lot of things above that on the list, right? And- 100%, yeah. Yeah. And, and so there's that, that initial problem. 22:23 There's also the problem that we are, we are used to trying to think of, of, of these things being things that will get fixed, right? Like, oh, we're exposed to this environmental harm, like a toxin or air pollution. 22:40 Well, we gotta pass some laws. We gotta do some things, and it's gonna be fixed. 22:44 In the best case scenario, we're gonna respond to this massive set of ecological and climate problems and stop things from getting worse, or at least not much worse. Right. That's the best- Right... case scenario. 22:54 We're gonna spend the rest of our lives living in the consequences of what people didn't do for the last four decades. And, you know, that's, that's a bummer. Um, it, it, it really sucks. 23:05 There's, you know, there's no other way around that, right? No. That, that was a, a horrible... You know, it was a crime, honestly. It was a crime against- 100%... you know, against humanity to have done that. 23:14 Um, and we did know better. We knew better at the time. People have been saying we should have done things differently for five decades now, right? You know, I... 23:22 One of my first gigs as a young reporter was going to the Earth Summit in 1992, right? Right. When everyone knew, every single leader of every nation- Sure... 23:32 on Earth knew these were problems that were serious then, needed to be addressed, et cetera, right? But we've had this campaign of disinformation. 23:39 We've had campaigns of civic sabotage and predatory delay that mean now we just live in the world where that already happened. Yep. Right? 23:47 The planetary crisis we once were seeking to avoid has already occurred, and we now live in the midst of it, and we're trying to contain its magnitude, right? Right. 23:56 But part of the problem with this legacy of thinking somebody's gonna come along and fix these things is that we also have that thinking about our own lives, right? 24:04 You know, I talked about how we have this idea of like, "Oh, what are the simple things I can do?" Right? 24:08 Treating sort of, you know, the, a, a planetary crisis that's changed the era of [chuckles] human civilization as a charity- Sure... we can set aside. But we also have that- Yeah... in our own lives. 24:17 Like, I can't tell you how many people I have talked to in my life who are like, "Great, so what do we do? Should we all move to Alaska?" Like, you know, "Do you have a-" Oh, all the time... "bunker?" 24:24 Like, how do we- Every day... how do I do a thing right now that will just make this go away for me, even if it's an extreme thing?As long as- Sure... it locks me back into certainty, right? Like as long as- Yeah... 24:35 I can say, "If I built a bunker or moved to Alaska, you know, or invested all my money in clean energy," or whatever the, the thought is that a person's having, grow backyard food, you know, that that's gonna return me to a state of certainty in my life, right? 24:49 And that's not possible anymore, right? We have to-- Part of the difficulty here is we have to become native to the demands of this moment, right? 24:59 And one of those demands is that we, we are going to have to be dynamic and adaptive for the rest of our lives. That's just, well, for de- generations to come. That's just how it comes now. And- Sure... 25:10 if it were as simple as, "Hey, you know, all you need to do is move to Alaska," right, then it would be horrible, but it would be solvable, right? It, it wouldn't be- Sure... confusing and difficult. 25:22 We wouldn't be in a discontinuity. We'd just be, you know, in, pardon the language, a shit storm, you know? Sure. Um- Sure. 25:29 But a shit storm ends, and it's easy to understand, and it's a thing you get over, and it's a thing you get through. It's like strep throat, right? Exactly. [laughs] It's, it's pretty clear. 25:36 It doesn't just keep- Yeah, exactly... fucking changing. And, and that is the thing that we have to be ready for because this is how, I mean, this is how compound interest works. Yeah. You know? 25:46 Um, and the problem is what happens when compound interest is, uh, you know, is mixed with, uh, living systems upon we have not only relied but, uh, exploited the entire way. So- Yeah... 26:00 um, I, I, this is exactly where I wanna go today, right? 26:02 I, I-- You've spent so much time and so much of [chuckles] your career, like you said, since, since 1992, like, on your first job, when everyone's like, "No, we get it," uh, comparing the past to the present and comparing the present to the future and going, "These aren't the same, and they won't be as long as we're around," right? 26:21 Yeah. 26:21 So not only, like, documenting all that, which is very important, like, e- everything that's changed in this relatively incredibly brief timescale of, of modern humanity, but also, and again, this is what I was saying offline, like, 26:36 trying to look forward, trying to extrapolate from the facts on the ground we have now as far as we can and asking questions about 26:47 our options going forward, about our storytelling going forward, about how we measure things going forward, about how we s- what our expectations should be, how we set our attitudes, how we build policy, how we talk to each other, and what the second-order effects all of, all of those things are because, 27:05 I mean, I think especially w- you know, like with kids, like, trying to understand the u- unknowns in a lot of situations is a fool's errand. And, and this is obviously a very specific version of that. 27:16 Um, but my goal whenever I'm sort of welcoming people, uh, you know, to the, to the sort of funeral home that is the, the climate movement at times, is, is to be transparent and practical about, "Look, the-- Okay. 27:30 You, you've seen some shit either happen to you personally or your, your hometown or where your parents are or a loved one or some species you care about or a forest, whatever it might be. Welcome. 27:41 Here's the real context behind that." But then also trying to be, and I, I find, like, this is so important to be as transparent but also as practical as we can about what we- Mm-hmm... 27:52 what's coming but also what we still don't know. And I think, like you said in the email to me, like, how unlikely it is that those unknowns might end up being advantageous to us. Yeah. Um, but what it means 28:07 to have to take on radical global uncertainty. And again, that is, that is why people say, "Can't I just build a backyard garden and this is fixed? Can't I just go to Canada?" 28:19 Which, by the way, got bad news, it's not going great. 28:22 What does it mean as a society for primaries in our election system, you know, for, for all of these things because that is what living, and I, and I've, I've transparently stolen this word, like, living in a discontinuity is, is becoming comfortable, like you said, being in it, but being comfortable and now becoming a species and a business or a family or a person that is defines themself as being adaptable. 28:48 Because otherwise, it's just going to be mentally and spiritually and practically very difficult to get through this thing, much less to contribute- Yeah... to arresting it in any way possible. Um, so 29:03 one of the things, like, I, I've loved in your, in your blog and podcast coming up and I'm sure is gonna be a big [chuckles] part of your book is you've written about how 29:12 c- control, f- for example, which is exactly what w- like you said, 29:17 w- i- is how we've defined ourselves is these orderly transitions, um, whether it's in, in business or the stock market or, or Congress, where we've got a bunch of people who've been in power for f- for 40-plus years, right? 29:29 But that's inherently what we're just going to have less of and how it's just not an option any longer. And 29:35 it reminds me of, maybe you read this, uh, there's a new book, uh, by, uh, Mariana, uh, Maz- uh, Mazzucato, I think is how you pronounce her name. It's called "The Mission Economy." Um- I'm familiar with her work. 29:45 I haven't read that book. Sure. Yeah. It, it's really great. 29:47 It's pretty new, and I'm going to just, uh, very poorly and, and vastly oversimplify it, but the, the main thrust is essentially, like, we have to design policy and economies and, and societies, uh, to an extent to support those, to reflect an achievable, measurable mission. 30:04 What is the output, and what are the measurements we can take along the way? 30:08 And, uh, it reminds me of, uh, I was rereading some of your, you know, old stuff, uh, uh, and things you've said at, like, at, back at Worldchanging. Mm-hmm. 30:16 Um, but it's the opposite of these, like, corporate 2050 net zero pledges from, like, the fucking airlines, right- Yeah... with no intermittent markers along the way. So 30:25 i- it's-- I think about, so, uh, just this week, in, in the, um, in the reconciliation bill, they said, "We're gonna do, uh," one of the things that's included and will probably get cut is we're gonna add dental and vision to Medicare. 30:38 Great.That's an, that's a measurable outcome. How do we... It's like Apollo, right? We're gonna put a man on the fucking moon. Great. Everything else we do has to support that very clear, practical thing. 30:53 And it's the same thing as not net zero, not some vague term that literally nobody can agree on, but just zero emissions. That's threshold, that's table stakes, that's an outcome that's not up for debate. Mm. 31:04 And everything else from how we fund it, and who works on it, and the decisions we make along the time, uh, uh, along the timeline, how dynamic we are, has to support and be able to stand up to that one thing. 31:15 Again, from our societies, to the cars we buy, to debates, whatever it might be. My question is, is do you feel like we can do that? Do you feel like we can rewrite our policymaking- Well-... 31:29 our economies and our societies to do that? I think anyone younger than you and I has no other choice 'cause they were born after 9/11, and they're like, "This whole thing has to b- be redone." 31:41 Like, "We don't have a choice. I don't care about your investments 'cause I'm not part of the stock market anyways." They're like, "It's a zero-sum game." But knowing what we know, 31:50 how, how possible do you feel like that is, and how do we get ourselves to that point where we're willing to make those bets? Yeah. 31:57 Well, I mean, I think that the first question we have to ask ourselves, um, is what are we trying to do, right? Yeah. What, what's the goal? 32:06 And, I mean, we can say some things that we probably all agree on that, like, one of the goals is to have, you know, a, a long-lived, uh, you know, human civilization that gives many people the opportunity to live rich, full lives, 32:21 um, you know- Sure... is, you know, stable and equitable and whatever. We, you know, we can, we can have some, some notions about what human goodness is. Sure. 32:30 But really, the, the, the critical thing is we don't know what the outcome we're seeking is, and we don't know that in very real terms because we haven't engaged with the reality of discontinuity, right? 32:44 That really the number one step we face is understanding- Right... the situation we're in. Because right now- Sure... the number of people who understand it... 32:53 I mean, I, I sometimes half-jokingly say, you know, that, you know, very few people, perhaps no one, has fully engaged with the reality of discontinuity, right? It's hard to do. For sure. It's hard to do. No. 33:05 But- We're not built to do that. [chuckles] No, we are built-- Our brains are built the exact opposite way, right? We look for- Right... pattern and continuity and... But also- Sure... 33:13 we are surrounded by a, a, a political and, and, uh, societal context that really values continuity. 33:20 Um, it values the continuity not of, like, the long continuity of humanity, but the continuity of what's making money right now. Like, where- Mm-hmm... do people have their investments? 33:30 You know, what's my property value? You know, how's my index fund doing? You know, how's the bottom line on the company, et cetera. 33:37 And people really do not wanna rock that boat, and we want to believe that there's something we can do that will, that will maintain that fundamental continuity moving forward. 33:47 And so we think about things like policy as the answer, right? We're gonna get policy that's gonna change things. Sure. Right? First, we get the laws, and then everything changes. 33:58 But that is, uh, it, it's not working, and it's not going to work. Because we, until we wrestle with discontinuity, we can't acknowledge that there are people whose interests radically diverge on this, right? Yeah. 34:12 Um, if we're being blunt, the interests of like, you know, uh, of coal miners, and oil executives, and, you know, Miami Beach real estate, uh, developers diverge strongly from- Yeah... 34:25 your interests, and my interests, and the interests of most people, right? There's not a happy medium there, right? 34:32 The myth is we're gonna bring everyone to the table, we're gonna get everyone to agree, and then we're gonna move forward, right? Sure. 34:38 In an orderly way, and go from this, uh, you know, this, this world to a new world, a new normal that works better. 34:46 And, you know, that, that leads to all sorts of problems, not least of which is it makes it very easy for people who don't actually wanna change at all to sign up and say, "We're part of the change," right? 34:56 "We're-- We've set a net zero goal. By 2050, we're gonna be net zero. We're," you know- 100%. And, and in the meantime, we've- And trees. Right. In the meantime, we've doubled- Right... 35:03 you know, the recycling rates in the office, right? That's our first- Right... step. Like, you know- Sure. Sure. 35:07 And, uh, you know, the absurdity of, uh, of, of, of oil companies talking about their own carbon footprint, right? You know, that kind of thing. And the- Yeah... 35:17 you know, the, the reality is that, uh, until we understand how temporary all the systems are around us, right, and how much torque is built up in the world around us, right, how ready to change almost everything around us is, if it hasn't already changed, then we're just ignoring it. 35:37 Um, until we understand that, we can't design rational outcomes, right? The first step here is understanding how different from our expectations the world has already become, right? 35:48 The first step is the snap forward, right? 35:50 And, and, you know, when we talk about things like how do we get Congress to act, or how do we do these things, I don't believe that there is a way to fashion the politics, the culture, you know, the activism, the business practices, you know, the innovations that we need without first accepting the inherent conflict here between the need to move fast and acknowledge the truth and other people's need to move slow and their denial of reality, right? 36:19 You have to, you have to see that as built into it because that is, that is why nothing has happened so far, you know? Yeah. You know, uh, the-- I think about it though, and, and, you know, not to be-- 36:31 It's hard not to be kind of ruthless when you look at what's already happening and what's already baked in and how many people are already suffering or will, and goO- okay. 36:47 I, I understand that you have different priorities and different vested interests because of your, your business or, or your beliefs or whatever it may be. 36:56 But, uh, you know, I don't have-- we don't have-- I don't have time, and we don't have time to get you on board if y- if you're not- Yeah... like, like you said, we're, we, we're not explaining it to anybody anymore. 37:06 I mean, I wrote about this in our newsletter today, like, uh, we don't have the bandwidth to, like, convince anyone anymore. We- that, that's passed. You get it or you fucking don't. 37:12 Like, and if you, like, if you don't, it's probably because, again, you have vested interest otherwise, or someone has-- It's like you said, the largest, uh, effort and mechanisms behind disinformation that's ever existed, forget it. 37:26 But I, I do wonder if we, we have to find some way to be proactively applying themselves to these things, and I think this is where a lot of this, the angst behind groups like Sunrise comes from, is going, um, yes, we need everyone to understand that there is a snap forward, uh, that we are a, a discontinuity that we are in, and your investments already don't matter, and, and X and Y. 37:51 But at the same time, like, we had to do this stuff yesterday, and so we actually have to be acting in the meantime, and if you're not on board, then we just have to get to fifty-one votes type of thing. You know? 38:00 It's, it's- Yeah... it's- Well, look, I mean, we could- I don't know. It's just pandemonium... we could craft, we could craft a politics. I mean, we, we could certainly craft an imaginary politics that would take- Sure. 38:08 Yeah, of course... take us forward in enormous strides, right? I mean- Of course... the, the, the real secret here, the, the sort of open secret to all this is we already have so many amazing solutions, right? 38:18 There are so many- Oh my God. Yeah... things we already know how to do. And, and- Solar's like free. Solar's essentially free, yeah. [laughs] Yeah. 38:23 I mean, we're already at the, you know, replacement rate for clean energy, right? It's cheaper to- Sure... in many cases to shut down the fossil fuel asset than to continue to run it, you know- Yeah... 38:32 compared to the cost of building and then running- Sure... a, a, a clean energy asset. But- Sure... you know, that's true for efficiency. It's true for urban planning. 38:40 We have amazing progress happening in terms of our understanding of ecological restoration. 38:45 I mean, there are literally millions of people working very hard on creating good solutions and now have been for five decades, and some of those solutions are not just as good as what we have now in pure economic- Right... 38:59 terms. They're better, right? Sure. 39:00 The only reason they're not being deployed and, and taken up is because those who have slow interests have built a vast political machine to control the pace of their own defeat, you know? That is- Hundred percent... 39:12 exactly what... I mean, honestly, one way to describe the Republican Party is a machine for climate predatory delay that also includes evangelical Christians, right? 39:23 I mean- Hundred percent, but it also reminds me of 2010, and I remember sitting next to someone on a plane who was arguing against what became Obamacare covering pre-existing conditions, and my only thought was, and again, this is where it gets dark, is, "Oh, you must not have a family member with a pre-existing condition." 39:43 'Cause if you've, if you have any connection to someone with one, the fact that they cannot go to the doctor, besides the emergency room, which destroy-- Uh, like, Americans [chuckles] going to the emergency room destroys our entire system in four hundred different ways. 39:56 But if you're not expo... If you were exposed to someone with a pre-existing condition in any way, there's no way you could vote against this thing unless you have just an enormous vested interest against it, right? 40:06 You would be arguing against your own personal human dignity, right? Against- Yeah. Well, and, and people, you know-... potentially family or friends or whatever it can be. 40:15 People- And that's where you see the Miami thing, people going, uh, you know, "We're, we're, we're moving here for Bitcoin," and whatever it might be, and it's great, but your buildings are falling down, and your foundation's made out of Swiss cheese. 40:23 At some point, you're gonna be exposed enough that you, you, you, you have to get on board in some way. 40:30 Well, so, you know, there's, there's, there's an old, there's an old saying that good strategy is about winning than fighting, right? You know? Sure. 40:37 Um, and I think in a very real way, all good climate strategy, all good sustainability strategy is the same, that we are not going to first convince everyone, second come up with a plan, and then third- Right... act. 40:50 That- Hundred percent... that, that is the orderly transition model, and it has- Yeah... already failed. It has zero chance- Yeah... of happening now. It is no longer possible to do that. 41:00 What we're gonna have is instead, you know, a whole set of conflicts and interventions where various folks who need new solutions to happen figure out how to make those solutions beat other existing practices. Right. 41:18 Right. And the b- one of the real problems with not being able to see the discontinuity is we don't realize that that is inevitable. That is inevitably- Yeah... 41:25 gonna happen across every single system in every single human society that doesn't completely fall apart. Some will. There are places that are going to be hit very hard in the coming decades- Mm-hmm... 41:36 and are gonna have a very hard time even holding on. But most of human society is not gonna be hit that hard, and what we're gonna see is a, is that torque being released, right? 41:46 And it's gonna change, um, you know, everything from investment decisions, to policy choices, to, like, our culture and the way we think about our own futures and our own lives, right, 41:57 you know, to how the economy works, how we need to educate our kids. It's gonna change... It is already beginning to change every single aspect of human society. 42:05 And so we have this idea that what we're trying to do, right, is, like, push this huge boulder of climate action, of, of, of sustainability up this really steep hill, and we just need to get more people behind it and push that boulder. 42:18 If we can just bring more people up on board, we're gonna get it to the top of the hill, and thank God, then we're good. Right. But that's not the situation we're in. 42:25 The situation is the boulder's already at the top of the hill, right? Right. And there... 42:29 And we want it to roll down, and there's a whole bunch of people who are making money keeping it propped up, you know, [chuckles] at the top of the hill. Hundred percent. Yeah. 42:36 Like, you know, holding it up there, keeping it from rolling, right? Right. And, and the sooner it rolls, the better it is for almost everybody in society, right? 42:44 The only people for whom it is not better are those people who have-You know, slow investments, slow, you know, slow, uh, priorities they can't get out of. And frankly- Sure... 42:54 that's a, that's a small number of people and, you know, they're doing the wrong thing. They're doing the wrong thing. They need to be... You know, our concern should not be focused on them. 43:02 Our concern should be focused on our kids and their kids and our grandkids, you know? Right. Their grandkids. Like, we should be thinking about who really benefits and who really loses, and how many people are... 43:13 What, what's the greater good for the greatest number? 43:16 And absolutely the most rapid climate action, sustainability action, you know, the ruggedization of our systems and cities, you know, the, the, the creation of sustainable prosperity, the acceleration of change, these are absolutely good for way more people. 43:30 You know, billions- Oh, yeah... more people than, than slow progress, quote unquote, would be. 43:35 But also, Stewart Brand has that great quote that, like, the greatest good for the greatest number will always be about future generations, 'cause most of the people who will ever live- Haven't been born yet... 43:45 have not yet been born, right? Sure. And so if we're talking about what is right and fair and good, the immediate destruction of slow systems is what's right and fair and good. 43:54 And, and the rapid im- you know, implementation of sustainability solutions, you know, of ruggedization, of restoration, of the things we know how to do, and we know that those things by and large will leave us better off than what we currently have. 44:07 Sure. Right? And it's only- Right... the inability to see what we currently have as brittle, as about to fall down, as, you know, as in fact losing us money, et cetera- Sure... 44:18 because of our current debate, the inability to see that makes it look like we're giving up prosperity and wealth for some crazy broken, you know, ecological future. 44:27 But it's actually for most of us the exact opposite of that. Sure. Right? Yeah. We're giving up a system that's losing us money, that's exposing us to danger, that's, like, harming our children, right? 44:36 That's making the planet unlivable and, like, human societies way more, you know, vulnerable and unstable for a world in which we have at least leveled off the threats to civilization and created the seeds for prosperity for a lot more people in ways that are more- Sure... 44:52 ruggedized to the realities that we face today. I mean, I, I think the open secret of this moment is not how bad things are, it's how good they can get and how quickly if we- Sure... 45:03 face up to reality, if we take that initial snap forward, right? Um, so that, I mean, that's- Yeah, and-... kinda where I'm coming from. No, no, no, I, I agree with you. And, and this is the, the... 45:12 When, when, when I t- [laughs] when, when I'm like, you know, people will ask the questions, they wanna engage on these things, or they say they wanna engage, and I go like, "You know, okay, how m- how much time do you have and, and how much you, you wanna really get into this?" 45:23 And, and you have to start with this fact that, like you said, uh, how, okay, how do we get into a discontinuity? A- and you dial it down to first principles. 45:32 W- we have based our, and fought over, and then decided upon, uh, economies, societies, and, and geopolitics that are entirely dependent on and constructed on a single finite resource that powered the entire Industrial Revolution of the West, 45:55 but also ruined everything, and ruined everything in this incredibly unequal way. 46:01 Uh, and i- we've had, we've even d- [laughs] you know, it's e- i- it's like when people talk about, uh, you know, uh, their ex-partners and talking about ignoring red flags and things like that. 46:11 It's like we've ignored so many red flags. 46:13 And then you get to something like COVID, and, and Ed Yong in The Atlantic had this great quote about, you know, it's like a flood going down a sidewalk and it's leaking into every crack that's been there along the way. 46:23 And, and m- my version of that that I've harped on is, is essentially, you know, it, of course it started b- before this, but for, for mainstream Americans, March, whatever it was, 13th 2020, whatever that Friday was when everyone's like, "I'm getting my kid out of school," 46:38 that was our pop quiz. And that was our pop quiz, and the, the, the quiz was, what are all of the decisions that you as a society have made up to this point? Now we're gonna see how they hold up. 46:53 And we failed on most of them. And so many of them come down to, oh, this thing, this resource that you've built everything on, 47:04 both by design and by necessity to the people in charge, which mostly look like guys like you and me, it made millions of people sick with preexisting cardio-respiratory conditions. 47:15 And now you've got this relatively unique virus that comes along, and it's kinda like this perfect virus. 47:22 It's less deadly than SARS, uh, which is good on one hand, but on the other hand that means it can get spread everywhere, and it attacks our cardio- uh, respiratory and cardiopulmonary, uh, systems in, in these crazy ways. 47:34 But if you've already got these preexisting conditions, because we've got millions of Black and brown kids that live within 30 miles of a coal plant or next to, in Los Angeles, fucking untapped oil wells next to- Right... 47:44 your school and your house. Freeways, yeah. Exactly. You're already done. And that all comes back to that single thing. All the wars we fought, all these things. And like you said, we're not... 47:53 W- yes, w- we're, we're in this discontinuity now because of those things, because all of these things are way more connected than we ever anticipated. 48:00 Um, it's not just Mark Wahlberg movies and, and what i- what oil exploded in the ocean when. It's what does that do over time to every one of these systems? 48:08 And like you said, w- this, this system that not that we want to build, that w- we need to have started building forever ago, uh, is going to be 48:19 so much better for so many people, because in the past hundred years all they've had is exposure to the worst elements of this thing. 48:27 That's, that's for me is the, is, is where I'm fine with these [laughs] old institutions of power completely being dissected and crumbling, and I think, uh, where so many of the young people feel the same way. Yeah. 48:40 All they have ever felt is elections that were lost, is poisoned air, is poisoned water- Yeah... is just massive inequality. And they're like, "II-- Like, you think I care about the stock market? 48:51 Like, I can't even invest in the stock market, and also most of your companies aren't gonna exist through this discontinuity anyways. Yeah. You know? 48:57 We have to, we have to tear the whole thing down 'cause this is the end of the beginning. This is version one, and it was a nightmare. 49:03 Uh, I mean, believe me, I am, uh, [chuckles] I am very sympathetic to the idea of, you know, burn it all down, right? Uh- Sure. Uh- And of course you have to have just transitions... 49:12 you know, you can't do this for, for, for three decades like I have and not- Right... you know, have a, a deep reservoir of rage, you know, about- Yeah... how- 100%... 49:22 how horrible many of the decisions that have been made have been and how much they've harmed people, how much they've harmed not just nature, but, but, but people. 49:31 I think it's really important, again though, to, to understand that, like, we have a narrative here, that this is an issue, that it will be solved- Sure... by advancing changes, you know, um, and- Right... 49:45 and by, by creating policy and, and- Right... and incentives that will move the ball forward until we've solved the issue like we're trying to solve, you know, gun violence or racism, right? Sure. Right. Um, 49:58 but it's not an issue, right? Yeah. We're not going to solve it, and I think the idea that the first step is we sort of overthrow everything and then we- Right... then we fix it is, uh, delusional. Um- Sure... 50:12 I, I don't think we're going to overthrow everything. I think that what we're gonna have is a society that still has many of the exact same problems we have today, but is now- Of course... 50:21 responding to the realities of today. And that- Well, in a lot of ways they already are just 'cause it's... 50:26 Look, I mean, you, you say who's leading the way on installing solar power, and it's businesses, not 'cause they give a shit, but because it's better for the bottom line. Right. 50:32 I mean- Capitalism is still running the game... way more, way more people benefit from change now than benefit from delay, way more people, and that includes- 100%... 50:40 investors and companies and national governments- 100%... you know, et cetera. It includes all the halls of power, right? The, uh- Yeah... you know, there are slow nations, but most nations are fast, right? 50:50 There are, there are- No, and I, I-... slow political parties, but most political parties are- Right... are, are understanding that they, that they need to start becoming faster. And, and- Sure... 50:59 that, you know, the important thing to understand, I think, is that we still keep trying to grapple with this as something that we're going to find a way out of. But it's not- Sure... a thing that we're moving through. 51:14 It just is reality now. It just is. Right? Yeah, of course. And, and so we... All of the questions that we had before still exist, and they're not going away. 51:21 We're not gonna, like, solve every societal issue with the, with the, you know, with the move towards sustainability and ruggedization and- Of course... sensible, sensible ideas. 51:31 We're gonna remain in a situation where some people are deeply disadvantaged and horribly, tragically compromised, in fact, many more people than today. 51:40 But if we're also, if we're very smart, we're gonna also live in a situation where billions of people are rising up out of poverty, where people have, even as they're exposed to greater threats, greater capacity to survive those wis- those threats and to withstand those threats with prosperity intact. 51:55 You know, that's the world that we're moving in. And it, it gets so... There's... 52:00 I have, at least, I mean, you know [chuckles] it sounds like you do too, like, I have such a desire for there to be a bad guy to defeat until we level up and level up- Always... and get the big boss and win. 52:09 That's the way- You know?... we've been trained, right? Yeah, yeah. That's the way we've been trained. That's the narrative. That's why- Right? 52:12 Like- And that was the, look, for, for, for better or, or, or worse, what- however way you felt it, this was the, uh... And, and I campaigned for him. 52:19 The problem with Obama from the beginning, right, is that every- and he has said this, is that everyone put on him this completely untenable expectation for what he could be, and there were a thousand different versions of that. 52:35 And in that case, it's impossible not to fail. And it's the same thing for... Like, that's the hope version of finding the good guy that's gonna save us all, right? 52:42 And it's the same thing for, for Biden winning and, and changing his, most of his politics along the way, and what's he gonna do, and hiring this all-star climate team along the way, and then you get mad because the Justice Department's [chuckles] being independent, but that's the whole point, is we want them to... 52:56 Like, it goes on and on and on, right? We want it to be that simple. We want, like you said, gun control, right? God, I, I fucking hate guns. I'm so tired of the whole thing. 53:03 We had, we had, uh, uh, you know, Gutenberg on, and he, and his, his daughter was mowed down in her school, and you're just like, "M- melt all the guns down, and can we just fucking be done with this?" Right? Yeah. 53:14 That is also complicated, but it's a hell of a lot more simple than this. My point when I talk about these, these sunrise kids are, are... 53:21 I mean my kids, who are white privileged kids and are gonna be fine, but everyone else that has been marginalized the whole time and is, and is angry and ca- [chuckles] and grew up reading, uh, Hunger Games, you know, is I not only want to, want to, uh, be an ally to them as much as I can, my goal is, is the, the outcome. 53:40 The means that we get there requires everyone, right? 53:42 So it means empathizing with them and allying with them in the same way that when, uh, CEOs or investors or founders or whoever, VCs, call me about w- how can I take advantage of this as an opportunity, right, on the capitalistic side. 53:55 And because they're like, "Look, we're invested in all these things, and they're all going south," whatever it might be. It's looking at them and, like you said, going, 54:01 "These are the biggest markets that are ever going to exist, and it's not even close, and these are the ways you can participate in those, whether it's investing or founding it, something, and whatever it is." 54:10 And a lot of the sunrise kids are gonna hate that 'cause they're like, "Fuck capitalism. Burn the whole thing down." Sure. I'm like, "No, I, I get it." But isn't, isn't that the role- I get it... 54:17 of being young in our society, is to be like- Of course... "Look at all- Yeah... look at all the things that are fucked up." Of course. "Let's change all this," right? Of course. You know? 54:23 And, and- And they're more justified than anyone's ever been, but, you know- Yeah, and-... it's, you have... We need everybody. Well, I think that 54:31 I, uh, on the one hand, I agree, and on the other hand, I totally disagree. Please. Because I think that, like- Yeah... the reality of this situation is that this crisis is a professional crisis, right? Sure. 54:42 Most of the decisions, in fact, almost all the important decisions about how things are changing or not in our society are made by people whose job it is to make that decision, right? Of course. 54:53 And the pe- Like you talked about with the disinformation... and... Exactly, and the people who have-You know, the power to influence those decision-makers, right, are also by and large professionals, right? Of course. 55:04 You know, we're talking about classes of people who are... 55:06 You know, on the one hand, there's like the billionaires and so forth, but just, you know, the top 10% in wealthy societies, right, are full of people who have assets, have political access, have education, et cetera, and that's like the top 2% of the globe, right? 55:20 Sure. And so on the one hand, yes, do we need everyone? In, in a certain way, yes. But in- Of course... the reality is that, that most of the job is gonna get done by that top 2% of humanity. Of course. 55:30 And most of the job within that's gonna happen, you know, bet- with the people who, who their actual work is to decide, do we build, you know, a, a solar farm or a new coal plant, right? Do we build- Yeah... 55:42 a new highway or do we densify around a new rail line, right? 55:46 Do we, you know, continue to do what we're doing now or do we, you know, build a seawall and create a wetland and whatever to protect the city from rising seas? 55:55 These are the decisions that, that make, that make the world. And 56:01 I get frustrated and sometimes even pretty angry when people put on, for example, youth climate activists, the responsibility to change things, 'cause it's not their responsibility. 56:11 They're doing exactly what they should do and say, "Hey-" They didn't make this fucking mess. Well, and they have no power to change it. That's the thing. Yeah, of course. 56:16 We have to get real about power, who has power and who doesn't. 56:20 And in our world, it's people with professional training, investable income, and political connections, right, and, you know, and good educations and so forth who, who have the power. And, and- Yeah... 56:31 generally that's older people. You know? Not always, but generally. 56:34 And generally it's people who are highly concentrated in the developed world and in the, and in the parts of the, of the developing, in quotes, world, that are already pretty rich, right? 56:44 Like parts of China and parts of India. You know, there are- Of course... there are a lot of very wealthy people. Well, we're the ones who are... You know, you and I are both in that group, right? And- Sure... 56:53 we're the ones who are gonna have to make these decisions. 56:56 And I think it, it starts to really get obsessive and it, it becomes an obsessive belief in the power of truth-telling to bring on an orderly transition when that is not what's gonna do it, right? 57:09 A recognition of reality, like not the speaking truth to power part of it, but the recognition that this has already happened and now we need to adapt to it. That is- Sure... 57:18 that is the revolutionary breakthrough in terms of changing the, the behavior of people whose job it is to make these decisions, you know? And, and I get- Of course... 57:28 I get very frustrated, not because I don't believe in, you know, in climate justice or in youth activism or, or et cetera. Of course I believe in these things. I spent my entire life fighting- Sure... 57:37 in many ways for these things. But we let ourselves off the hook. 57:41 People like you and I and the people listening to this show and our friends and colleagues and, you know, bosses and so forth, we let ourselves off the hook by saying we need everyone, blah, blah, blah. 57:51 What we really need is we need us. Sure. We need the people- No, fully... who have the power to make the decisions to make the decisions, you know? And- Absolutely. 57:58 Yeah, and- That's the only thing that's gonna get it there. I mean, look- Yeah... 58:01 th- the entire United St- I mean, we, we mythologize this all the time, but, but, uh, you know, the future of the United States, uh, as much as the, as Rob wrote about a couple weeks ago, like, as much as the green vortex, as he put it, has worked the past, you know, decade almost inadvertently, uh, but thank God it, it, it has made so much progress. 58:19 Uh, you know, it comes down to this one senator from West Virginia or, or the one, uh, turns out very moderate senator from, from Arizona. And, and as much as, uh... Look, I, I'm for the kitchen sink approach. 58:31 Like, this is why I pick up the phone when someone calls and says, "Jesus Christ," and says something dark like, "What, what, what, what can my company do to benefit from COVID?" And I'm like, 58:41 "Ignoring the fact that, like, you're a sick person," [laughs] um, you know, "Here, here, here are the things." 58:46 Because if I can at all turn them into being a benefit in some way because they have the levers of power, then I will do whatever I can to do that. And it's the same thing for getting that 51st vote. 58:57 If it, if, if the whole pie is, as they are l- I think still right now, these, uh, Sunrise LA kids have been camped out on Feinstein's doorstep for like three days. 59:07 If that is part of it as well as whatever donors have to donate to her or get her to retire or whatever it might be, I'm, a- again, the, whatever the means are to get us there, great. 59:18 The climate justice part, it's all of it. But we ha- we cannot... 59:20 Like, I, I think the, the point, not to put words in your mouth, where, but what you're getting to is, like, we would be, especially folks like us would be so naive to think that fundamental, systemic, societal change or even human change just happens because we are marching in the streets, is not how it works. 59:39 I mean, we... How many, how many Black people have been killed in the streets for so many years? Millions of people marched last year. 59:45 Millions of people across the entire world, tens of millions of people, and w- and one guy barely got justice for kneeling on videotape on a guy's neck. That's what it took to get to that point. Like, barely. 59:57 So the idea that we're gonna get rid of capitalistic society is, is just, it's incorrect and it's black or white. That's not the way it's gonna work. 1:00:05 But I will do whatever it takes to m- like I, I, I've always put just nudge the needle of progress as far as we can every time, because I think- Mm-hmm... 1:00:12 I think any anticipation that we're gonna do more than nudge it is naive, but I also think that if you, it's the, w- what is the Japanese tenet? Uh, you know, 1% every day get... 1:00:25 Looks, doesn't look like much, but over time it adds up. 1:00:28 You know, we have to do these things every time, and any win we get in, on a state level, on a local level, on a federal level, international level for these non-binding treaties, whatever the thing is, I will push every day, whatever the stakeholder is, 'cause like you said, these people don't have power. 1:00:45 They can camp out on our doorstep and it's great, and I support it, and any of these people are like, "Great, I'll send 200 bucks a month to Sunrise." 1:00:51 Okay, great, but what can, what, what is your company capable of doing? You know, what is your, what, who are you close to that you can influence? 1:00:59 'Cause I will be ruthless and vigilante about getting us wherever it takes us... uh, to get there. You know, so I, I totally, you know, I, I am with you. Um, 1:01:11 and at the same time, I think one of the, one of the things that I, that I'm trying to help folks see is that 1:01:20 our idea of how change happens, our model of change, is built on a model of, of, of trying to, you know, nudge forward, push forward progress on specific issues, right? Sure. And this is not an issue. 1:01:35 What we face is not an issue- Right... it can't be fixed through activism. It can't be fixed through policy. No, of course not. Right? It can't be fixed. 1:01:42 But like, but it also, we can't respond those ways through the kind of power that we're able to marshal in these narrow avenues, right? Sure. 1:01:51 Within a, you know, within activism that is at best partially effective, escer- especially when done by people who have very little power other than power of showing up. Sure. 1:02:00 And, you know, but also that can't be done in policy arenas where predatory delay and civic sabotage have pre-limited the outcomes available to such an extent that those outcomes no longer include what we need to do, right? 1:02:13 You can't win the fight because the fight is already set up to be lost, right? Right. If, if- You can't fight and win. Let, let me- Or further... hear me out. Hear me out... if they've literally changed the fight. Right. 1:02:22 Hear me out, exactly. Um, you know, that, that you cannot fight to win because the situ- the wi- the victory condition is no longer contained within the game, right? 100%. Um, and so the, the, the problem we face, right? 1:02:38 Is that the, is that the situation is that the world has already changed to a degree very few of us, if any of us, are really capable of grasping. It has already, right now, while we're talking. 1:02:51 And everything around us is still oriented towards the previous understanding of the world, towards the old systems, the old ways of doing things, including activism, including politics. Yeah. Right? 1:03:03 And so part of the challenge is having to understand that the recognition of that reality is itself incredibly disruptive, which is why so much effort has been spent to keep us from recognizing it, to keep us from- Of course... 1:03:17 discussing it, right? And it is disruptive not only to the people who have a stake in preventing change, but also it's disruptive to all of us who've acquired professional expertise or social standing or, or- Oh, yeah... 1:03:31 political power. You enjoy democracy. Yeah. Well, I mean- Yeah... who, who are benefiting from the way that things are set up, right? Sure. 1:03:39 And we have a lot of triangulation in our society where people are like, "Well, you know, we're gonna do this part now," right? You know, big goal's down the road. We all want, you know- Sure... 1:03:48 uh, net zero, but we're gonna do this part now. And people who are experts in doing this part now, but doing this part now has become part of the way we deny the reality of our situation, that we don't face- Sure... 1:03:59 the reality that we are already in this massive discontinuity where everything we thought we knew no longer works. Right. 1:04:07 And where we do have a lot of good ideas, a lot of knowledge, a lot of insight into what we can do next, right? 1:04:14 But we have to begin with the understanding that we're not going to change what we have into what needs to happen. It's already in discontinuity. It's already disrupted. It's in upheaval. Yeah. 1:04:24 And so what we're building is something out of that dyn- dynamic, right? And that's a very different task than having people sit in at, you know, Feinstein's office, right? I mean, that may- For sure... 1:04:34 or may not be helping. Um, it certainly, I don't think it does any harm. Um- Right... but, but we need to understand that what's already happened, right? We're not yet prepared for what's already happened. 1:04:45 And a big part of what I'm trying to say, you know, with The Snap Forward, is that if we wanna understand how to be effective in the world, we have to understand first when we are, right? Yeah. 1:04:56 We have to get to when, when we are and act from that premise, and that so much of what we're trained to do about this situation is ineffective not because we're bad people, or, or it was badly intentioned, or that, you know, it was a stupid idea when it was created, but simply because it's of a different world. 1:05:13 It's from a world- Sure... we no longer live in. And, and so, you know, a lot of what's gonna need to happen in my point-- from my point of view is that we're gonna need to win a whole lot of fights, right? 1:05:22 You know, win a whole lot of battles, and then go back and fight to have it integrate into a better society, right? Sure. We don't have time to, like, take it stepwise and hope that- Right... 1:05:31 in 20 years policy comes through that brings us forward, because in 20 years we'll live in a whole 'nother planet yet, yet again. Oh, of course. Right? Oh, of course. 1:05:39 And- People ask me all the time, they're like, "What do you think college is gonna look like in 10 years?" I'm like, "Oh, this is [laughs] the... 1:05:45 We're, we're s- for- forget-" Like, you think that's the thing that's gonna change? Like, it's, it's wild, man. Did you read, um, or see, um... I- I'm sure you're familiar with Eric Holthaus. Sure, yeah. 1:05:56 Uh, meteorologist and writer. He wrote a great book last year called The Future Earth. Um, and I, I really enjoy it because it... 1:06:05 Well, it doesn't, it's not as, as necessarily, uh, aggressive as, as probably or even our conversation today, but the first part of it does set up like, look, this is what's baked in and is already happening, but 1:06:18 this is the Earth we can build over the next 40 years. It's going to be very rough, especially these... And he sections it off by decade. 1:06:26 The next 10 and the 10 after that is- and actually th- that second bit is actually gonna probably be the worst of it. But if we make monumental, encompassing, overwhelming progress along the way, 1:06:39 here's the little benefits we might start to see for more people than have ever had help before, and past that, what that might look like. 1:06:47 But it's important to acknowledge in every step, and I think he does a really good job of, like you're saying, like this i- this just is, which sounds like something from the Bible, right? 1:06:55 Like, this is what it is right now, and this is what it is for as long as it's w- you and I certainly will ever know, and, and our children and their grandchildren- YeahOverwhelming, fundamental 30,000 feet down to ground level change, and not just once, not just twice, but over and over and over, and some of that's gonna be very difficult to comprehend. 1:07:17 It's like the first time you're in Berkeley that you've ever, uh... Earthquakes that shake are scary. Earthquakes where the ground rolls, I don't know if you've been in one of those. Sure, yeah. 1:07:25 Those are the ones that fuck with your head, because our lizard brains aren't really programmed to think that the earth can move underneath- Right... your feet. And that is [laughs] you know, it's not, uh, uh- Right. 1:07:34 Why are there waves on the ground? Yeah, exactly. It's, it's- Right. Yeah, yeah. It, it, it doesn't add up, and that's what a lot of this is. But... 1:07:41 And not that we can control earthquakes, but it's, it's we can build this much better thing, but the old way of doing it, which I fully agree with, uh, and, and I think we probably, uh, uh, agree on, on more than we're letting on here, is that, which is just, like, it's going to require not just everything we know how to do, but acknowledging that most of that's not gonna work, and so how do we do everything within the scope of what actually might be possible? 1:08:05 Yeah, and I think, you know, a- again, part of what I'm trying to do with The Snap Forward is to help us move our thinking into a new place, right? And, you know, uh, I like Eric's work. 1:08:18 Um, he interviewed me for that book. Uh, you know, um, I think it's a good book. Uh, but there's a challenge, which is it verges on what, you know, what I call safe utopias, right? 1:08:30 And, and, and a safe utopia is a place where we solve our problems, right? Without having to address fundamental conflicts that exist in our society, right? 1:08:40 Where, where the, the problems resolve themselves through bringing everyone together. Safe utopias are an essential part of the idea of an orderly transition, right? 1:08:48 That we can get to an end point where everything's gonna be better for people, no matter... You know, yes, things have changed permanently. 1:08:54 We live in a new world, but everything's gonna be better for people because we come together, right? And, and I am, you know, 100% pro coming together. 1:09:03 But I also think we have to acknowledge that conflict is baked into every aspect of the problems that we're facing now, right? That this crisis- Also just who we are. Who we are, but also... I mean, certainly. 1:09:14 And there, there's competition, and, and, you know, a- and, and the desire to, you know, gain power and status over others. These are- Of course... major human drives. 1:09:23 But like, but also just that every system around us has somebody who is going to fight as long as they can to keep things the same way, because it's good for them, right? 1:09:36 And that there's no way that we're going to talk those people out of giving up their power, because so many of them have held on for so long that there's no transition there. Sure. Yeah. 1:09:45 You can't transition coal now, right? There's no way- Right... to get... Save the coal industry. Yeah. Right. The only thing we're doing with coal is shutting it all down as soon as- Right... we possibly can, right? 1:09:54 Right. So there's no way to bring, like, coal interests and people who care about the planetary future to the table together and agree on an outcome. Sure. There's just no way that's ever gonna happen, right? Right. 1:10:06 It's a zero-sum conflict because- Unless that-... of how long we've waited... unless that outcome is th- how do we just... Uh, uh, we have to start by acknowledging that coal is over, and go from there. Yeah. 1:10:17 I mean, but even, I mean, we could have a whole discussion about the coal industry, right? Oh, God, yeah. Because I- Oh, yeah. No, no... 1:10:22 I think that actually it's one of the biggest mistakes progressive politics has made, is identifying coal miners as, as an emblem of climate justice. I think it's- Sure... 1:10:31 catastrophic to our thinking, because they're not, right? When you- Sure... are the person doing the crime, right? Yeah. You are not a victim of that crime. No matter- Well, you've also known you've- You know... 1:10:42 been a part of it for 25 years. Like, it's ne- we're- this isn't- Exactly... the old days anymore. There, there, uh, there have been so many offers on the table, so many opportunities to do things differently. 1:10:50 And so, anyway, but that's a whole other issue, right? I'm with you. 1:10:53 The, the point that I'm trying to make is that we s- we really want there to be ways in which this resolves itself back into continuity, into a new stability, into orderliness- Sure... 1:11:05 that it all makes sense again, that we all are in it together. But that's not the world we live in now, right? Yeah. 1:11:11 We live in a world that is disorderly, that's, you know, that is full of upheaval and discontinuity that, you know, where we are not going to arrive in our lifetimes at a new normal, right? Right. 1:11:21 For the rest of our lives- Yeah... part of the nature of our lives is to not have a normal that we can just go, "Well, this is how things are, so I'm just gonna plan for that," right? Sure. 1:11:29 That is the real crisis, right? The real crisis- Right... is that's the way things are now, and we're not admitting it, right? That is the- Right. I think-... 1:11:37 fundamental part of the crisis, is like the world is already disorderly, discontinuous. You know, there is no transition. There's no new normal. There's no safe harbor at the end of this. 1:11:49 There's just building a society that can live within the new era that we've created, or not. 1:11:54 Right, and that's what, I mean, I, I mean, I think normal then is, if, if we, the, if you use like a definition of what is your ex... Like, can there be an expectation? 1:12:03 And if you wanna call that normal, the expectation needs to be unpredictive or unpredictable, uh, complete upheaval- Yeah... essentially. And, and that's just what you're... 1:12:14 I mean, e- everything comes down to setting expectations, right? [laughs] I mean- Yeah... 1:12:17 whether it's, whether it's profits or participation, I mean, that's, that's what we're- Well, the more people who engage in a snap forward, the more people who take on, like, thinking about when we actually are and what that means- Sure... 1:12:28 the faster we're gonna find good solutions and be able to figure out how to assemble all these amazing opportunities we have- Sure... and solutions and better ways of doing things into new models that work, right? Sure. 1:12:40 It's just, we can't expect that the measurement of success of that is that we restore a new normal- Right... because it's not in our capability at this point. 1:12:49 Maybe our kids will, maybe our great-grandkids will, but it's not in- Sure... our capability now, and that's not the win scenario for humanity. 1:12:55 The win scenario for humanity is we minimize the damage, we minimize the suffering, and we elevate possibility, right? I mean, that's- Sure... the win scenario. 100%. Like, yeah. 100%. I mean, that's... 1:13:05 Yeah, we, we can't change what age we were born into, but this is, this is the job we've signed up for, which is just to begin, uh, 1:13:14 begin the proactive-undertaking of the transition as much as we can control it, which is very little, and the old ways not only don't work, but just don't apply in any way anymore. 1:13:27 So w- w- work within the systems, uh, where it's necessary. I mean, we... For instance, you have to pass this reconciliation [chuckles] bill to do anything, but what is literally the next step past that? 1:13:38 And it has to be something that's just fundamentally different. Yeah. I gotcha. 1:13:42 So listen, uh, we always wanna end with specific action steps that people can take, and, uh, obviously this is a much more philosophical talk than a lot of ours. But I, uh... 1:13:51 if you could spend a little time talking about, again, like, what are the specific places, the, the specific questions people can ask representatives, for instance, the people with the power, or the specific places they can go to educate themselves or to level up so that they can feel like they are actually starting to, again, snap forward to acknowledge that we are in a disco- besides the fact that they already listen to this fucking show, like, that they're [chuckles] in a discontinuity. 1:14:15 I mean, they already signed up for this thing. So where can we go? How can we get more people on board and rolling with this thing? Yeah. 1:14:22 Well, I mean, you know, uh, one easy answer is, uh, folks can sign up for my newsletter, which is, uh- Perfect... free and is available, uh, on Substack, uh, alexsteffen.substack.com, or you can Google The Snap Forward. 1:14:34 Um, and, you know, a lot of what I do in the newsletter, or if folks wanna support the, the, the, the newsletter, they can get a free pod- or a paid podcast as well, uh- Mm-hmm... for subscribers. 1:14:44 Um, and a lot of what I'm doing in both of those is trying to explore these questions. How do we think about it? What do we know? 1:14:50 And I, you know, I do along the way, both there and in my Twitter feed, which is just @alexsteffen, try and, uh, refer to informative things that I've found, right? Like I, I do try- Mm-hmm... 1:15:01 and, uh, I try and do a lot of spotlighting of good stuff, stuff that's- Mm-hmm... interesting to think about. Um, I think that the biggest thing people can do other than starting... 1:15:13 You know, there's, there's the, you know, George Clinton mind free, uh, line, "Free your mind and your ass will follow," right? Right. [chuckles] I think starting by freeing our minds and understanding- Yeah... 1:15:21 that we live in a discontinuity is the biggest thing any of us can do. Sure. 1:15:26 But after that, you know, one of the things that we can all aim for is, uh, having informed discussions with people in our lives, whether those are our elected representatives or our neighbors or our best friends or our colleagues, where we start to talk about these things, not as something, not as an issue we have to do a thing on, right? 1:15:44 Not like, "Hey, do we have- Sure... a climate giving program," or, "What's your policy on climate?" Right? Yeah. But as, as a change in the world we need to adapt to, right? Sure. 1:15:55 Um, a thing that we need to now respond to as, as a center of what's going on, and I think the more people who are even asking those questions, right? Including in our own families, right? Um- Yeah... you know. 100%. 1:16:06 How, how do we figure out if where we're living is a good place to stay? How are we gonna talk with our kids about what's going on, right? You know, how are, how are our kids being educated? 1:16:16 Are they being educated to understand the vastness of the discontinuity they're gonna live their lives in, in a way that they're able to process, right? Um- Right... 1:16:24 uh, uh, in an age appropriate and, you know, caring kind of way. Um, in our professional lives, are we acquiring the skills we need? 1:16:31 Are we making the investments with whatever resources we have in the kinds of things that are going to, you know, thrive and prosper and make a difference in the, in the world ahead, right? In the new- Sure... right? 1:16:46 You know, or, or aren't we? And h- if so, you know, like how do we figure that out? You know, but also even in our own... I think in our own lives, trying to understand the, what's going on ar- on around us, 1:16:58 not just as tragedy, right? But, but as change, you know, that has tragic elements. It has loss, you know- Sure... but it also has growth, and we can't see the growth because it's hard for us to see when we are, right? 1:17:15 We can't see the possibility. We can't see the opportunity. 1:17:18 But to my mind, one of the most important things that we can do is when we wake up in the morning and this thought hits us, to ask, "What is opening up for us," not just what's closing down, right? Sure. 1:17:29 We're losing species. We're losing ecosystems. Cities will be destroyed. People will be impoverished. Bad things are happening, but what else is happening, right? 1:17:38 Because the fact is once you start, once you leave behind the assumption that we're gonna protect all these old systems that are already broken, you know, that we're gonna have a, a, an orderly transition, once you leave that assumption behind, all sorts of possibility opens. 1:17:51 Well, we could build better societies. We can build- Sure... materially better economies. You know, we can do things to protect cities. We can do things to welcome refugees. 1:18:00 We can do things to, you know, safeguard ecosystems. Um, the, the, the, the number of things we are capable of doing and doing to our own benefit are enormous, right? I mean- Sure... it's... 1:18:11 Again, it's the open secret is not how bad things have gotten, but how good they can get. Um- Right... 1:18:16 and so I think, you know, trying to center ourselves emotionally or, you know, spiritually if people come at things that way, in that idea, what's opening up? How good can things get? 1:18:26 And how can I be an agent in bringing that on? Um, I think, I think that's an important thing to do, and, uh, changes how you look at life. It makes things... 1:18:36 It, it creates a source of, of positive energy and a place to put your love, you know? Yeah. I'm fully with that. I mean, you know, one of our biggest things is, is, is it is, um, it is 1:18:48 at, at the very least ineffective to take action without as much context as you can garner that's both reputable and informed and, and worldly and, and empathetic certainly. Um, and I, and I hope this conversation... 1:19:00 And I love your newsletter and your podcast. I'm a big fan, and I've learned so much from you over the years. Thank you. Um, so I can't wait for the book. But, so can't recommend that enough. 1:19:07 But it, it does matter, folks, and, and setting your expectations, if nothing else, 1:19:13 um, even if that expectation is to expect change, uh, at every turn, and often we won't be able to understand it, at least at the beginning, um, is, is necessary. 1:19:24 But like you said-We won't just build these new orderly things. We have an opportunity to do things that we've just never done before. Mm-hmm. You know? We have never done immigration right. 1:19:35 We have never done power right. We've never done these things. 1:19:38 And I-- And, and when I say right, I mean in a just way, in a way that is all-inclusive, where, you know, water and air and, and shelter and food [chuckles] are-- those are table stakes. Doesn't matter. 1:19:50 That's what we do. We, we don't do that in any way anywhere, and we can start with those. Mm-hmm. 1:19:55 Um, but we have to acknowledge they're gonna be more challenged than they ever have before in ways we can never comprehend again. Yeah. 1:20:01 Um, but it is our job, like you said, of this generation to, to begin to change the thinking for folks, for ourselves, and for everyone else, so that we can take those on in the most effective way we can. Exactly. Yeah. 1:20:12 Um, I know you gotta get out of here. I, I really appreciate it, man. Thank you so much. Absolutely. Thanks for having me on, man. 1:20:18 It's, it's, it's really great, and, um, I really appreciate the, the support and the encouragement, um, that you've, that you've shown, and, you know, let's, let's keep in touch. 1:20:26 [upbeat music] Thanks to our incredible guest today, and thanks to all of you for tuning in. 1:20:33 We hope this episode has made your commute or awesome workout or dishwashing or fucking dog-walking late at night that much more pleasant. 1:20:42 As a reminder, please subscribe to our free email newsletter at importantnotimportant.com. It is all the news most vital to our survival as a species. And you can follow us all over the internet. 1:20:53 You can find us on Twitter @importantnotimp. [sighs] Just so weird. Also on Facebook and Instagram @importantnotimportant. Pinterest and Tumblr, the same thing. So check us out, follow us, share us, like us. 1:21:06 You know the deal. And please subscribe to our show wherever you listen to things like this. And if you're really fucking awesome, rate us on Apple Podcasts. Keep the lights on. Thanks. Please. 1:21:15 [chuckles] And you can find the show notes from today right in your little podcast player and at our website, importantnotimportant.com. 1:21:22 Thanks to the very awesome Tim Blaine for our jammin' music, to all of you for listening, and finally, most importantly, to our moms for making us. Have a great day. Thanks, guys. 1:21:34 [upbeat music] That's it for this week's conversation. 1:21:52 For more conversations, scroll back in the feed or visit podcast.importantnotimportant.com to search by name, topic, whatever. Thanks for sharing, thanks for leaving a review, and thanks for giving a shit. 1:22:07 [upbeat music]